10 Updates

Attorney's Time Slips Slip Up Post-Judgment Attempts To Defraud Creditors In Frankel

Jan 18 2014, 1:07pm CST | by

A former Lehman Brothers stockbroker, Sofia Frankel, was accused of churning her client’s accounts. After arbitration, a $2.5 million judgment was awarded against Sofia on October 30, 2008. Just...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

27 weeks ago

Attorney's Time Slips Slip Up Post-Judgment Attempts To Defraud Creditors In Frankel

Jan 18 2014, 1:07pm CST | by

A former Lehman Brothers stockbroker, Sofia Frankel, was accused of churning her client’s accounts. After arbitration, a $2.5 million judgment was awarded against Sofia on October 30, 2008.

Just days after the arbitration award was entered, Sofia went to see attorney David Pratt of the Proskauer Rose LLP firm, and (very importantly, as we will see later) took along her son, Michael. What did they talk about?

Proskauer’s attorney time records for November 2008 describe a conversation of November 7 “with Sofia and Michael re: asset protection plan,” followed two days later by a conversation “with Michael Frankel re: asset protection planning.” The various items under consideration included the “sale/transfer of N.Y. condos,” “homestead waiver issues,” the “option of filing claim in bankruptcy court to obtain indemnification for arbitration award” and “efforts to identify insurance coverage or indemnification for arbitration award.”

At this time, Sofia had five major assets:

(1) Miami condo, claimed as homestead with her husband;

(2) Manhattan condo, owned with her husband in tenants in the entirety;

(3) 100% ownership in Applied Medicals LLC, a Florida medical supply company;

(4) A $4+ million investment account solely owned by Sofia at Fidelity; and

(5) Another Manhattan condo, solely owned by Sofia.

According to Pratt’s plan, Sofia withdrew $3.3 million from the Fidelity account, and apparently used $2.9 million of that money to purchase another Miami condo held solely in her name, and which she claimed as her homestead.

Sofia’s son, Michael — who is to feature prominently in the Opinion — acquired a 10% interest in Applied Medicals LLC, so as to terminate the LLC’s single-member status (Florida law allows a creditor to take the assets of a debtor’s wholly-owned LLC, which Applied Medicals LLCs was until Michael acquired his interest).

Then, Michael “bought” Sofia’s solely-owned Manhattan condo, valued at $1.175 million, for $1 “and other valuable consideration”.

Here, Sofia and Michael claimed that they had an unwritten, oral agreement for Michael to purchase the condo made in 1999, whereby Michael took immediate possession and assumed expenses, then at the age of 30 (coincidentally, 2009 when the transfer occurred), Michael would get the condo. Oh, and there were also some credits that Michael would get for deductions that Sofia would get for the interest and taxes that were actually paid by Michael over a decade.

The “other consideration” turned out to be a promissory note for $970,000 due in 30 years, plus monthly interest payments of $2,390 per month.

The trial court didn’t buy Sofia’s and Michael’s story, and granted summary judgment for the creditors. Because the past consideration was not memorialized in writing, under New York law it did not comprise fair consideration under that state’s Debtor and Creditor Law.

On appeal, the story didn’t fare any better:

 the record fails to support defendants’ contention that the conveyance was made pursuant to a previous agreement rather than as part of an asset protection plan contrived to insulate property from the claims of judgment creditors.

The Appellate Division also took great pains to point out that there was no “fair consideration” for the transfer of title from Sofia to Michael, noting that “fair consideration” in New York has two elements: (1) adequacy of consideration, and (2) good faith.

Whether or not the first test — adequacy of consideration — was met or not met, it was clear that there was utterly no good faith in Sofia’s sale of the condo to Michael, coming immediately after she suffered the arbitration award and started moving assets out of the reach of her creditors.

Here, Sofia and Michael claimed that it was only Michael’s intent as the transferee that was relevant in determining good faith, but the Appellate Division after a substantial survey of the law concluded otherwise. If either Sofia or Michael acted without good faith, then “fair consideration” could not be present, and certainly Sofia’s conduct fit that bill:

It is apparent that Sofia’s conveyance of the subject Manhattan condominium apartment to her son was but one of a series of transactions undertaken as part of an “asset protection plan” devised with the assistance of counsel immediately after the arbitration award was rendered against her. The emptying of a brokerage account, the purchase of Florida real estate claimed as a homestead and the transfer of the subject apartment held in fee simple demonstrate not merely a series of transactions coincidental to estate planning, as her affidavit intimates, but a concerted effort to place her assets beyond the reach of impending judgment creditors. Finally, the addition of Michael as a member of Applied Medicals LLC, of which Sofia was formerly the sole member, precludes plaintiffs from obtaining an order from a Florida court directing the surrender of her entire interest in the company to satisfy the award against her.

Though Sofia’s lack of anything like good faith was enough to put the kabosh on fair consideration, the Appellate Division didn’t let Michael off the hook either:

It is apparent that Michael was a participant in the asset protection plan from its inception, having conferred with his mother and her counsel. He was clearly instrumental to its implementation, having been installed as a member of Applied Medicals LLC to frustrate seizure of its assets and having received title to the subject premises conveyed by Sofia.

The Appellate Division went on to delve into the nuances of New York law relating to valid conveyances of real property, and essentially concluded that the property transfer was hinky, if not technically invalid, because of the unwritten terms and other circumstances. And as to the “past consideration” paid by Michael in addition to the $1 American,

 the facts conceded by defendants fail to demonstrate that, prior to the February 2009 conveyance of the apartment, Michael was anything more than a month-to-month tenant paying less than fair market rent for the premises. As to defendants’ suggestion that the 2009 agreement to transfer title was supported by past consideration, the amounts previously paid by Michael exceed the use and occupancy value agreed upon by defendants by a mere $21,433.66, a little more than 2% of the purchase price. As plaintiffs point out, when the transfer tax and filing charge are taken into account, the amount of past consideration received by Sofia for the apartment at the time of its conveyance was a negative $11,835.09, which negates any alleged fair consideration for the purchase of the subject apartment.

In thus concluding that Sofia had engaged in a fraudulent transfer to Michael, the Appellate Division in its summary gave their case one final kick:

 Michael has not alleged, let alone demonstrated, that he was a good-faith purchaser for value without knowledge of the fraud at the time of conveyance so as to render immaterial the lack of good faith in making the conveyance. Once again, this was clearly indicated by Michael’s participation in the asset protection plan with his mother and Proskauer Rose before the 2009 alleged transfer.

And with that, the Appellate Division affirmed the trial court’s grant of summary judgment for the creditors on the fraudulent transfer claim.

ANALYSIS/>/>

Once again, we must begin with the caveat that this is nothing like legitimate asset protection planning, but rather is just a blatant post-judgment attempt by Sofia to cheat her legitimate creditors. And, once again, we must reiterate that asset protection is all about avoiding fraudulent transfers, and not making them.

There is an old saying a bad lawyer can make a good argument, but only a good lawyer will know when the good argument is a loser. Here, while Sofia was able to transfer the condo and articulate an argument why fair consideration existed, the argument was destined to be a loser because the timing was obviously highly suspect, and the consideration paid by Michael was highly suspect.

But even beyond all that, we see yet another case where the Court essentially sees the two words “asset protection”, and that is basically all the Court needs to know to give the debtor the thumbs-down. Whatever planners may think of the legitimacy of asset protection planning, this case is but one in an increasingly long line of cases where the Courts view “asset protection” as a less-than-honorable practice.

Sadly, this isn’t because the Courts have addressed actual pre-claim asset protection, but rather because the Courts having to consider blatant fraud-on-creditor cases like this where the planner uses the words “asset protection” are making up so many of these cases. Here, the planner should not have recorded “asset protection” in his timeslips, but instead just recorded “planning to commit fraud on Sofia’s creditors” which is what all this ended up amounting to. The timeslips became a major slip-up, as they provided easy evidence for creditor’s to deflate Michael’s claims that he was in anything like good faith regarding the condo transaction.

There is utterly no need to use the two words “asset protection” in any client matter. There is no need to use the term in planning memoranda, in planning documents, in client communications, in billing statements, or anywhere else. The smart law firm will be the one that arranges for their technical support experts to have their word processing software automatically substitute the words “bubble gum” in place of “asset protection”. Yet, in case after case we see planners persisting in this practice in defiance of now substantial case law, not to mention common sense.

This case is also illustrative of how Courts considering fraudulent transfer issues do not look at transactions in isolation, but rather look at transactions in light of all the surrounding circumstances. A good story in isolation can become a bad novella where substantial other seedy transactions are contemporaneously taking place.

Here, it was clear that Sofia was transferring a goodly portion of her assets for the purpose of cheating her creditors, and that Michael was complicit in assisting her, such as buying into Applied Medicals LLC so as to terminate its single-member status as to Sofia. In the light of these other circumstances, it becomes obvious that Sofia was selling the condo to Michael not for truly legitimately reasons, whatever they said (words are cheap), but to cheat her creditors out of their collection rights against the condo.

This case is disappointing in the sense that Proskauer Rose LLP is normally a very good law firm with very good lawyers. Here, we can only hope that somehow this planning slipped past their internal controls and was a “one bad apple” sort of aberration.

Which is to say that the mere fact that a client is in financial distress does not ipso facto mean that the attorney should (or as we have seen in other cases, ethically can) provide certain assistance to the client. This is a case where the client should have been told, “You should have done you planning before these claims arose, and it is now too late for anything like asset protection planning to be done for you.” Sometimes clients, for their own good, need to be told the cold-hard truth that post-judgment is not the time to start planning, and shown the door. Yet, it is probably inevitable that we will continue to see these attempts that cannot be reasonably be characterized as anything other than attempts to cheat legitimate creditors out of their collection rights.

And that’s not asset protection at all, or at least anything like legitimate asset protection planning.

CITE AS

Sardis v. Frankel, 2014 WL 37870 (N.Y.App., Jan. 7, 2014).  Full opinion at http://goo.gl/SEJCO7

This article at http://onforb.es/1eU6KHj and http://goo.gl/pNnEHb

Source: Forbes Business

 
Update
10

7 weeks ago

RM47mil KWSG contributions still unclaimed

Jun 9 2014 7:54am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: About RM47 million of contributions in the Teachers Provident Fund (KWSG) still remain unclaimed, the Dewan Rakyat was told ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
9

7 weeks ago

Gold shop lost almost RM1mil

Jun 9 2014 3:50am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KANGAR: A gold shop owner lost almost RM1 million after after the safe on in his shop was ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
8

7 weeks ago

Motion to debate MAS losses in Dewan Rakyat rejected

Jun 9 2014 3:39am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: AN emergency motion to debate the losses incurred by Malaysia Airlines last year, amounting to RM1.2 billion was rejected by the Dewan Rakya ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
7

7 weeks ago

MH370 Tragedy: Hisham: RM27.6 mil spent on 1st phase of SAR

Jun 9 2014 2:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia spent some RM27.6 million in its first phase of the search operations for missing Malaysia Airline flight MH370, said Acting Transport Minister, Da ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
6

7 weeks ago

9.1m litres of diesel seized in a month

Jun 8 2014 1:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PUTRAJAYA: The Domestic Trade, Cooperatives, and Consumerism ministry has seized some 9.1 million litres of diesel and property worth RM58 million since mounting ‘Operasi Diesel Selatan ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
5

7 weeks ago

Girl, 9, awarded RM2.78m compensation for medical negligence

Jun 6 2014 4:56am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: A nine-year-old girl who suffered brain damage during her birth at a government hospital was awarded over RM2.78 million in compens ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
4

7 weeks ago

Malaysia's total trade in April up 12pc

Jun 5 2014 11:52pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's total trade in April 2014 rose by 12 per cent from a year ago to RM123.86 billion due to growing trading activities, International Trade and Industry Minister Datuk Seri Mustapa ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
3

7 weeks ago

Works Ministry to spend RM20m for upgrading works at 50 accident black spots

Jun 4 2014 11:35pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

JOHOR BARU: The Works Ministry will implement upgrading works at 50 accident prone locations in the country that have been identified this year involving an allocatio ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
2

7 weeks ago

Najib launches loan scheme for Ramadan traders

Jun 4 2014 10:24pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PUTRAJAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak today launches RM45 million Ramadan Bazaar Scheme 2 ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
1

8 weeks ago

Residents bring up objection against Kidex to Suhakam

Jun 4 2014 4:49am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PETALING JAYA: A group of 20 Petaling Jaya residents held a meeting with the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) over their objection against the proposed RM2.2 billion Kinrara Damansara Skyway (Kidex) ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

OPEC daily basket price closes tad higher
Vienna, July 30 (IANS) The basket of 12 crude oils of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) stood at $105.44 a barrel Tuesday, against $105.22 last Thursday, according to the OPEC Secretariat.
 
 
Moscow calls US sanctions 'illegitimate'
Moscow, July 30 (IANS) The economic sanctions imposed by the United States are a revenge on Russia, the country's foreign ministry said Wednesday.
 
 
EU boosts funding to fight Ebola epidemic
Brussels, July 30 (IANS) The European Union Wednesday allocated an additional 2 million euros ($2.68 million) in aid to tackle the Ebola epidemic in West Africa.
 
 
Top doctor in Sierra Leone dies of Ebola
Nairobi, July 30 (IANS/EFE) Sierra Leone's top Ebola virus doctor, Sheikh Umar Khan, died a few days after contracting the lethal disease which has claimed the lives of 672 people in Western Africa, health authorities in Sierra Leone announced Wednesday.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Jessica Simpson wants to be thinner?
Jessica Simpson is allegedly eager to lose more weight. The Weight Watchers spokesperson, who lost 50 pounds before marrying Eric Johnson in Montecito, California earlier this month, is said to be determined to stick to...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Chris Pratt's son brought him closer to Anna Faris
Chris Pratt says his premature baby boy brought him closer to his wife, Anna Faris. The 'Guardians of the Galaxy' star and the 37-year-old actress welcomed their son, Jack, into the world nine weeks early in August 2012...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Drew Barrymore pays tribute to late half-sister
Drew Barrymore has paid tribute to her estranged older half-sister, who was found dead on Tuesday (07.29.14). The 39-year-old actress offered her sympathies to her extended family after Jessica Barrymore, whom she only...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
G7 warns Russia faces more sanctions
London, July 31 (IANS) The G7 leaders in a joint statement Wednesday said Russia will face further economic sanctions if it continued to support rebels in Ukraine. The warning came after the EU added eight more...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Kim Kardashian slams Rob's ex-girlfriend
London, July 31 (IANS) Reality TV star Kim Kardashian has hit out at brother Rob Kardashian's ex-girlfriend Adrienne Bailon for bad mouthing her sibling. Talking to a Latina magazine, the actress-and-singer, who dated...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Kohli's significant dinner date with Vaughan (Analysis)
Southampton, July 31 (IANS/RAY) Tuesday night, India batsman and vice-captain Virat Kohli had dinner with Michael Vaughan, former England captain, at a Brazilian restaurant in Southampton. This was revealed by the...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Few Americans believe US winning fight against terror: Poll
Washington, July 31 (IANS) Belief that the US is winning the fight against terrorism has dropped to its lowest level in more than a decade of regular tracking, a poll has found. A new Rasmussen Reports national...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Simon Cowell will be a great dad: Ex-girlfriend
Los Angeles, July 31 (IANS) Former Playboy model Carmen Electra says that her ex-boyfriend, Simon Cowell, will be a great father to his son Eric. The 54-year-old music mogul and his girlfriend, Lauren Silverman,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Reach out to others as friends: UN chief
United Nations, July 31 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon has called upon all to reach out to one another as friends and build long-term foundations for lasting peace in the time of mistrust and violence....
Read more on Politics Balla
 
When Rita Ora forgot her lines
Los Angeles, July 31 (IANS) Singer Rita Ora found acting "difficult" as she kept forgetting her lines while filming her scenes for the upcoming erotica "Fifty Shades of Grey". The 23-year-old singer, who is playing...
Read more on Celebrity Balla