Russia's Economic Performance Is Actually Very Similar To Other East European Countries'

Jan 20 2014, 8:46am CST | by

Russia's Economic Performance Is Actually Very Similar To Other East European Countries'

Ever since it was lumped in with the BRICs, people have judged the performance of Russia’s economy primarily in comparison to India, Brazil, and China. While Russia does not necessarily come out looking bad when compared to Brazil,  if you look only at headline GDP growth numbers then it is clearly lagging pretty far behind India, China, and several other of the more dynamic emerging markets. Quite a lot of people never thought Russia belonged in the BRICs in the first place, and the calls for removing it from the club grew ever louder as its 2013 GDP number were repeatedly revised downward to a measly 1.4%.

While I think the BRICs are an interesting concept, and while Jim O’Neill, the person who coined the term, accurately predicted a strong shift in economic gravity away from the developed world, the simple fact is that Brazil, Russia, India, and China are extremely different countries with extremely different cultures, politics, economics, and demographics. Apart from being large, they just don’t have very much in common.

I’ve long thought that it makes far more sense to compare Russia to the countries with which it shares the myriad aftereffects of state socialism. Russia and the countries of Central and Eastern Europe are, of course, not identical. But in trying to build market structures on the wreckage of the command economy, Russia and other post-Communist countries have shared many of the same economic, social, and political challenges. They inherited economies that were way too focused on heavy industry and that had extremely under-developed service sectors. Manufacturing both employed way too large a percentage of the workforce and was extraordinarily inefficient. Banking systems were practically non-existent, and the management of state finances was chaotic (at best). Due in large part to uncertainty over the new “rules of the game,” corruption was pervasive and on a scale rarely seen in other periods of history. This was a specific set of challenges that few countries outside of Eastern Europe had to face.

And so while Russia looks like a sclerotic failure when you compare it to China or India, it looks a lot better when you compare it to Poland or Romania:

This won’t necessarily be true in the future: it’s entirely possible that, five years from now, Russia will lag behind other parts of Central and Eastern Europe that have made a more concerted effort at economic reform. But at the moment Russia is simply not lagging behind the countries to which it is most similar. It’s performance is very much in line with the region.

Russia’s economy clearly has a lot of problems, with persistently high capital flight at the top of the list and corruption not far behind. But I still think it is noteworthy that virtually every country in the region has gone through a period of protracted economic weakness over the past several years. Some of Russia’s slowdown is domestic in nature, but when a decelerating Russia is still growing more quickly than traditionally strong performers like Poland and Slovakia, it strongly suggests that there is something that is negatively impacting the entire region’s economy.

Whatever that “something” is, whether it’s excessively tight money from the ECB or the initial impact of the demographic shock of the early 1990′s, it cannot be solved by any one country acting alone. Which is to say that even if the Russian authorities suddenly get serious about economic reform, it probably won’t have much of a short-term impact.

Follow me on Twitter @MarkAdomanis or on Facebook

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Why There Are So Many Terrible Managers In Business Today And What To Do About It
Throughout my 18-year corporate career, I had scores of managers who were, sadly, anything but inspiring.  The majority were clueless as to how to motivate, lead or develop their staff, or help employees utilize their...
 
 
Five Red Flags That Scream "Don't Take This Job!"
You can find tons of advice about how to get a job interview and how to snag a job. Most of it comes from the “Do whatever you have to do to get hired!” school of thought. The job market isn’t a job-seeker’s paradise,...
 
 
Penguins Playoff Tickets Down 25% After Blue Jackets Take Home Ice Advantage
With their win last night against the Penguins, the Columbus Blue Jackets have won their first game in the NHL playoffs and brought the first NHL playoff win to the Buckeye State.  Despite that historic achievement,...
 
 
Community Colleges Are The New Business Incubators
The rumor is community colleges are fallback schools because of price or easy, last-minute admissions. But that isn’t exactly the case anymore. Community colleges are now in the business of providing entrepreneurial...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

U.S. Ranks 94th Of 100 Tax Systems; What Slovakia Could Teach IRS
Is our tax system competitive? Many global companies say no. Apple CEO Tim Cook lambasted the U.S. tax system in testimony before the Senate Permanent Investigation Subcommittee. Its report on Apple suggested tax...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Why There Are So Many Terrible Managers In Business Today And What To Do About It
Throughout my 18-year corporate career, I had scores of managers who were, sadly, anything but inspiring.  The majority were clueless as to how to motivate, lead or develop their staff, or help employees utilize their...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Five Red Flags That Scream "Don't Take This Job!"
You can find tons of advice about how to get a job interview and how to snag a job. Most of it comes from the “Do whatever you have to do to get hired!” school of thought. The job market isn’t a job-seeker’s paradise,...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Penguins Playoff Tickets Down 25% After Blue Jackets Take Home Ice Advantage
With their win last night against the Penguins, the Columbus Blue Jackets have won their first game in the NHL playoffs and brought the first NHL playoff win to the Buckeye State.  Despite that historic achievement,...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Community Colleges Are The New Business Incubators
The rumor is community colleges are fallback schools because of price or easy, last-minute admissions. But that isn’t exactly the case anymore. Community colleges are now in the business of providing entrepreneurial...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Life Insurance and the 831(b) Captive Insurance Company - Wait For The Test Case Before Signing Up
There is an old saying about life insurance: “Life insurance isn’t bought, it is sold.” The public doesn’t exactly clamor to buy life insurance, and if you don’t believe me then just try to find a life insurance store...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Cesar Chavez Flick Lacks Nuance, Economic Literacy
The new biopic Cesar Chavez film is an emotional tale that breathes new life into the story of the important Latino labor organizer who died in 1993. Yet the film has multiple inaccuracies and doesn’t give justice to...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Why Jose Mourinho Needs To Worry About His Head When Chelsea Plays Atletico Madrid In UEFA Champions League
There are so many sidebars to the UEFA Champions semi-final between Atletico Madrid and Chelsea that is easy to forget that a fantastic encounter is in prospect forget. The Managers While Jose Mourinho needs little or...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Sherry Turkle's Solution To The Downside Of Screen Relations: Conversation
If Neil deGrasse Tyson from Cosmos has become the  bard of deep time, then Sherry Turkle is the bard of the present moment. Her stories, most recently Alone Together, tell us what our emerging technologies are doing to...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla