Unemployment Benefits Stalled In Senate Because The Electorate Wants Economic Growth Too

Jan 15 2014, 8:22am CST | by

Unemployment Benefits Stalled In Senate Because The Electorate Wants Economic Growth Too

The failure of the Senate to reach an agreement on either a short (3 month) or longer- term (11 month) extension of  unemployment insurance combined with two new polls showing the electorate is moving away from ‘economic fairness’ arguments is the clearest evidence of a pivot toward a preference for ‘growth’ policies.

The reason the issue has stalled is deeper than Republican intransigence over how the extension would be paid for.  This has never been a debate about fiscal responsibility and pay-go rules.  The inability of the two bills to reach the current filibuster threshold and Senator Harry Reid’s unwillingness to allow the possibility of a diverse array of amendments suggests that while a consensus among lawmakers has yet to emerge, the electorate – calling into Congressional offices back home – clearly wants something more productive in return for the extension.

Lawmakers sense this but are confused by all of the inputs and the emotional intensity tied to each preference.  Washington is just too noisy right now.  After returning from their recess, it is very likely that legislative deal-making will better reflect what the electorate is communicating.

My read is that the electorate now wants economic growth policies paired with any major piece of income redistribution legislation.  That is what the latest Rasmussen poll on the economic fairness vs. economic growth question suggests to me. Finding that 53% of Americans rate economic growth over economic fairness, Rasmussen concluded yesterday, “President Obama has declared income equality to be his number one issue this year, but most voters continue to rate economic growth as more important than economic fairness.”

And citing the always elusive (and often biased) ‘internal poll,’ Rep. John Boehner, with glee, pointed out that Republican pollster David Winston has determined that more Americans now blame President Obama for the state of the economy than do President George W. Bush, who was in power at the beginning of the Great Recession.

The Hill reports, “The Speaker shows slides illustrating the numbers. After Obama’s 2012 reelection, according to Winston’s polling, 53 percent of voters said ‘policies of the past’ were causing the nation’s economic problems, while 44 percent blamed policies ‘of the present.’ Polling in November 2013 found those numbers largely reversed; 41 percent blame the policies of the past, while 49 percent blame current policies. ‘Since he can’t blame George W. Bush anymore, the president has chosen to talk about rising income inequality, unemployment, and the need to extend emergency unemployment benefits,’ Boehner said. ‘After five years in office, Barack Obama still doesn’t have an answer to the question: Where are the jobs?

The only problem with Rep. Boehner’s thesis is that if the electorate is asking President Obama ‘where are the jobs?’ they are similarly wondering of Republicans, ‘where are your growth policies?

Clearly, with Republicans polling higher than Democrats on the issue of who is better suited to handle the economy, the electorate is not looking for obstruction of redistribution policies as much as they are looking for avenues which proactively increase employment.

As I pointed out in “Because Republicans React To Obama They Are Controlled By Him,” it is Democrats who are taking the lead in more prominently advancing ideas and legislation in accordance with their economic ideology.  Republicans focus on the errant ways of these policies without offering their own.

Either economic growth is no longer a part of the party’s ideology – replaced by anti-Government Tea Party fiscal populism –  or Republicans have become demand-side Keynesians themselves or the economic growth wing of the party is too marginalized or unorganized within it.

From another direction, Brad Plumer points out the effect of all of this in The Washington Post,  “Economists on both the left and the right who have looked at this problem tend to think the government needs to do a lot more to tackle long-term unemployment. That could include work-sharing programs. Or tax incentives for companies that hire the long-term jobless, as economist Dean Baker has suggested. Or relocation assistance. Or even, as AEI’s Kevin Hassett has proposed, the government could hire people directly. But Congress isn’t doing any of these things. They’re not even talking about any of these things. The only debate is between Democrats (and some Republicans) who want to extend the emergency unemployment insurance program and conservatives who oppose it. But there’s little legislative debate over larger, more comprehensive measures.”

Congress can’t reach a deal over the extension of unemployment insurance because only one side – the Democrats –  or one economic school, Keynesian, proactively offers an agenda.

Once Republicans figure this out, not only will we have a more robust economic debate but one that brings us closer to economic growth.

- Follow Cedric on Twitter

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

4 Steps To Reaching Your Money Goals -- Faster!
By Stella Grizont This post originally appeared on LearnVest. I don’t know about you, but when it comes to managing my finances, I can often come up with a whole list of things I’d much rather do … including cleaning...
 
 
Apple's Analysts Almost Universally Positive On The March Quarter Results
Apple’s shares are up over $40 today driven by its very solid March quarter results and better than expected guidance for the June quarter. I have summarized over a dozen sell-side notes below and many analysts have...
 
 
Can China Lead? Highlights And Thoughts From Harvard China Forum
This past weekend I went back to my alma mater to attend the annual Harvard China Forum, where a handful of the organizers are my personal acquaintances. With 1,200 attendees and a $100,000 budget, it is perhaps the...
 
 
A Secret Of Customer Service Training You Can Learn In The Shower (Or At The Ritz-Carlton)
I remember one time when my hair got really, really dirty–I’d been at camp. When finally under the blissful flow of the shower head, my temptation was to wash my hair eight or nine times in a row. Which didn’t really do...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Apple's Sales Figures Prove A Sad Fact: There's Still No PC As Desirable As A Mac
Mac sales make up just a tenth of Apple's revenue, but they’ve received a significant amount of attention following the company’s quarterly report yesterday, both from analysts and from the CEO Tim Cook himself. Cook’s...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Apple's Analysts Almost Universally Positive On The March Quarter Results
Apple’s shares are up over $40 today driven by its very solid March quarter results and better than expected guidance for the June quarter. I have summarized over a dozen sell-side notes below and many analysts have...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Odyne Systems, LLC Partners with Allison Transmission’s Midwest Distributor, Inland Power, to Deliver on $45.4 Million Contract
Waukesha, WI, April 24, 2014 --(PR.com)-- Odyne Systems of Waukesha and Inland Power Group of Butler, Wisconsin have teamed up to deliver on a $45.4 million contract from the Department of Energy, administered through...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Odyne Systems, LLC Partners with Allison Transmission’s Midwest Distributor, Inland Power, to Deliver on $45.4 Million Contract
Waukesha, WI, April 24, 2014 --(PR.com)-- Odyne Systems of Waukesha and Inland Power Group of Butler, Wisconsin have teamed up to deliver on a $45.4 million contract from the Department of Energy, administered through...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Cleared Of Fraud Against SMEs, RBS Eases Rules For Distressed Businesses
Last week, The Royal Bank of Scotland Group was cleared by law firm Clifford Chance over allegations that the U.K.-based banking group deliberately put failing small and medium enterprise customers out of business to...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Cost Savings Are Allowing Colgate To Invest Back In Building Brands And Products
In the past several quarters, balancing the business mix between developed and emerging markets has helped Colgate-Palmolive to achieve above market growth and experience only a moderate impact on net sales from...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Shift In Agricultural Sales Timing, Lower Chemical Prices Weigh On DuPont's Earnings Growth
DuPont reported modest earnings growth for the first quarter due to lower agricultural sales volume and continuing pricing pressures in the chemicals segment. The company’s adjusted diluted earnings per share of $1.58...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Google's Glass Explorer Program Was A Social Experiment That Backfired
Google Glass was launched without any clear explanation of what it was supposed to be used for. When promotional videos started to show people going about their daily routine, it quickly became clear that what we were...
Read more on Business Balla
 
America's 100 Best Corporate Citizens in 2014
America’s 10 Best Corporate Citizens In 2014 In December Bristol-Myers Squibb joined the Medicines Patent Pool, an international organization in Geneva, Switzerland, that makes drugs available at low cost to people...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Talent Knows No Limits
Last month I had the pleasure of attending Cirque Du Soleil’s Michael Jackson tribute The Immortal World Tour. To say the performance was out of this world would be an understatement. If you’ve ever seen a Cirque show...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla