Tax Pet Food? Even Amazon Can't Define It

Jan 2 2014, 8:38am CST | by

Tax Pet Food? Even Amazon Can't Define It
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

New Year’s Day launched the 16% pet food tax in Mexico. Half of Mexican households have pets, and low income earners are expected to be hit especially hard. Food for horses, a pet of the elite, isn’t taxed, though that’s ostensibly because they are classed as livestock by the new law.

Americans have been taxing pet food for years, though in most states, sales tax doesn’t apply to human food. Pet food is taxed in America, but not uncooked human food. Restaurant meals and prepared takeout? Usually taxed. Keeping track of many arcane rules about what’s taxed and what isn’t can be daunting (one argument against Amazon taxes online) and leads to scary disputes.

In California, one mom and pop wholesale produce seller sold only produce. Strictly wholesale, the company delivered fruits and vegetables to city schools, hospitals, and the zoo. Aha, the zoo is a problem, said sales tax auditors. They slapped the produce seller with a crippling bill for back taxes on produce delivered to the zoo.

This produce was consumed by animals and that made the sales taxable, the state said. What’s more, because this produce company never filed sales tax returns (selling only nontaxable produce, why would it?), 8 years of taxes were due. Only 3 years would have been fair game if the company had been filing returns.

One possible way out was that the zoo had snack bars and cafeterias where produce was eaten by humans. But the wholesaler couldn’t show which carrots and bananas were consumed by people and which by animals. How could it when it just delivered the produce? So the state said it was all taxable.

Eight years of taxes, penalties and interest would wipe out the family business. So after efforts to compromise with auditors failed—this was in California after all—they went to a formal hearing before California’s five member Board of Equalization. Given the human (and animal?) interest, the produce seller invited the press.

Did you know that if you tell a supermarket checker you’re buying broccoli for your dog, the store has no way to charge you sales tax? Plus, if an animal is suitable for human consumption, the food it eats isn’t taxable. So, produce eaten by primates was taxable, but not produce eaten by goats and sheep?

Hey, some people eat snake, turtle, and game animals. Was this law cultural discrimination? “I’ve eaten snake,” admitted one of the five judges. Examples showed the law to be riven by contradictions.

That made the state’s position seem arbitrary. The press thought so too. As for the five-member Board, it looked increasingly uncomfortable about putting this mom and pop produce seller out of business. It lead to a speedy verdict for mom and pop.

Some pet owners take on the tax man too. One big pet tax victory was the Oakland, California Cat Lady who beat the IRS in a cat fight. Her tax decision said she could claim the cost of vet bills and cat food as charitable contribution deductions. Some people focus on business deductions instead.

In Seawright v. Commissioner, a married couple running a junkyard put out food to attract wild cats. The feral cats they attracted dealt with snakes and rats on the property. They made for a safer junkyard for customers, and that made cat food a business expense.

Sometimes, tax law seems to be going to the dogs.

You can reach me at This discussion is not intended as legal advice, and cannot be relied upon for any purpose without the services of a qualified professional.

Source: Forbes Business


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Add spices and herbs in food for super health
Washington, Oct 29 (IANS) Spices and herbs not only offer a zingy flavour to your food, they can also improve your health by helping to reduce sodium, calorie and fat intake, finds research.
High milk intake may lead to early death: Study
London, Oct 29 (IANS) Instead of strengthening your bones, drinking more than three glasses of milk a day may increase the risk of early death, a study has found.
UN to help Myanmar move out of least developed countries
Yangon, Oct 29 (IANS) The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) vowed to provide technical assistance to Myanmar to help lift it out of the least developed countries (LDC) list, the president's office said Wednesday.
Black tea, citrus fruits lower ovarian cancer risk
London, Oct 29 (IANS) Having black tea and citrus fruits daily - and red wine occasionally - may lower the risk of developing ovarian cancer, research shows.

Latest from the Network

Chloe Grace Moretz: I'm a geek
Chloe Grace Moretz is a ''geek'' when she's at home. The 17-year-old actress - who can be seen playing a prostitute alongside Denzel Washington in new action thriller film 'The Equalizer' - insists she lives a pretty...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
High powered MRI scans identify language centres in brain
Vienna, Oct 29 (IANS) A study from the Medical University of Vienna found how 7-Tesla ultra high-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) could be used to clearly show the brain areas responsible for speech processing...
Read more on Business Balla
Timothy Spall sees 'certain parallels' with William Turner
Timothy Spall sees ''certain parallels'' between himself and William Turner. Spall, 57, plays the influential painter in his new film 'Mr. Turner', for which he won the Best Actor award at the Cannes Film Festival, and...
Read more on Movie Balla
Trinidad cricket board condemns Windies players pull out
Port-of-Spain, Oct 29 (IANS/CMC) The Trinidad and Tobago Cricket Board (TTCB) has condemned the recent decision by the West Indies cricketers to abort their tour of India. The condemnation came in the form of a motion...
Read more on Sport Balla
Binge drinking hampers memory in long run
Washington, Oct 29 (IANS) High doses of alcohol during adolescence may continue to affect the brain even after drinking stops, leading to structural changes in the brain and memory deficits, says a significant study....
Read more on Celebrity Balla
EU: inspiring innovation through 3D-printed robot
Brussels, Oct 29 (IANS) The European Union (EU) said that it has a 3D-printed robot ready to be introduced in schools to cultivate the creativity of students studying mechanics, computer sciences, electronics and 3D...
Read more on Politics Balla
'Confident West Indies will appear in 2015 World Cup'
Sydney, Oct 29 (IANS/CMC) John Harden, 2015 Cricket World Cup chief executive, has said he is confident that the former champions West Indies will appear at next year's event in Australia and New Zealand. Harden...
Read more on Sport Balla
NASA cargo spacecraft explodes minutes after launch
Washington, Oct 29 (IANS) In a shocking incident, an unmanned commercial rocket carrying crucial scientific cargo for the International Space Station (ISS) exploded moments after lift-off Tuesday evening. Orbital...
Read more on Politics Balla
Sleep disturbances linked to higher Alzheimer's risk in men
London, Oct 29 (IANS) Elderly men with self-reported sleep disturbances run a higher risk of developing Alzheimer's disease than men without self-reported sleep disturbances, says a study. "We demonstrate that men...
Read more on Business Balla
Champ Bailey Retires From the NFL
Former Denver Broncos cornerback Champ Bailey retired from the NFL on Oct. 28.Bailey ends his career as one of the top shutdown cornerbacks in league history, per Ben Swanson of the Broncos' official website:"Longtime...
Read more on Sport Balla