360° Coverage : Why Justice Matters: The Indictment & Trial Of Dr. Martin...

2 Updates
Why Justice Matters: The Indictment & Trial Of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. On Tax Charges

Why Justice Matters: The Indictment & Trial Of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. On Tax Charges

Jan 20 2014, 9:23am CST | by

The power to tax is the power to destroy. Daniel Webster is thought to have coined that phrase in his oral arguments in the Supreme Court case, McCulloch v. Maryland (17 U.S. 327 (1819)). He...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

35 weeks ago

Why Justice Matters: The Indictment & Trial Of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. On Tax Charges

Jan 20 2014, 9:23am CST | by

The power to tax is the power to destroy.

Daniel Webster is thought to have coined that phrase in his oral arguments in the Supreme Court case, McCulloch v. Maryland (17 U.S. 327 (1819)). He actually said, “An unlimited power to tax involves, necessarily, a power to destroy.” Chief Justice Marshall later paraphrased Webster in his opinion, clarifying, “Taxation, it is said, does not necessarily and unavoidably destroy. To carry it to the excess of destruction would be an abuse, to presume which would banish that confidence which is essential to all Government.”

Confidence in our government. It’s something we talk a lot about today but concern over the potential for widespread government abuse (think NSA, IRS, etc.) is nothing new. Years ago, Dr. Martin Luther King’s willingness to lead the civil rights movement not only resulted in his untimely death but also near constant harassment by government officials including tax authorities.

Investigations into his finances were nothing new for Dr. King: he was investigated in two states (Georgia and Alabama) on numerous occasions. In 1960, he made news as being the first person ever criminally charged in the state of Alabama on tax fraud. The felony perjury charges for signing fraudulent tax returns stemmed from allegations that Dr. King had not included taxable income of nearly $45,000 on his return – the equivalent in today’s dollars of $354,157.60. A committee formed at the home of Harry Belafonte to help pay expenses associated with the trial called the charges a gross misrepresentation of fact, noting that “[i]n no year of his life has Dr. King’s net income even approached such a figure.”

After his indictment, Dr. King was asked by a reporter, “Have your income tax returns been investigated before?”

He replied, “Oh yes, they have been investigated two or three times before. This is nothing new. Investigations have taken place before. And the last time, the state came and said that since I was leaving the state, they wanted to do this audit. And the man who was doing the audit made it very clear to me over and over again that my returns were thoroughly honest and as accurate as anyone can make returns. But he also admitted that he was under pressure from his superiors to bring some charge. This was one of the last things I heard from him when we were talking over the whole matter.”

You can see the interview with Dr. King on this WSB-TV news film clip .

Following the investigation, Dr. King was arrested and eventually brought to trial.

To honor the day, as I do always, I am reposting an article (unedited) that I wrote a few years ago about Dr. King’s trial and the legal profession. It remains one of my favorite posts to this day. Enjoy!

I’ll be frank. I don’t always love being a lawyer.

When I was a little girl, I used to watch Perry Mason with my grandfather on TBS. That constituted my entire legal experience before entering law school. And it was flawed.

You see, on TV, none of the lawyers lied to Perry Mason over the phone about being amenable to a continuance and then told the Clerk of Court differently. Nobody faxed Perry Mason a witness list the day before a hearing along with evidence that they “forgot” to send prior. A lawyer didn’t claim proper service on Perry Mason and then fail to deliver the notices to his law offices. You never saw a lawyer represent clients who had sent Perry Mason death threats via email attempt to assert that Mr. Mason was the one being unreasonable. You didn’t see cases drag on for years and years (yes, plural) because counsel just couldn’t get it together enough to resolve the matter. On TV, no matter how dire, how dramatic, there was ultimately justice.

The law is supposed to be about justice, about finding the truth. And increasingly it feels like it’s not. It’s more about touting your wares, putting yourself on commercials during daytime television standing in front of legal books shouting about maximizing money, about doing anything to get paid. And that is sad.

A few months ago, I attended a hearing that made me question my role in the law. You’re probably assuming that the hearing somehow didn’t go well. That isn’t true. It went remarkably well. Our client was an excellent witness. The judge was fair and very accommodating. We walked out of the hearing knowing that we had done a good job. The thing was, I felt relieved that it was over. I was happy for my clients. But I wasn’t happy for me. Truth be told, I hated every minute of preparing for the case. Well, not every minute. The theory, the strategy? That I didn’t mind. Our strategy was simply to tell our story. And we somehow felt that should be enough. In the end, I think it was./>/>

But the getting there? The games? The complete lack of professionalism exhibited by opposing counsel? Lying about continuances? Surprise witnesses? Last minute evidence? Maybe that seems exciting on TV but in real life, it’s not exciting. It’s sickening. It’s stressful. It’s not fair to good lawyers who spend their time crafting a case. It’s not fair to clients who don’t know what to expect in the court room. And yet somehow, month after month, this behavior doesn’t seem so unusual.

And as opposing counsel sat at her chair in her too tight blouse with the clickety-click of her little heels on the floor, the same counsel who called my clients’ claims frivolous, the same counsel whose supervising partner at Big Law Firm once commented to me that she didn’t understand why a small firm like mine would go up against a big firm like hers, I thought about why we were all at that place, how it all happened that we were in the same room believing two different versions of the truth. I couldn’t explain it.

Later that same day, while reaching for my Moscow Mule (yes, my favorite cocktail du jour, even before Rachael Ray put it in her magazine last month – grr) at the Union League, I understood why the partner at my former firm kept a bottle of wine in his desk: the pressure of being a lawyer, the pressure of having to win, it’s a lot to take in. And while other professions can often look to each other for reassurance, we don’t really have that in the legal profession with few exceptions. It is, by its very nature, adversarial. It is competitive. It is cut throat. And me? I am not. Of course, I like to win. I like to think that I am good at it. And then maybe I think that’s not something to be particularly proud of.

So, over the past few weeks, which have been professionally difficult, I have tried to remember why it is exactly that I became a lawyer – and what about it I used to love. And I was reminded of my favorite scene in the movie Philadelphia. The one where Andrew Beckett sums up what’s actually good about the law:

Joe Miller: What do you love about the law, Andrew?

Andrew Beckett: I… many things… uh… uh… What I love the most about the law?

Joe Miller: Yeah.

Andrew Beckett: It’s that every now and again – not often, but occasionally – you get to be a part of justice being done. That really is quite a thrill when that happens.

And so I tried to think of when that happened last – when justice was actually done. Not when I won a case or when I got a client out of trouble – that happens often enough. But remember, winning and justice aren’t the same thing. I had to think for awhile.

Later, I was preparing to write post about Martin Luther King, Jr. Day. I figured I’d just put up a copy of his famous “I Have A Dream” speech and call it a day. But as I researched, I found part of his autobiography which, I will confess, I have never read in full. And I saw something interesting: I knew that Dr. King had been arrested several times for various accusations, but I didn’t realize that he had been on trial for tax evasion.

Yep. On February 17, 1960, a warrant was issued for the arrest of civil rights leader Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. on charges of tax evasion. He was accused of allegedly falsifying his Alabama income tax returns for the years 1956 and 1958; he was the only person ever prosecuted under the state’s income tax perjury statute. It seemed like an inevitable victory for the government.

In his autobiography, Dr. King described the trial like this:

This case was tried before an all-white Southern jury. All of the State’s witnesses were white. The judge and the prosecutor were white. The courtroom was segregated. Passions were inflamed. Feelings ran high. The press and other communications media were hostile. Defeat seemed certain, and we in the freedom struggle braced ourselves for the inevitable. There were two men among us who persevered with the conviction that it was possible, in this context, to marshal facts and law and thus win vindication. These men were our lawyers-Negro lawyers from the North: William Ming of Chicago and Hubert Delaney from New York.

And something quite remarkable happened. On May 28, 1960, only after a few hours, Dr. King was acquitted by an all white jury in Montgomery, Alabama.

Dr. King said about his trial:

I am frank to confess that on this occasion I learned that truth and conviction in the hands of a skillful advocate could make what started out as a bigoted, prejudiced jury, choose the path of justice. I cannot help but wish in my heart that the same kind of skill and devotion which Bill Ming and Hubert Delaney accorded to me could be available to thousands of civil rights workers, to thousands of ordinary Negroes, who are every day facing prejudiced courtrooms.

And it dawned on me: no matter how many slick-haired, silver-tongued attorneys do their best to make a quick buck at the expense of the reputation of the profession, you can’t dispute that justice is attainable. And justice is good. And justice is important. And even if it is infrequent, it’s worth it when it happens.

Want more taxgirl goodness? Pick your poison: receive posts by email, follow me on twitter (@taxgirl), hang out with me on Facebook or check out my YouTube channel. If you want to keep an eye on documents I’ve posted, check out my profile on Scribd. And finally, you can subscribe to my podcast on the site or via iTunes (it’s free).

Source: Forbes Business

 
Update
2

3 weeks ago

Khazanah throws MAS RM6b lifeline

Aug 29 2014 5:01pm CDT | Source: Business Times Singapore

August 30, 2014 1:15 AMKHAZANAH Nasional will inject RM6 billion (SS$2.4 billion) over three years to resuscitate loss-making Malaysia Airlines (MAS) under a recovery plan that includes even an Act of Parliament. Other key moves are migrating its operations, assets and liabilities to a new ...
Source: Business Times Singapore   Full article at: Business Times Singapore
 

 
Update
1

3 weeks ago

MAS posts loss of RM307m for Q2

Aug 28 2014 5:00pm CDT | Source: Business Times Singapore

August 29, 2014 1:13 AMMALAYSIA Airlines (MAS) registered a loss of RM307 million (S$122 million) for the second quarter to end-June, but warned of worse to come in the second half when the "full financial impact of the doubl ...
Source: Business Times Singapore   Full article at: Business Times Singapore
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

UN mission team to combat Ebola arrives in Africa
United Nations, Sep 23 (IANS) An advance team of the United Nations Mission for Ebola Emergency Response (UNMEER) has arrived in Ghana's capital Accra to set up the operation's headquarters, a UN spokesman said Monday.
 
 
Spanish Ebola patient in 'serious' condition
Madrid, Sep 23 (IANS) An Ebola affected Spanish missionary who was flown back from Sierra Leone was described as "serious" by the health authorities in Spain.
 
 
Alibaba raises $25 bn in history's biggest IPO
New York, Sep 22 (IANS/EFE) Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba collected $25 billion in the largest initial public offering ever after underwriters exercised an option to purchase additional shares, the company said Monday.
 
 
Ukraine to partially replace gas with heating oil
Kiev, Sep 22 (IANS) Ukraine will increase the use of heating oil in the county's energy mix to replace natural gas, Deputy Prime Minister Volodymyr Groysman said here Monday.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

FIFA member predicts 2022 World Cup will not be held in Qatar
Berlin, Sep 23 (IANS/EFE) A member of the executive committee of international soccer's governing body, FIFA, said Monday that he doubted the 2022 World Cup would be held in Qatar, on account of its high temperatures...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
UN agency steps up aid for 130,000 Syrian refugees
United Nations, Sep 23 (IANS) The UN Refugee Agency (UNHCR) has been stepping up assistance to the Turkish government to aid an estimated 130,000 Syrian Kurds who have crossed into Turkey since last Friday, the United...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
French national abducted in Algeria: France
Paris, Sep 23 (IANS) A French national was kidnapped in Algeria's Tizi Ouzou region Sunday, the French foreign ministry said Monday. "A French national was kidnapped on Sunday in Algeria, in the region of Tizi Ouzou,...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Charlie Sheen wants Two and a Half Men return
Charlie Sheen wants to reprise his role on 'Two and a Half Men'. The 49-year-old actor - who was fired from the show in 2011 after rowing with its producer Chuck Lorre and subsequently threatened him and Warner Bros...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Ariana Grande's life coach 'couldn't handle' her behaviour
Ariana Grande's life coach quit because he ''couldn't handle'' her bad attitude. According to the New York Post newspaper's Page Six column, the 21-year-old singer's former employee - who was in charge of keeping her...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Nicolas Cage slept in Dracula's castle
Nicolas Cage spent the night in Dracula's castle. According to the 50-year-old actor's 'Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance' co-star, Idris Elba, Nicolas opted to stay in the fictional vampire's home to ''channel his...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
David Hasselhoff: Justin Bieber is a 'cool guy'
David Hasselhoff thinks Justin Bieber is a ''cool guy''. The 'Baywatch' star confessed he had ''a lot of fun'' with the 20-year-old singer on the set of his latest video and claims the unlikely duo had ''a blast''...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Some American IS recruits are back in US: White House
Washington, Sep 23 (IANS/EFE) The Obama administration believes that some of the roughly 100 Americans who may have travelled to the Middle East to join the ranks of the Islamic State (IS) militant group have returned...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Now Bieber lives healthier lifestyle
Los Angeles, Sep 23 (IANS) Singer Justin Bieber, more popular for his off-stage antics rather than music, is reportedly embracing a healthier lifestyle and has given up alcohol. According The Sun newspaper, Bieber is...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Ukraine, rebels creates buffer zone amid new casualties
Kiev, Sep 23 (IANS) Ukrainian troops and independence-seeking rebels have started establishing a weapon-free buffer zone to separate the areas they control from each other, the country's military said Monday. "A...
Read more on Politics Balla