360° Coverage : The U.S. Government Wants To Rank Our Colleges. Why?

1 Updates

The U.S. Government Wants To Rank Our Colleges. Why?

Dec 22 2013, 7:36am CST | by

The U.S. Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan, has come up with a plan to produce official government rankings of our universities. The plan was announced this past August, and over the past month,...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

35 weeks ago

The U.S. Government Wants To Rank Our Colleges. Why?

Dec 22 2013, 7:36am CST | by

The U.S. Secretary of EducationArne Duncan, has come up with a plan to produce official government rankings of our universities.

The plan was announced this past August, and over the past month, the Obama administration has been holding public forums around the country to get input about its plan.  But it seems like they’ve already made up their minds.

I hope not.  There are many reasons why this is a truly bad idea.

First of all, we have multiple rankings systems already, including the highly regarded U.S. News  college rankings, which millions of students, faculty, and administrators use every year.  Even though everyone loves to complain about it, U.S. News is pretty darned good: they rank colleges in many categories, by region, by specialty, and more. They also rank graduate programs and professional schools such as law and medicine.

If you don’t like U.S. News, there are several other rankings, including the more recently established World Rankings from Shanghai and The Times Higher Education rankings. These are excellent rankings, well-documented using multiple criteria, and not nearly so US-centric. All these websites are chock-full of useful data about hundreds of universities.

I know, I know: “ratings aren’t rankings” as Ben Miller wrote recently at the Inside Higher Ed site. But I’m not at all confident that the proposed ratings won’t turn into a ranking system, especially with the weight of the federal government behind them.

So we don’t need a federal ranking of universities. That’s the first problem.

Second, this push to create official ratings will inevitably lead to a new bureaucracy within the Education Department, which will then create a constituency that will fight to keep itself in existence. How many staff will Secretary Duncan hire to create these rankings? Dozens? Hundreds?  And how many university employees around the country will then have to be hired to answer whatever questions the government asks?  This seems like it could quickly become a very expensive proposition, running in the tens of millions of dollars annually, or perhaps even more. I haven’t seen any estimate of how much this new system would cost, but I’m betting on a lot. What will we cut from the federal budget to create this new system?

Third, a ranking system will likely spawn a host of unintended consequences, in the form of new requirements that universities will have to satisfy. Why? Well, primarily because federal financial aid to universities will be tied to their ratings. Thus it’s pretty clear that universities will do whatever they can to keep the feds happy. And I’ve no doubt that with a full-time bureaucracy in place, the federal raters will keep moving the goalpost – coming up with new measures that in turn will spur new costs throughout academia. I’m highly skeptical that any of these government metrics will lead to better education.

We’ve already seen what government scorecards do in our public education system. Thanks to the No Child Left Behind program, we now have incessant testing of students, beginning in elementary school, and thousands of hours devoted to teaching students how to take tests rather than learn new material. Schools have not improved as a result. Do we want this trend to creep into colleges too?

I’m not the only one who thinks this a bad idea. Janet Napolitano, the president the University of California system and former Secretary of Homeland Security under President Obama, told the Washington Post that she is “deeply skeptical” of the criteria that a federal ratings bureau would develop.

“It’s not like you’re buying a car or a boat,” said Napolitano.

Secretary of Education Arne Duncan has already criticized the critics of the new rankings system, calling the criticism “premature and a little silly.”  Duncan emphasizes the need to address the alarming number of college students who default on their student loans. This is certainly a problem, but a college ranking (or rating) system is not the solution.

Perhaps the biggest problems with student debt is the rapid rise in mediocre, for-profit online colleges. If the feds want to get the loan problem under control, they should stop funneling money to these Yugos of higher education. As the PBS show Frontline pointed out in 2010, for-profit universities are

 “churning out worthless degrees that leave students with a mountain of debt.”

And they’re not cheap, either - the GAO found that

tuition in 14 out of 15 cases, regardless of degree, was more expensive at the for-profit college than at the closest public colleges.”

So yes, we do have a problem with student debt. One solution would be to exclude truly bad colleges, which are responsible for a disproportionate share of student debt, from federal aid. But that would mean naming the bad apples, who in turn will claim that the government is somehow being unfair. Perhaps the new ratings are an attempt to be fair, but it just makes no sense to rate everyone in order to identify the worst universities. Having a federal government agency produce college rankings is just a bad idea.

Source: Forbes Business

 
Update
1

7 hours ago

MAS posts loss of RM307m for Q2

Aug 28 2014 5:00pm CDT | Source: Business Times Singapore

August 29, 2014 1:13 AMMALAYSIA Airlines (MAS) registered a loss of RM307 million (S$122 million) for the second quarter to end-June, but warned of worse to come in the second half when the "full financial impact of the dou ...
Source: Business Times Singapore   Full article at: Business Times Singapore
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Massive solar flare can damage communications on Earth
New York, Aug 29 (IANS) The most powerful solar flare ever is beginning to rotate to a position directly in line with Earth that, if it hits the ground, can send GPS and communication signals out of gear, the NASA reported.
 
 
Human trials of Ebola vaccine to start next week
Washinton, Aug 29 (IANS) The US government announced Thursday that it will start initial human trials of Ebola vaccine next week.
 
 
4,000 Gaza fishermen go fishing in six-mile area
Gaza, Aug 28 (IANS) As many as 4,000 fishermen in the Gaza Strip Thursday were able to go fishing in a expanded zone, previously restricted to just three miles by Israel, a senior Palestinian official said.
 
 
Number of Ebola cases may reach 20,000: WHO
Geneva, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The number of people infected with the Ebola virus in Western Africa could reach 20,000, six times more than the current estimates, the World Health Organisation (WHO) warned Thursday.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Massive solar flare can damage communications on Earth
New York, Aug 29 (IANS) The most powerful solar flare ever is beginning to rotate to a position directly in line with Earth that, if it hits the ground, can send GPS and communication signals out of gear, the NASA...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Paes-Cara, Bopanna-Katarina advance in US Open mixed doubles
New York, Aug 29 (IANS) India's Leander Paes and his Zimbabwean partner Cara Black, seeded third, along with the sixth seeds Rohan Bopanna and his Slovenian teammate Katarina Srebotnik advanced to the second round of...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Is Philippines mulling an 'anti-selfie' bill?
Manila, Aug 29 (IANS) A bill that seeks to bar taking photos of people without their permission is under intense discussion in the Congress in the Philippines, said Carlos Zarate, a representative from Bayan Muna, the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Volcano erupts in Papua New Guinea
Port Moresby, Aug 29 (IANS) Papua New Guinea Police have warned residents to stay indoors after a volcano erupted Friday. Tavurvur, an active volcano on East Britain Island, erupted at 3.00 a.m., Xinhua reported. The...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
World's longest garland honours Indian spiritual guru in US
New York, Aug 29 (IANS) Over 200 meditation students of Sri Chinmoy from 35 countries, including India, have set a new Guinness world record for the World's longest fresh flower garland to honour the Indian spiritual...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Protest leaders meet Pakistan Army chief
Islamabad, Aug 29 (IANS) Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and Pakistan Awami Tehreek (PAT) leaders Friday met the Army Chief Raheel Sharif to find a solution to end the on-going political crisis in the country. This...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
US Sikhs, lawmakers protest basketball ban on turbans
Washington, Aug 29 (IANS) Two US lawmakers, including the lone Indian-American Congressman, have joined Sikh community groups in protesting the world basketball body FIBA's delay in reviewing the discriminatory policy...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Australian PM to visit India, Malaysia
Sydney, Aug 29 (IANS) Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott announced Friday that he will travel to India and Malaysia next week. On Abbott's first visit to India as prime minister, he said he will visit New Delhi and...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Brazil wants Neymar from Santos: Dunga
Rio de Janeiro, Aug 29 (IANS) Brazil coach Dunga has said he expects Neymar to be fully fit for the Selecao's friendlies against Colombia and Ecuador next month. The 22-year-old missed Barcelona's 3-0 victory over...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Udinese sign Brazilian midfielder Evangelista
Rio de Janeiro, Aug 29 (IANS) Udinese have completed the signing of midfielder Lucas Evangelista from Brazil's Sao Paulo. The 19-year-old was sold to the Italian Serie A outfit for 4,000,000 euros, Xinhua cited from...
Read more on Sport Balla