Eastern Promises: Ukrainian Angst, Russian Influence And Market Reactions

Dec 23 2013, 4:47pm CST | by

Eastern Promises: Ukrainian Angst, Russian Influence And Market Reactions
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

On November 22nd of this year, Ukrainian President, Viktor Yanokovych, backed out of a financial cooperation and support agreement with the European Union. Since that time, large-scale protests in Ukraine’s capital city of Kiev have gained international attention as the country’s 46 million people publicly debate the state of their government and its relationships with Russia and the EU. On December 17th, a deal between Ukraine and Russia was signed giving financial support in the form of Russian purchases of $15 billion of Ukrainian government bonds and significant discounts on Russian natural gas. In essence, Ukraine is deciding which sphere of influence it will be beholden to in the near future – that of “Mother Russia” or a move away from Warsaw Pact times and into greater European dominance of Ukrainian domestic affairs. This has broad implications for Europe, markets, and for the idea of austerity.

The original negotiation between Ukraine and the EU was a way to deal with a sovereign debt problem and general economic malaise in Ukraine. Although Ukrainian debt to GDP ratios look to be reasonable, domestic growth is lacking, industrial and corporate development is non-existent, and wages have not kept up with bouts of inflation. Third quarter GDP fell by 0.4% after having fallen the previous quarter by 0.5%. Forecasts for next year’s growth in the Ukraine are tepid at best with the average of a 1.5% growth rate.

Ukraine has limited foreign reserves on hand and is currently in its third recession in five years which is why Fitch Ratings recently lowered its foreign and local currency debt rating to B- with a negative outlook. With global investors awash in liquidity courtesy of central banks, higher yielding Ukrainian bonds looked attractive as did the Ukrainian stock market. From January 2009 to May 2011 the Ukrainian PFTS stock index gained 250%. However, the Ukraine now has to pay back $15 billion of sovereign debt in the next two years which would be very problematic absent new external liquidity flows or a rescue package.

Enter the Russians to their generous cash! Prior to the Russian deal, Ukraine sought assistance in the form of financing from the EU, just like the European PIGS (Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain). However, the EU’s offered terms came with strict repayment conditions, structural economic reform, and IMF involvement. All of these terms seemed bitter pills for a President and political party that have tended towards their Russian relations and where corporate cronyism between Russian and Ukrainian elites is embedded.

The backdrop to Ukraine’s current plight is geopolitics. Russia desperately wants to exert its control in a westerly direction. Losing Ukraine to further EU influence would certainly hurt Russian pride and would be thought of as an unwanted economic incursion. Russia views western meddling in its geographically closest former Soviet Union countries as interloping which is why Russia masterfully offered Ukraine a bailout program at the last minute. The idea of expanding NATO further east is the one thing that brings disparate Russians to the table in denunciation of the west and EU. In addition, to enjoying Ukraine as the “bread basket” of Eastern Europe and holidays at fine resorts, Russian politicians are worried about Russian domestic unrest especially with the Sochi Olympics approaching and President Putin’s somewhat weaker popularity at home. Preventing unrest in Ukraine from becoming a template for internecine Russian squabbles is tantamount to actually helping an old Soviet ally.

While emerging market investments are obviously fraught with risks, Ukraine is a perfect illustration of the theoretical becoming the actual risk. When Ukrainian GDP was growing or stable (far too infrequently) and the political landscape of Ukraine was more hospitable towards closer relations with Europe, there were logical reasons to own Ukrainian assets. That was especially true of carry trades funded by generous central bank liquidity. Those investment notions of high yield, but “safe” emerging market bonds have been severely eroded by Federal Reserve tapering and in the case of Ukraine, intensely messy domestic politics.

In the last ten days, credit traders have profited handsomely by selling Ukrainian credit default swap protection or buying Ukrainian bonds as the snap-back on prices was dramatic after the Russian agreement was announced. For example, Ukrainian dollar-denominated bonds saw their yields go from more than 15% to less than 9% in a handful of trading sessions. That type of volatility is likely to dissipate as the market re-prices sovereign default risk and traders focus on next steps in Ukrainian politics.

Ukraine is a country with massive agricultural potential. It has a special type of black soil which makes agribusiness efficient and profitable when run on industrial scales. In addition to farming and other agribusiness, Ukraine has tremendous industrial potential and is frequently thought of a type of a type of “Poland in waiting” for further industrial-manufacturing development.

Notwithstanding Ukraine’s potential, it is the political atmosphere including the rule of law, corporate transparency, and electioneering that must change if Ukraine is to attract more emerging market investment managers and greater foreign direct investment. Year to date, Ukrainian stocks are down almost 10% and have returned almost nothing over the past five years. That negative performance indicates investor nervousness about future volatility in financial and real Ukrainian assets.

Until Ukraine aligns itself closer to Europe or until a strong rule of law is established, retail investors are probably wise to avoid Ukrainian financial assets. For large institutions or hedge funds, there may be some justification to owning Ukrainian bonds at these levels as a future deal with the EU, although not imminent, is also not outside of the realm of possibility. To a certain extent, the EU needs Ukraine to “play nicely in the sandbox” with Russia as EU countries nervously receive huge quantities of Russian natural gas through Ukrainian pipelines. The best case scenario for Ukraine is snap elections (not likely), immediately political reform (also not likely) and the implementation of business-friendly and investor-friendly laws (possible). The upside-optionality trade is that Ukrainian politicians will embrace the EU much sooner than consensus believes.

Macro style investors seeking longer term exposure to Eastern Europe, would do well to investigate, Polish real assets instead of trying to thread the economic and political environment of Ukraine. Polish real assets seem moderately attractive, especially if the Polish Zloty strengthens. Alternatively, if investment managers must put money to work in Ukraine, highly liquid and transparent assets should be the first choice, even if they trade at a premium.

Disclaimer: Nothing herein should be relied upon to make an investment decision and nothing herein is intended as investment advice or a recommendation.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

J.P. Turner Goes Paperless with Docupace Technologies
J.P. Turner and Docupace Technologies Partner to Increase Efficiencies and Move toward a Paperless Workflow
 
 
A Celebration of Family Business: 2014 Massachusetts Family Business of the Year Awards Call for Nominations and Entries
Northeastern University Center for Family Business announces a call for nominations for their 8th Annual Massachusetts Family Business of the Year Awards. Applications are due May 1, 2014. The awards program to celebrate and announce the recipients is scheduled for June 11, and will be held at the Henderson House, Weston, MA.
 
 
HVAC Contractor in Dutchess County Stands Apart from Other Local SMBs with Web Site Launch
Local HVAC specialist "Kulk's Plumbing and Heating Inc." partners with the SEO experts at "Prospect Genius" to bring comprehensive home services to Dutchess County, NY and beyond.
 
 
Oliver Wight Sponsor Singapore S&amp;OP Innovation Summit
Oliver Wight Partner, Don Harding will present on Integrated Business Planning, the next evolution of S&OP, at the Singapore S&OP Innovation Summit on 26-27 June 2014.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Health care site flagged in Heartbleed review
WASHINGTON (AP) — People who have accounts on the enrollment website for President Barack Obama's signature health care law are being told to change their passwords following an administration-wide review of the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
The New Role Of Leaders
When Alfred Sloan created the modern corporation at General Motors, he based it on the military.  The company was split into divisions, each with its own leadership.  Information flowed up, orders went down and your...
Read more on Auto Balla
 
Marisa Tomei is too old to play Lady Gaga?
Marisa Tomei thinks she's too old to play Lady Gaga in a movie. The 'The Wrestler' actress was flattered to hear the 'Applause' hitmaker would like her to play the 28-year-old singer if there is ever a film made about...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Hawkeye Technology Improves Time Clock Reporting and Payroll Integration in TimeClick LE 12
Logan, UT, April 18, 2014 --(PR.com)-- Hawkeye Technology, creator of TimeClick, a leading employee time clock software, announces the release of TimeClick version LE 12. This new version offers powerful new reporting...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Airbnb Cofounders Are Billionaires As Share Economy Leader Closes $450 Million Round At $10 Billion Valuation
It took a month, but Airbnb’s founders are confirmed as the share economy’s first billionaires, at least on paper. That’s because the home-sharing site has closed its new fundraising round, raising $450 million at a $10...
Read more on Business Balla
 
`Taxpayers Rely On IRS Guidance At Their Own Peril,' Tax Judge Rules
Before filing your 2013 tax return, did you  consult an Internal Revenue Service publication for clarification of some confusing point? That’s living dangerously. Or so a U.S.  Tax Court Judge declared this week. “...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Predicting The Most Expensive Games Of The 2014 NFL Schedule
Even at the times of little news during the offseason, the NFL keeps fans in anticipation of what might come next. With less than a month until the NFL Draft, the release of the 2014 NFL schedule is expected sooner. For...
Read more on Business Balla
 
How The Wealthiest Families Make And Lose Their Money -- Part 5
In this series of articles on wealth creation and maintenance, we have hit on a few key findings of researchers and practitioners.  The vast majority of family wealth stems from business ownership and not inheritance. ...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Can High-Speed Internet Spark Better-Paying Jobs?
Many of us look at high-speed internet as a way to enjoy pleasures like clearer HDTV and speedier Wi-Fi. But as lightening-fast service gets rolled out in new markets, it could also pave the way to innovation–and new...
Read more on Business Balla
 
For NHL and NBA Playoffs, Parking, Like Tickets, Also Have A Premium
When the Nets and Raptors tip off tomorrow afternoon, the NBA playoffs will be underway.  Along with the NHL playoffs, many think the next two months are the most exciting in all of sports. Over the course of the next...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla