Why "Starchitects" Should Leave Santa Monica's Skyline Alone

Dec 28 2013, 12:07am CST | by

Why "Starchitects" Should Leave Santa Monica's Skyline Alone
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

If the building gods have their way, the ocean views in Los Angeles may soon be overshadowed by towers of swirling steel and glass. A string of high-profile architecture proposals by Rem Koolhaus, Frank Gehry and Cesar Pelli (designer of Kuala Lumpur’s Petronas Towers) have been batted around lately as part of a “revitalization” effort in Santa Monica. Some projects scored approval, others didn’t. But the idea is the same: Each envisions massive construction aimed at luring hoards of international visitors and Angelenos to the famously low-key neighborhood.

At the risk of sounding like a fusty old crank, I’d rather not see the changes go forward as planned. Santa Monica’s allure has always been its absence of glitz. In many ways, it’s the un-Beverly Hills. Surfers and A-list screenwriters mix and mingle without fuss on Main Street, and even glamor girls know to ditch their Birkin bags for canvas totes at the iconic Wednesday and Saturday farmer’s markets off Third Street Promenade. SaMo is super wealthy, for sure, but it is wealth that errs on the side of modesty and moderation. Showing off status might mean absentmindedly flashing your Google employee laminate or perhaps plugging your electric vehicle into one of the new publicly-accessible EV charging stations at Santa Monica Place Mall or the Pier.

But here’s what the city’s Planning Commission has in mind for the beach town’s future. Let’s start with Gehry. He’s a son of Santa Monica, so I get it. The bungalow residence he designed with corrugated steel and chain link on 22nd Street is a local landmark, and it’s been 35 years since his most notable design there — Santa Monica Place, which was torn down and redeveloped several years back.

The new Ocean Avenue Project is based around a 22-storey, 244-foot tall hotel with a mirrored white facade on nearly two acres to include retail and restaurants, an art museum, observation decks and a deep parking garage.

The designs are typical Gehry: swirly and mesmerizingly beautiful. But the project brings major density, scale and what some have called “Manhattanization” to the ocean front. Currently, there’s a four-storey limit on new buildings in downtown Santa Monica (this one got a workaround by adding public art spaces and parking). And while there’s nothing wrong with a bit of skinny vertical (can you ever be too rich or too thin?), I worry this could be a gateway to a bigger-is-better mindset in a place where building size hasn’t mattered much — mainly because Santa Monica residents never let size get out of hand.

That’s why people gasped a little when the city approved Cesar Pelli — designer of the 1,500-foot-tall Petronas Towers in Malaysia, once the tallest structures in the world — for an ambitious makeover of the 86-year-old Fairmont Miramar hotel at the end of Wilshire Boulevard. The Argentina native, best known locally for the monumental Pacific Design Center, has plans for three new buildings built around a tower that rises more than 300 feet over Ocean Ave.

Residents weren’t happy with the proposal. A meeting at Civic Auditorium went on for five hours as locals voiced concerns about everything from clogged traffic to “the selling of the sky” over Santa Monica. With this and other mega-projects suddenly on the town’s radar, one resident stepped to the mike to say his town is taking a “Jackson Pollock approach to development.”

More is definitely more in the proposal Rem Koolhaus’s firm submitted this year, which may explain why it got shot down at the 11th hour. It’s not that I’m not a Koolhaus fan. Seattle’s Library is one of the most arresting buildings I’ve ever seen, inside and out. But it worried me to think about a 400,000-square-foot town plaza under a 225-room  hotel, chockablock with restaurants, shops and parking for more than 1,200. Even without the construction nightmare to come from all this, Santa Monica is already too busy with cars most afternoons and weekends.

The World's Tallest Residential Towers

The Koolhaus build was full steam ahead last July after beating out a rival proposal by the firm of Robert A.M. Stern. But then in August, the city of Santa Monica changed its mind. Voting 5 to 1 to oppose the project, the city council shot down the mixed-use structure with a curious statement from Santa Monica’s mayor, Gleam Davis, who said, “It may be the most perfect project on this site. But does that make it the right project?”

Developers went back to the drawing board and Santa Monica got a much-needed time out. No doubt, a massive building project will emerge again. It’s simply a matter of addressing issues like public access to open space and the amount of affordable housing. Or maybe there’s a chance that the old Santa Monica spirit will prevail as people declare that bigger isn’t necessarily better and that saying no is as important a development for this laid back beach community as anything these starchitects might dream up.

What’s your opinion? Am I just being a stick-in-the-sand?

Follow me at @davidhochman or @letterfromla

Source: Forbes Business


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Bangladesh pushes for working South Asian free trade deal
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina Wednesday called for implementing the free trade agreement (FTA) that the Saarc nations signed nearly a decade ago.
NASA floats airship challenge idea
Washington, Nov 26 (IANS) The US space agency NASA is planning to kickstart a challenge for developing airships that can break records in terms of duration of flight at high altitudes.
OPEC daily basket price closes lower
Vienna, Nov 26 (IANS/WAM) The basket of 12 crude oils of the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) closed over a dollar lower at $74.28 a barrel Tuesday compared to $75.70 Monday, the OPEC Secretariat said.
Early deafness diagnosis improves teenagers' reading skills
London, Nov 26 (IANS) Early detection of deafness in babies is linked to better reading skills later in their lives, says a new research.

Latest from the Network

86 protesters arrested in Hong Kong
Hong Kong, Nov 26 (IANS/EFE) At least 86 people were arrested and over a dozen injured in Hong Kong Wednesday in clashes between the police and pro-democracy protesters during the clearing of a protest site in Mong Kok...
Read more on Politics Balla
Mexico plans policy changes to stem violence, graft
Mexico City, Nov 26 (IANS/EFE) The Mexican government plans to rework its internal security policy to check the violence and corruption that prevails after 43 students in police custody went missing, outraging the...
Read more on Politics Balla
NASA floats airship challenge idea
Washington, Nov 26 (IANS) The US space agency NASA is planning to kickstart a challenge for developing airships that can break records in terms of duration of flight at high altitudes. The idea behind the "20-20-20...
Read more on Business Balla
Benedict Cumberbatch disappointed to miss McGrath
Benedict Cumberbatch says it was a ''tragedy'' to not record 'Penguins of Madagascar' with Tom McGrath. The 38-year-old actor couldn't work opposite his co-star Tom due to their conflicting schedules, which forced them...
Read more on Movie Balla
Ridley Scott won't direct Blade Runner sequel
Ridley Scott won't be directing the 'Blade Runner' sequel. The 76-year-old director - who helmed the original sci-fi thriller in 1982 - has confessed he will not be returning to the director's chair for the follow up...
Read more on Movie Balla
OPEC daily basket price closes lower
Vienna, Nov 26 (IANS/WAM) The basket of 12 crude oils of the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) closed over a dollar lower at $74.28 a barrel Tuesday compared to $75.70 Monday, the OPEC Secretariat...
Read more on Business Balla
Two JMB activists awarded death sentence in Bangladesh
Dhaka, Nov 26 (IANS) A court in Dhaka sentenced two activists of the militant Jamaat-ul-Mujahideen Bangladesh (JMB) to death Wednesday, for shooting dead a police informant during a search operation nearly eight years...
Read more on Politics Balla
Tough competition in 2015 Copa America: Uruguay FA president
Montevideo, Nov 26 (IANS) The 2015 Copa America championship, to be held in Chile next summer, is gearing up to be a tough tournament to win, Uruguay's top football official has said. According to the president of the...
Read more on Sport Balla
Bayern dominated despite being down to 10: Guardiola
Manchester, Nov 26 (IANS) Bayern Munich coach Pep Guardiola said that his team dominated the game despite being down to 10 in the Champions League match against England's Manchester City. "Even though we lost, I am...
Read more on Sport Balla
We made mistakes: Bayern's Dante
Manchester, Nov 26 (IANS) Bayern Munich defender Dante believes that Manchester City forward Sergio Aguero is a great player but Bayern should blame the Champions League loss on themselves. Bayern lost 2-3 to...
Read more on Sport Balla