10 Updates
Is College a Sucker Bet?
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

Is College a Sucker Bet?

Dec 23 2013, 4:48pm CST | by

I’m proud to say that I’m the father of highly accomplished identical twin high school senior daughters, and like their friends and more than three million other 12 th graders around the nation ,...

Filed under: news


31 weeks ago

Is College a Sucker Bet?

Dec 23 2013, 4:48pm CST | by

I’m proud to say that I’m the father of highly accomplished identical twin high school senior daughters, and like their friends and more than three million other 12 th graders around the nation , they’ve just experienced the first wave of this year’s college acceptances and rejections. But the one question I’ve been wondering about as they await subsequent communiques from all the wonderful public and private institutions to which they’ve applied, is this: Is college a sucker bet ?

I’m worried that it just might be for a lot of kids and their parents. That’s because in this radically changing economic era we’ve entered – an Economic Revolution, I firmly believe , driven by near-infinite information flows and as profound in scope and scale as the Industrial Revolution before it – a traditionally structured college education looks increasingly like an anachronism.

And a damn expensive anachronism at that. A world of Internet-enabled, omnipresent information is attacking some of the core advantages that a college education has traditionally provided for graduates, sapping its economic horsepower even as its cost soars.

Correlation Is Not Causality

But wait, you say – all the studies!

Any challenge to the notion that Americans must have college degrees to earn higher incomes is typically met with an immediate fusillade of evidentiary studies which show that those with college degrees now have a bigger income advantage over those without than ever before. And factually, that is true, although the differential actually retreated in a recent study .

But as any study-wielding social science or education academician very well knows, causation is not causality. Just because statistics show that those with a degree earn more than those without doesn’t mean the acquisition of a college degree causes the difference.

It just means there’s a correlation. Similar correlations no doubt exist between higher earning power and higher intelligence, higher earning power and growing up in a higher income household, higher earning power and higher work effort, and so on.

That’s just to say that the idea that a college education guarantees you a higher income – or anything else, other than a large tab that someone’s got to pick up – is a fallacy.

Unsurprisingly, not many academic institutions have any interest in deconstructing income/education mythology that benefits their current business model. Also not surprisingly, not many politicians or lobbyists sit around DC hotel lobbies dreaming up programs that encourage Americans to work longer hours or take more entrepreneurial risks — but they’re happily introduce bill after bill to expand funding for college education. So the train rolls on.

A College Degree’s Sources Of Economic Advantage Are Diminishing/>/>

College degrees have historically held two sources of economic value: One was how much more the degree enabled you to contribute economically based on what you learned during the years  you were acquiring it. (Years which currently cost about $41,000 each at the typical U.S. private college. )

The second source of economic value was the signaling value of the degree itself: If you’re a graduate of Dartmouth, the reasoning went, you must be a lot smarter than the average bear, and you really must be a lot smarter than the average bear without a college degree.

Studies have indicated that this signaling value has been worth a lot particularly since U.S. employers are blocked on anti-discrimination grounds from giving any kind of IQ tests to job applicants . In a world of limited, imperfect information about prospective employees, employers could at least use the “brand” of your university to suggest how intelligent and capable you were likely to be as a member of their team.

So armed with only aptitude tests and a reasonably well-accepted, US News & World Report sort of hierarchy of college selectivity , there was a certain logic that drove the value of college degrees:  Yale grad must be smarter than University of Oklahoma grad, who in turn must be smarter than Red Rocks Community College grad, who in turn must be smarter than high school grad, who in turn must be smarter than high school dropout.

The mad scramble by kids and their parents to get the kids into top colleges has therefore traditionally offered some pretty solid economic justification. In a non-transparent world, something that stood for the unknowable – The Ivy-League-degree-as-answer to the question of “How good IS this job candidate, really?” – was worth a lot.

But as the available information about each of us becomes more and more easily accessible and evident, a “magic box” that stood for how smart you are becomes less and relevant. If I can use the Web and social media to find out everything there is to know about you – what you’re good at, what you know a lot about, where you’ve worked, what you’ve accomplished, what your friends and colleagues and former bosses say and think about you, what certifications you have, and objective measures of how smart you are – I really don’t give two flips, as an employer, about your college degree.

So for instance, let’s Google (NASDAQ: GOOG) you. I learn a whole lot in a snap. You were an athlete. You were in a play. You wrote a brilliant Tumblr post about baseball statistics. You made an impassioned speech before your city council when they were trying to sell off your childhood baseball diamond for development.

Now let me check your Facebook (NASDAQ: FB) profile. You smile a lot and seem like you come from a great family and your sister’s a NASA astronaut. You’re still close to your grandmother and visit her in the nursing home often. You’re a gamer. You post funny videos. You have a black Lab.

Now let’s check your LinkedIn (NYSE: LNKD) profile. You’ve had a lot of responsibility for your age. You’re commendably endorsed by a former boss for some of the specific skill sets we’re seeking. You know a lot of the same people I know. You were employee of the year at Baskin Robbins and got very high compliments from your summer internship supervisor at Google.

Or else…you didn’t do or get any of that, which also tells me a lot. Or else you weren’t smart enough to make sure your accomplishments and talents are all out there for people like me to see, which makes me wonder, in this increasingly intensively recorded world, if you’re a lightweight, a Luddite, or some kind of anti-social troll. Do I want to hire someone that leaves no footprints?

The upshot? The more a prospective employer knows about who you really are, the less they’re going to care about what your $165,000 piece of paper suggests you are. When reality becomes more transparent, signaling mechanisms lose their value. It’s like having a satellite weather map versus the outcome of this year’s Groundhog Day.

So What Should A Bright Kid Do?

As with so many of our economy’s Industrial Age customs and practices, the transition from what has been to what comes next isn’t guaranteed to be smooth or orderly. Road maps that worked to guide our lives through a few centuries of one type of economic order won’t necessarily help much as we transition into this next information-saturated one.

There’s a good playbook for any kind of journey into uncertainty, though, and it’s definitely applicable here for any student facing the dilemma of preparing themselves to benefit from the whirlwind changes of an Economic Revolution:

  1. Recognize that something very different – and therefore uncertain – is happening in our economy, and that simply following traditional paths is unlikely to yield good results.
  2. Do the hard work of getting smart about the forces driving the economic change, and draw your own conclusions about where those forces are likely to take us.
  3. Figure out what mix of experiences, relationships, resources and credentials will best equip you for the journey, and create an intentional plan to acquire what you need, balanced by the time and cost of obtaining them.
  4. Take action and make it happen. If you’ve made some wrong calculations about what’s happening and the direction you’re personally heading, you’ll figure it out much faster through action than inaction. And like a hockey player turning sharply on the ice, you can use your momentum to swing quickly into action on a different vector.

So Is College A Sucker Bet?

From an economic standpoint, I’m afraid the answer for far too many young Americans is: Yes. The game is rigged, and not in your favor. You’re paying an incredibly inflated amount of money to acquire skills that can be had much less expensively, and the signaling value of the degree you’ll get is deflating like a jumpy castle when the birthday party’s ended.

My own sense is that there are growing returns to risk-taking and entrepreneurship, and diminishing returns to following old rules of how to get ahead. When I was a 17 year old college freshman in 1980, I concluded that I had made a bad decision in selecting an expensive, exclusive private school just two weeks into orientation. I packed my bags and decamped for my hometown state university, bulked up my course load, and blew threw an economics degree in three years for very little money.

The flexibility that having very little student debt afforded me changed my life – and flexibility is one of the very most important attributes anyone can have in a time of revolutionary change.

A conversation I had with a friend about that series of events the other day illustrates the dilemma. By going to school on the cheap, staying for summer classes and taking an extra course load, I got a degree in 1983 that cost me a grand total of about $10,000. My first job, at the local NBC TV station selling advertising, paid me about $20,000. Ratio of first job salary to college expense: 2-1.

My friend, about a decade younger, said he paid a total of about $100,000 for college and got a first job paying about $50,000. His ratio: 1-2.

How about yours? You’re going to peel off a cool $165,000. First job, if you’re lucky, still at about $50,000? Your ratio: 1-3.3.

Sure, everybody’s circumstances (and numbers) are different. But the back-of-the-envelope calculations aren’t looking too good, and they’re certainly heading in the wrong direction.

I don’t have a magic bullet or an easy answer. Silicon Valley’s Peter Thiel believes so strongly that the old rules are wrong that he’s paying 20 of the best and brightest a year to skip college in favor of a hands-on technology entrepreneurial education . What I do have is a very, very strong sense that the game has changed profoundly. The emperor may not be naked yet, but he is certainly walking around in just his tighty whities.

Good luck in this time of very difficult decision making. I feel your – and my girls’ – pain. But take charge of your future by observing, thinking, and acting on your own. Old roadmaps can lead to big trouble when the road ahead has changed and the travelers aren’t paying close attention.

Dave Maney has an economics degree from SUNY-Binghamton and an MBA from Stanford, so it’s easy for him to say, isn’t it? He is the Founder/CEO of Deke Digital LLC and can be found on Twitter and Google+.

Source: Forbes Business


7 weeks ago

RM47mil KWSG contributions still unclaimed

Jun 9 2014 7:54am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: About RM47 million of contributions in the Teachers Provident Fund (KWSG) still remain unclaimed, the Dewan Rakyat was told ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Gold shop lost almost RM1mil

Jun 9 2014 3:50am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KANGAR: A gold shop owner lost almost RM1 million after after the safe on in his shop was brok ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Motion to debate MAS losses in Dewan Rakyat rejected

Jun 9 2014 3:39am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: AN emergency motion to debate the losses incurred by Malaysia Airlines last year, amounting to RM1.2 billion was rej ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

MH370 Tragedy: Hisham: RM27.6 mil spent on 1st phase of SAR

Jun 9 2014 2:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia spent some RM27.6 million in its first phase of the search operations for missing Malaysia Airline flight MH370, said Acting Transport Minister, Datuk Seri Hish ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

9.1m litres of diesel seized in a month

Jun 8 2014 1:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PUTRAJAYA: The Domestic Trade, Cooperatives, and Consumerism ministry has seized some 9.1 million litres of diesel and property worth RM58 million since mounting ‘Operasi Diesel Selatan’ in the southern st ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Girl, 9, awarded RM2.78m compensation for medical negligence

Jun 6 2014 4:56am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: A nine-year-old girl who suffered brain damage during her birth at a government hospital was awarded over RM2.78 m ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Malaysia's total trade in April up 12pc

Jun 5 2014 11:52pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's total trade in April 2014 rose by 12 per cent from a year ago to RM123.86 billion due to growing trading activities, International Trade and Industry Minister Datuk Seri Mustapa Mohamed s ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Works Ministry to spend RM20m for upgrading works at 50 accident black spots

Jun 4 2014 11:35pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

JOHOR BARU: The Works Ministry will implement upgrading works at 50 accident prone locations in the country that have been identified this year involving ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Najib launches loan scheme for Ramadan traders

Jun 4 2014 10:24pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PUTRAJAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak today launches RM45 million Ramadan ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


7 weeks ago

Residents bring up objection against Kidex to Suhakam

Jun 4 2014 4:49am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PETALING JAYA: A group of 20 Petaling Jaya residents held a meeting with the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) over their objection against the proposed RM2.2 billion Kinrara Damansar ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

EU to impose more restrictive measures against Russia
Brussels, July 30 (IANS) The European Union (EU) has agreed a package of "significant" additional restrictive measures targeting sectoral cooperation and exchanges with Russia, the European Council said in a statement Tuesday.
Green spaces impact birth weight positively
London, July 29 (IANS) Where expecting mothers live can also have a bearing on the birth weight of their babies as researchers have found that mothers who live near green spaces deliver babies with significantly higher birth weights.
What makes you a pessimist?
London, July 29 (IANS) Cannot see thing turning out to be all right? A hyperactive habenula, half the size of a pea in the brain that tracks predictions about negative events, could be the key, a study suggests.
Russian space 'sex geckos' are safe for now
Moscow, July 29 (IANS) There is good news for the geckos aboard the Russian Foton-M4 space satellite meant to study the effects of microgravity on sex and reproduction.

Latest from the Network

Former Libyan deputy PM kidnapped in Tripoli
Tripoli, July 30 (IANS) Unidentified gunmen Tuesday kidnapped Libya's former deputy prime minister Mustafa Abu Shagor, a parliamentarian confirmed. The gunmen forced Abu Shagor into a car near his house in Tripoli's...
Read more on Politics Balla
'Russian forces continue to mass along border with Ukraine'
Washington, July 30 (IANS) Russian military forces continue to gather on Ukraine's southeast border, and Moscow continues to funnel heavy equipment to Russian-backed separatists in Ukraine, a Pentagon spokesperson said...
Read more on Politics Balla
'Israel did not request US for ceasefire in Gaza'
Jerusalem, July 30 (IANS) Senior Israeli officials Tuesday denied US Secretary of State John Kerry's claim that Israel had requested the US to extend a humanitarian ceasefire in Gaza. "Kerry was the one who brought...
Read more on Politics Balla
Douglas-Zeta-Jones open up about cancer battle
Los Angeles, July 30 (IANS) Actor Michael Douglas and his wife Catherine Zeta-Jones are opening up again about the former's battle with throat cancer. The 69-year-old actor got candid while talking about being mis-...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Russian airport evacuated after bomb scare
St.Petersburg, July 30 (IANS) An airport in Russia's northern capital of St. Petersburg was briefly evacuated Tuesday following a bomb threat. However, no suspicious object was found. A total of nine flights were held...
Read more on Politics Balla
Lithuania to ban a few Russians' entry
Vilnius, July 30 (IANS) Lithuanian authorities will ban a few Russian citizens from entering the Baltic country in the wake of prevailing international context and conflicts in Ukraine, a diplomat said Tuesday....
Read more on Politics Balla
Adele takes vacation before album release
Los Angeles, July 30 (IANS) Singer Adele has rented a villa in Ibiza, Spain for a relaxing holiday before she starts promoting her new album. The 26-year-old singer plans to spend a month travelling back and forth...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Zac Efron was 'going crazy' before rehab
Zac Efron admits he was ''going crazy'' at home before seeking help in rehab. The 'That Awkward Moment' star, who sought treatment for an alleged cocaine addiction twice last year, says he realized he had a problem when...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Kanye West wants to put baby plans on ice
Kanye West wants to put his plans to have a second child with Kim Kardashian on ice. The 'New Slaves' hitmaker, who has 13-month-old daughter North with the reality TV star, is reportedly stressed out by his wife's...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Hayden Panettiere will be 'an amazing mother'
Hayden Panettiere's fiancé Wladimir Klitschko thinks she's going to be ''an amazing mother.'' The heavyweight professional boxer, 38, is thrilled the 'Nashville' actress, 24, is expecting their first child and is...
Read more on Celebrity Balla