360° Coverage : Judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny: Author Dilip D'...

10 Updates
Judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny: Author Dilip D'Souza (Interview)
Photo Credit: RAVEENDRAN, Getty Images

Judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny: Author Dilip D'Souza (Interview)

Dec 30 2012, 1:07am CST | by

New Delhi, Dec 30 (IANS) As India's slow justice system occupies national attention a well known writer says the working of the judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny from lay people.

New Delhi, Dec 30 — As India's slow justice system occupies national attention a well known writer says the working of the judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny from lay people. Author Dilip D...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

1 year ago

Judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny: Author Dilip D'Souza (Interview)

Dec 30 2012, 1:07am CST | by

New Delhi, Dec 30 (IANS) As India's slow justice system occupies national attention a well known writer says the working of the judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny from lay people.

New Delhi, Dec 30 — As India's slow justice system occupies national attention a well known writer says the working of the judiciary must stand up to public scrutiny from lay people.

Author Dilip D'Souza's new book, "The Curious Case of Binayak Sen", examines the questionable life term for sedition awarded to the doctor and human rights activist from Chhattisgarh despite doubts being cast on the evidence against him.

"I didn't set out to build a case defending Sen. My idea was just to examine the case that was built against him and see what I could learn. I firmly believe the working of our judiciary can and must stand public scrutiny from lay people like us; and in fact the greatest respect we can offer our judiciary is such scrutiny. It's in that spirit I started writing this book," D'Souza, a 52-year-old writer from Mumbai, told IANS in an e-mail interview.

Sen, 62, was arrested in May 14, 2007, in Raipur and sentenced to life imprisonment by a Chhattisgarh court Dec 24, 2010, for allegedly supporting and sympathising with Maoists. In April 15, 2011, the Supreme Court released him on bail.

The book, written in simple language, delves into Sen's life-altering training in rural healthcare at Vellore's Christian Medical College, his years treating the poor at a mining area hospital, his commitment to ending malnutrition and the writer's several meetings with Sen. It then logically examines the charge-sheet and evidence against Sen, highlighting the anomalies. He also writes on sedition and dissects the judgment.

Asked if he wanted the weaknesses of evidences as pointed out in the book to help in Sen's case, D'Souza said: "Of course! It surprises me that these weaknesses - and there are more, not in the book - did not figure in his case. It is this weakness of evidence that is the greatest criticism of the case against Sen."

But D'Souza said he does not exactly know the reason behind Sen's arrest. "I can only offer conjectures: his work and criticism stepped on too many toes."

Throughout the book, published by Harper Collins, D'Souza also tries to show how lack of dedicated doctors in rural areas is slowly killing the poor.

"To me, concerns of community or rural healthcare are a fundamental part of Sen's story. They are what made him what he is; they are also part of the process by which Naxalites (Maoists) have come to find such a lot of popular support."

Sen, who heads the Chhattisgarh unit of rights group People's Union for Civil Liberties, was branded a Maoist courier for passing on three letters by jailed Maoist ideologue Narayan Sanyal to businessman Piyush Guha.

Asked if Sanyal and Guha too were wrongly sentenced to life with Sen, D'Souza said: "I haven't examined their cases at all. Perhaps I should, or someone should, and write a book about them."

In the book, he says sedition is misunderstood in India, referring to the Kedarnath vs State of Bihar case. How?

"With sedition, there is the whole issue of freedom of speech, and what the place is for a law like that in a democracy. But Kedarnath made it very clear: to establish a case of sedition under the law, there must be a direct incitement to violence. That is, someone accused of sedition under Section 124 A must be subjected to this test: did they incite violence? If they don't pass it, it's not sedition. It's that simple. I don't believe Sen (and many others accused of sedition) pass that test."

Asked why Sen's lawyers could not see through the apparent flimsiness of evidence, he said: "He had some fabulous lawyers. I don't know why more was not made of all the shoddy evidence presented to court. To me, the evidence alone should have been reason to dismiss the case. Still, better late than never?"

(Sourabh Gupta can be contacted at sourabh.g@ians.in)

IANS

Source: IANS

 
Update
10

6 weeks ago

President gives Away Scope Meritorious Awards to Public Sector Enterprises says our CPSEs have a Vital role in Making India into a Truly World Class Global Manufacturing Hub and we Need to Innovate While Doing Business CPSEs in India have been Syno

Nov 5 2014 4:52am CST | Source: Business Standard

The President of India, Shri Pranab Mukherjee presented the Standing Conference of Public Enterprises (SCOPE) Meritorious Awards today (November 5, 2014) at a function held in Vigyan ...
Source: Business Standard   Full article at: Business Standard
 

 
Update
9

6 weeks ago

President of India presents SCOPE Meritorious Awards

Nov 5 2014 4:52am CST | Source: Business Standard

The President of India, Shri Pranab Mukherjee presented the Standing Conference of Public Enterprises (SCOPE) Meritorious Awards today (November 5, 2014) at a function held in Vigyan Bhawa ...
Source: Business Standard   Full article at: Business Standard
 

 
Update
8

6 weeks ago

Indian finance minister urges CEOs to help build up India’s creaky, outdated infrastructure

Nov 5 2014 4:28am CST | Source: Canadian Business Online

NEW DELHI – India’s finance minister is urging foreign investors to help plug enormous gaps in the country’s infrastructure blamed for holding up growth. Arun Jaitley told international and Indian CEOs that the country was “waiting for you.” He was speaking Wednesday at the opening of the India Economic Summit. Prime Minister Narandra Modi has enchanted Indians with his vision for a country crisscrossed by modern highways and dotted with high-tech smart cities. That’s a far cry f ...
Source: Canadian Business Online   Full article at: Canadian Business Online
 

 
Update
7

6 weeks ago

Indian Markets Scale New Peaks on Reforms Euphoria

Nov 5 2014 3:33am CST | Source: IBTimes UK

Indian investors cheer falling oil prices and New Delhi's intention to further reform Asia's t ...
Source: IBTimes UK   Full article at: IBTimes UK
 

 
Update
6

6 weeks ago

Ashamed to say my children studied abroad: Uday Kotak

Nov 5 2014 2:38am CST | Source: Business Today

Speaking during a session on education at the India Economic Summit in New Delhi, Executive Chairman and Managing Director of Kotak Mahindra Bank Uday Kotak said there are a large number of "schooled" people in the country, but n ...
Source: Business Today   Full article at: Business Today
 

 
Update
5

7 weeks ago

World IP Forum

Nov 3 2014 9:08am CST | Source: Africa Business

About India Conference: Intellectual Professionals LLP is pleased to welcome you to take part in ‘World IP Forum’ which will be held on January 10th -12th, 2015 at Le Meridien, New Delhi. The theme for the conference is “International Challenges and Trends in Intellectual Property “and this three-day conference will ...
Source: Africa Business   Full article at: Africa Business
 

 
Update
4

7 weeks ago

Maruti revamps Alto car to counter slow India recovery

Nov 3 2014 7:51am CST | Source: Reuters India

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Maruti Suzuki, which sells almost one in two cars in India, is betting a new version of its bestselling model will help it retain a stranglehold on the budget market, even as it courts wealthier ...
Source: Reuters India   Full article at: Reuters India
 

 
Update
3

7 weeks ago

Bhopal Gas tragedy: Victims to go on indefinite hunger fast from Nov 10

Nov 3 2014 5:18am CST | Source: Business Standard

The representatives of five organizations of survivors of the Union Carbide disaster in Bhopal on Monday announced their plans of indefinite fast at the Jantar Mantar in New Delhi from November 10 on the issue o ...
Source: Business Standard   Full article at: Business Standard
 

 
Update
2

7 weeks ago

President of India inaugurates ASSOCHAM Summit on livelihood security

Nov 3 2014 4:50am CST | Source: Business Standard

The President of India, Shri Pranab Mukherjee inaugurated a Summit on Livelihood Security: Realizing the vision for 1.3 billion Indians organized by ASSOCHAM at Vigyan Bhawan in New D ...
Source: Business Standard   Full article at: Business Standard
 

 
Update
1

7 weeks ago

Coal India October output beats target for first time in seven months

Nov 3 2014 4:45am CST | Source: Reuters India

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Coal India Ltd's production beat its target in October, the first time in seven months, as the state-owned miner opened a major mine and there were no rain-related ...
Source: Reuters India   Full article at: Reuters India
 

 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/8" rel="author">Luigi Lugmayr</a>
Luigi is the founding Chief Editor of I4U News and brings over 15 years experience in the technology field to the ever evolving and exciting world of gadgets. He started I4U News back in 2000 and evolved it into vibrant technology magazine.
Luigi can be contacted directly at ml@i4u.com. Luigi posts regularly on LuigiMe.com about his experience running I4U.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Russia allows buffalo meat imports from India
Moscow, Dec 4 (IANS/TASS) Russia has allowed imports of buffalo meat from India, the country's veterinary regulator said Thursday.
 
 
New guidelines for prostate cancer testing
Melbourne, Dec 4 (IANS) Prostate cancer checks in Australia are set to improve after cancer agencies and health experts reached an agreement on new testing guidelines at the World Cancer Congress (WCC) currently being held in Melbourne.
 
 
Australian researcher discovers first artwork by early human
Sydney, Dec 4 (IANS) An Australian researcher has discovered what is believed to be the first artwork created by a human.
 
 
Insects compete with rats to clear garbage
New York, Dec 4 (IANS) Insects play a very important role in cleaning up cities and they compete with other pests like rats and pigeons in their endeavour, a study has said.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Australian researcher discovers first artwork by early human
Sydney, Dec 4 (IANS) An Australian researcher has discovered what is believed to be the first artwork created by a human. The simple zigzag pattern found on a fossilized shell from the Indonesian island of Java has...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Insects compete with rats to clear garbage
New York, Dec 4 (IANS) Insects play a very important role in cleaning up cities and they compete with other pests like rats and pigeons in their endeavour, a study has said. Scientists sampled arthropods - such as...
Read more on Business Balla
 
School headmaster shot dead in Pakistan
Islamabad, Dec 4 (IANS) Unidentified gunmen Thursday killed the headmaster of a private school in Pakistan's Balochistan province. Police officials said the armed men opened fire at the vehicle of Zahid Ali,...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Four more bodies recovered from sunken South Korean ship
Seoul, Dec 4 (IANS) Four more bodies were recovered Thursday from a sunken South Korean fishing ship in the Bering Sea, the foreign ministry here said. This increased the toll to 16, including six South Koreans and 10...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Lesbian couple asked to desist in London restaurant
London, Dec 4 (IANS) A lesbian couple in a London restaurant was asked to desist by a staff member, who asked them to "stop what you are doing". Lydia Cawson, 29, said that she and her girlfriend were asked by a staff...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Oxford Dictionaries to add 1,000 new words
London, Dec 4 (IANS) 'Mamil' (middle-aged man in Lycra), 'silvertail' (a person who is socially prominent or who displays social aspirations) and 'crony capitalism' are among the 1,000 new words to be added to...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Oceans play key role in global 'warming hiatus'
London, Dec 4 (IANS) Increased heat uptake across three oceans - North Atlantic, the Southern Ocean and Equatorial Pacific Ocean - is the likely cause of the 'warming hiatus' -- the current decade-long slowdown in...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Novel imaging to identify if TB drugs are working
Washington, Dec 4 (IANS) Tuberculosis patients who are not cured of the infection can develop multi-drug resistant TB and have to take as many as six drugs for two years. Now, researchers at University of Pittsburgh...
Read more on Business Balla
 
PM makes first appointment to High Court of Australia
Canberra, Dec 4 (IANS) Prime Minister Tony Abbott's government Thursday appointed former Victorian Supreme Court judge Geoffrey Nettle as the next Justice of the High Court of Australia. Attorney General George...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
18 suspected militants killed in Pakistan airstrikes
Islamabad, Dec 4 (IANS) At least 18 suspected militants were killed Thursday in airstrikes conducted by Pakistan Air Force fighter jets in North Waziristan. According to officials, the airstrikes were conducted in...
Read more on Politics Balla