Embattled Gasket Maker Sues Asbestos Lawyers For Fraud

Jan 10 2014, 10:41am CST | by

Embattled Gasket Maker Sues Asbestos Lawyers For Fraud

Gasket manufacturer Garlock Technologies has sued four law firms for fraud as it awaits a bankruptcy judge’s decision on how much money the company must set aside to settle thousands of asbestos claims against it.

Garlock, a division of EnPro Industries, entered bankruptcy in 2010 after its cost of settling asbestos suits skyrocketed from $5,000 per claim past $70,000, in a familiar cycle as other defendants went bankrupt and lawyers escalated their demands against the few remaining solvent manufacturers. Garlock says it owes plaintiffs nothing because its products contained small amounts of a less dangerous form of asbestos; plaintiff lawyers have suggested the firm owes $1.4 billion.

Garlock contends it is the victim of fraudulent claims by plaintiff lawyers who accuse multiple companies of causing their clients’ illness, often with conflicting stories about how their clients got sick. It tried, and failed, to get U.S. Bankruptcy Judge George Hodges in Charlotte, N. Carolina to release client files that it contends would show the fraud. Plaintiff lawyers resisted, saying those files contain confidential medical information.

It filed lawsuits against four prominent asbestos law firms late yesterday, under seal. Those firms are: Belluck & Fox and Shein Law Center in Philadelphia; and Simon Greenstone and Waters & Krause in Dallas. Representatives of those firms weren’t immediately available for comment. The lawsuits, actually adversarial actions in bankruptcy, seek the recovery of money from the firms.

EnPro said yesterday it expects Judge Hodge to release his opinion estimating its liability after 4 p.m. today. EnPro spokesman Don Washington declined comment.

By suing the asbestos lawyers who are suing it, Garlock is following in the steps of CSX, which in 2012 won a $429,000 fraud verdict against Pittsburgh lawyers Robert Peirce and Louis Raimond after uncovering evidence the lawyers had used phony diagnoses from discredited Dr. Ray Harron to fabricate asbestos cases against the railroad. Evidence in that case included internal memos suggesting the lawyers knew Harron was “very, very liberal” with his diagnoses, but, Peirce said in one letter, “even a disputed diagnosis case has some value.”

The lawyers also hired an unlicensed tech to run a mobile X-ray screening program, and let a doctor use an automatic signature stamp to sign medical reports.

It isn’t clear what’s in the complaints Garlock filed under seal, but attorney Samuel Tarry with McGuire Woods in Richmond, who represented CSX, told me fake diagnoses lie at the core of most such cases.

“If we’re going to see more of this litigation it’s because there are unfortunately still doctors who are willing to say whatever lawyers ask them to say,” said Tarry, who declined to comment directly on the CSX case because it is on appeal.

Garlock previously accused another law firm of fraud for making conflicting stories about how its client was exposed to asbestos. Plaintiff lawyers accused the company of trying to game its bankruptcy by disrupting long-settled methods of assessing liability based upon previous court verdicts.

Pursuing law firms for fraud is difficult because plaintiff lawyers try to shield all of their documents under the attorney-client privilege.

“It’s a challenge to prove intent unless you have smoking-gun documents,” Tarry said.

When judges have penetrated that veil, they have found interesting facts. The most important example came when U.S. District Judge Janice Jack demanded the case files for thousands of plaintiffs in silicosis cases and after matching up their Social Security numbers with previous filings found many had already collected payments for asbestosis. Jack, a former nurse, threw out the silicosis cases since the two diseases are virtually never found in the same patient.

Garlock, like other companies, wants to set up a trust to pay future asbestos claims so it can exit reorganization. The dispute with plaintiff lawyers is over how much money should go into that trust.

Asbestos trusts are mostly overseen by plaintiff lawyers and operate in secrecy, making it impossible to match up claims as Judge Jack did to uncover fraud. Solvent companies complain that lawyers target them with suits first, knowing they can later tap the bankruptcy trusts without fear that the trusts will dispute their claims as inconsistent with exposures their clients alleged in suits against the solvent companies. The U.S. House passed a bill last year that would open the trust records but it won’t pass in the Democratic-controlled Senate, where asbestos lawyers are a major source of campaign contributions.

Source: Forbes Business


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

15 Million T-Mobile User Data Stolen on Experian Servers
15 Million T-Mobile User Data Stolen on Experian Servers
Credit monitoring firm Experian has been hacked. Affected are about 15 million T-Mobile Customers. T-Mobile CEO John Legere responds.
Narendra Modi Courts Silicon Valley Companies, Making India the New China
Narendra Modi Courts Silicon Valley Companies, Making India the New China
India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi, is courting the top technology companies in Silicon Valley. On Saturday, Mr. Modi visited Tesla and met Elon Musk. He also had dinner with Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella and Google...
How Can Solar Panels Be Made More Efficient?
How Can Solar Panels Be Made More Efficient?
The unique Kirigami technique can help capture more sunlight as it enables solar panel cells to track the sun throughout the day.
Amazon Christmas 2015 Rumor - Smallest Tablet Ever?
Amazon Christmas 2015 Rumor - Smallest Tablet Ever?
With Labor Day having come and gone, Christmas is starting to roll out into stores and onto the internet - and everyone is trying to get a head start on the competition. Amazon is one of the first to have rumors come...