Net Neutrality Decision: Welcome To The Singles Bar, YouTube

Jan 15 2014, 8:21am CST | by

Net Neutrality Decision: Welcome To The Singles Bar, YouTube

The federal appeals-court decision gutting the Federal Communications Commission’s “net neutrality” rules leaves online content providers like Netflix and Google's YouTube in the position of male patrons at an old-fashioned singles bar. In order to gain access to the network, they may have to pay a cover charge. And that opens the prospect of angry consumers and endless litigation like what has consumed the credit-card industry, as merchants battle Visa, MasterCard and American Express over who should pay for the ubiquitous charge network that everybody benefits from.

In a decision released yesterday, a three-judge panel of the U.S. District Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit held that the Obama administration overstepped its authority when it prohibited broadband providers from blocking or discriminating against certain types of traffic. The decision was hardly the slam-dunk victory some have ascribed to the plaintiff, Verizon: In a thoughtful post at the Volokh Conspiracy, Stuart Benjamin notes that two of the three judges found the FCC still has “virtually unlimited power to regulate the Internet,” in the words of dissenting Judge Laurence Silberman, as a means of insuring broad access and competition.

Still, the decision opens the door for what economists call a two-sided market, where the costs of a useful network fall on the parties most willing to pay for it. The classic example is the singles bar (which may or may not still exist — I’m getting old), where men paid a cover charge to get in and women walked in for free. The women got in for free because they were unwilling to pay a cover charge and the men paid because they wanted to meet the women. Without this allocation of costs, the network would break down and both sides would spend the evening watching “Three’s Company” reruns at home.

Two-sided markets abound. Women often pay more to dry clean a shirt (for them, it’s called a “blouse”) than men because men tend to be dogs who won’t take their clothes to the dry cleaner unless it’s cheap. Investors pay for the dubious value of sell-side research through higher commissions their brokers and mutual-fund managers pass through to them.

Merchants historically have paid most of the cost of the credit-card network because they get most of the benefit. Consumers spend more with credit cards than with cash or checks, and merchants don’t have to mess with fraud and the cost of running their own accounts-receivable departments.

The problem with two-sided markets is they strike many people as unfair. Merchants love the credit-card network, but they look at the 2% or more that is trimmed from their gross receipts, compare it with their 5% margins, and dream of the riches they would have if only they didn’t have to pay for credit transactions. That’s led to some of the most lucrative litigation in history, as lawyers have assembled class actions on behalf of thousands of merchants who say the credit card issuers used their monopoly control of the market to gouge them on fees.

In the latest settlement, Visa and MasterCard would refund $6 billion to merchants and get rid of rules prohibiting surcharges for credit purchases. Big retailers including Wal-Mart and Target object to the settlement, saying it lets the credit-card companies off the hook too easily and will actually cost consumers more; nevertheless a judge approved the settlement in December.

I’ve maintained the key provision of the credit-card settlements, allowing merchants to surcharge for credit purchases, is meaningless since they always had the power to offer discounts for cash. There is absolutely no difference between a discount and a surcharge, despite what plaintiff lawyers and their highly paid economic experts say. But the dispute highlights the difficulties people have in wrestling with two-sided markets. They love the network, but they hate the idea of having to pay for it. Some merchants apparently think paying for it would be more palatable if they charge the “same price” for everything, but tack on a surcharge for credit purchases. I don’t think consumers are that dumb, but who knows?

So with this decision, the D.C. Circuit may have thrown YouTube and Netflix into the singles bar. Broadband providers can go to the content providers, which consume 50% of North American downstream bandwidth, according to a recent Sandvine report, and demand fees for high-speed, reliable delivery of their content. Netflix could respond by hiking its monthly subscription charge, while Google might have to insert more ads on YouTube, or find other ways to pay to get access to consumers. Consumer advocates and net-neutrality fans worry that Comcast, say, will try to discriminate against Netflix, which is making inroads as consumers dump conventional bundled cable-TV for Internet video on demand. Others say the broadband providers can’t risk angering their customers with such tactics.

There’s nothing new about this sort of conflict and market evolution. The North American natural gas market was heavily regulated until the 1980s, including price controls on gas at the wellhead. The result was disastrous gas shortages, as drillers had little incentive to produce more, as well as inadequate pipeline capacity. Congress eliminated price controls at the wellhead in 1989 and later ordered pipeline companies to unbundle their services, providing regulated transport as one service and selling the actual gas molecules on the deregulated market. The result was a flourishing gas business, technical innovation that produced the shale-gas revolution, and now, a market where North American consumers have at least a 100-year supply of cheap gas for heating, electricity and industrial production.

The price, of course, was a couple of decades of chaos, uncertainty, and financial distress. Enron was born out of deregulation and collapsed; so was Kinder Morgan, which has been a huge success. The costs of the network, instead of being buried inside impenetrable long-term gas contracts and layers of bureaucratic rules, became transparent and fell to whoever was the most willing and able to pay. Those prices were also flexible, to inspire pipeline companies to overbuild their networks. Want the cheapest transport contract possible? Sign up for interruptible delivery, where your supply can be shoved aside for a higher-paying customer. Absolutely, positively need that gas 24 hours a day? Pay more for firm delivery, which of course also means the pipeline company has to set aside extra capacity for when your demand spikes.

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission still maintains control over interstate pipeline rates, which some say is causing bottlenecks in markets where pipeline companies would build larger-diameter lines if they could reap higher rates on those few days a year when demand hits records. But overall, the market functions better with consumers buying their molecules from the people who produce those molecules, and paying the pipeline operators to deliver them.

The broadband market may never get to that stage. It’s hard to imagine consumers getting a variable bill each month based on how many YouTube videos they watched. Even cellphone networks seem to be transitioning to all-you-can-eat data plans, highlighting an important difference between digital content and physical molecules. But the conflict over who pays will continue to simmer in the background. And with this ruling, content providers may find themselves in line outside the bar, waiting to hear what the cover charge is to get access to all those networking possibilities inside.

Watching carefully will be the antitrust lawyers, who need only prove a broadband provider has the power to dictate prices to lodge a lawsuit challenging those fees. Market power will be elusive, of course, if the D.C. Circuit ruling inspires enough broadband providers to expand their networks.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Global entrepreneurship summit boost for SMEs
Marrakech, Nov 22 (IANS) Nine agreements were signed between the Moroccan General Confederation of Enterprises (CGEM) and several small and medium enterprises (SMEs) as well as between major Moroccan banks and start-ups at the 5th Global Entrepreneurship Summit (GES 2014) held in Morocco.
 
 
NASA's flying saucer among 'Best of What's New'
Washington, Nov 22 (IANS) NASA's Low-Density Supersonic Decelerator (LDSD), a spacecraft that aims to facilitate the safe landing of future Mars missions, has earned a place in the the Popular Science magazine's "Best Of What's New" list.
 
 
Indian helping to light up Gambia (Diaspora Feature)
Banjul (Gambia), Nov 22 (IANS) Like many Indians who are proving to be philanthropists around Africa, Ram Mohan has set up a social business called Comafrique Intelizon Initiative and has embarked on the replacement of candles in villages in the Gambia with solar lights from India.
 
 
Leopards in human areas not conflict animals: Study
New Delhi, Nov 22 (IANS) Leopards in human areas are not always "stray" or "conflict" animals but residents with strategies to thrive in human dominated areas, says the first GPS-based study of leopards in India.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Davis Cup final: Switzerland nudges ahead with doubles win
Lille, Nov 23 (IANS/EFE) Superstar Swiss duo of Roger Federer and Stanislas Wawrinka put their country ahead in the Davis Cup final with a 6-3, 7-5, 6-4 victory over the French pair of Richard Gasquet and Julien...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Former police official arrested over students' disappearance in Mexico
Mexico City, Nov 23 (IANS/EFE) A former deputy police chief and suspected member of the Guerreros Unidos ("United Warriors") drug cartel, that allegedly, is involved in the disappearance of 43 students in Mexico...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Iran to allow UN inspectors access to Marivan nuclear site
Tehran, Nov 23 (IANS) Iran decided to allow UN nuclear inspectors access to its Marivan nuclear site, Atomic Energy Organisation of Iran (AEOI) said Saturday. "We are ready to provide a controlled access to the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Kendall Jenner feels she is like Hannah Montana
Los Angeles, Nov 23 (IANS) Model Kendall Jenner, who is seen in a reality TV show "Kourtney and Khloé Take The Hamptons", says she feels "like Hannah Montana" while juggling between fashion and TV. Hannah Montana,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Iran nuclear issue: Kerry holds talks with Gulf foreign ministers
Vienna, Nov 23 (IANS) US Secretary of State John Kerry held talks with the foreign ministers of UAE, Kuwait, Qatar and Bahrain on the Iranian nuclear issue Saturday. Earlier, Kerry delayed his departure from Vienna in...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Professor Green not ready for kids
Professor Green and Millie Mackintosh are not ready to have children. The 30-year-old rapper - who is married to the former 'Made in Chelsea' star - has revealed they do not want to have a baby yet because their dogs...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Taylor Swift's midriff mystery
Taylor Swift doesn't want people to know she has a belly button. The 'Blank Space' hitmaker admitted she chooses not to wear tops which reveal her midriff because she wants to keep her fans guessing as to whether she...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Wilko Johnson: 'I shouldn't be here'
Wilko Johnson believes he ''shouldn't be here'' after battling cancer. The 'Game of Thrones' actor was given the all clear in October following a 17-month battle with pancreatic cancer, and has recalled the ''marvellous...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Penelope Cruz joins Ben Stiller in 'Zoolander 2'
Los Angeles, Nov 23 (IANS) Actress Penelope Cruz is all set to star with actor Ben Stiller in the film "Zoolander 2". According to Deadline magazine, details of Cruz's role in the sequel of "Zoolander" has not been...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
No general election in Pakistan before 2018: Nawaz Sharif
Islamabad, Nov 23 (IANS) Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif said Saturday that a general election would not be held in the country before 2018. He thus rejected the demands by the opposition Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf...
Read more on Politics Balla