Demonizing One Percenters Ignores Their Social Good

Jan 22 2014, 9:17am CST | by

The New York Times continues its battle against people in the top 1 percent income bracket, through Paul Krugman’s latest warcry and a first-person essay from Sam Polk, an ex-Wall Streeter and recovering, self-diagnosed “Wealth Addict.”

Let’s start with Polk’s narrative. He’s a former hedge fund trader who chucked multi-million dollar bonuses to launch a non-profit organization with a wonderful mission to help low-income families fight obesity.

It’s fabulous that Polk found a meaningful life. And it’s true that many of the derivative products he criticizes are too opaque and complex for buyers and sellers. The “virtuous” origin of derivatives as a means to protect, say, farmers from weather aberrations, has morphed into something dangerous and harmful to Wall Street investors, and by contagion, Main Street. Those schemes can and should be reigned in.

Of course Polk’s free to pursue a life he finds rewarding. But it would have been fascinating to read about his recovery from “wealth addiction” while remaining inside the financial system instead of completely wrenching himself out at a young age. The irony about Polk’s switch to non-profit work is that someday he could write an equally scathing rebuke of mismanagement, cronyism and self-interest in 501c3-land. Perhaps someday he will.

And it seems he’s looking through an “either-or” lens. He’s dismissing the morality of capitalism, the realization that what he did as a trader added value to the world and lifted people out of poverty by creating wealth through efficient capital investment. Yes there are some shoddy financial instruments. But financial services firms could not stay in business if they weren’t adding substantial value.

This value provides infinitely more succor in the millennia of human history (and perhaps prevents more wars) than any government handout or NGO. Polk’s sinister portrayal of  hedge fund investors and workers doesn’t acknowledge that these people are big boys and girls who understand risk. We want to encourage “creative destruction” by these high net worth folks as a way of creating value for everyone else.

Polk urges his former Wall Street compatriots to either quit their jobs or pool some of their bonus money together for charitable causes. His rhetoric echoes Krugman, who lambastes what he calls “The Undeserving Rich,” those shameless, heartless cads in the top income brackets.

Yes, plenty 1 percenters are materialistic and superficial. And it’s true, as Krugman implies, that many 1 percenters personally behave in imprudent, dirty and self-indulgent ways that don’t help the cause of social conservatives seeking to restore the nuclear family and traditional values to help alleviate poverty. But these wealthy people, through either their smarts or birthright–as a friend jokes, those who “won the sperm lottery”– create undeniable value for those below them in the income ladder. And even if we dispersed all bonuses or taxed the uber-rich to equalize median household income levels, it would be merely a drop in the bucket compared to what a well-functioning economic machine does to help life from being nasty, brutish and short.

If wealth was perfectly distributed, there would be neither the incentive nor the ability for these high-risk projects to get off the ground. It wouldn’t be feasible to corral massive levels of capital if it were equally spread across households, many of which prefer to spend rather than invest. Inequality is the tradeoff for societal progress on a sustained upward, growth trajectory.

Krugman bemoans rising tuition costs at American universities, which makes it more difficult for low and middle-income kids to get an education. But he doesn’t point a finger at the university administrators–the one percenters who overwhelmingly donate to Democrats–who jack up the price of tuition above inflation, fueled by a massive expansion of government financial aid to students without proper financial training or cost/benefit analysis of whether their chosen field matches the new, information-based economy.

A primary trigger of the financial crisis was low-income folks taking out mortgages they couldn’t afford, pushed by regulators that sought to expand homeownership to unqualified buyers. We need to empower low-income folks with a comprehensive financial education to prevent such crises from happening again.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Modi among contenders for Time's Person of the Year
New York, Nov 20 (IANS) Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is in the list of 50 contenders for Time magazine's Person of the Year.
 
 
Atomic clock that fits in your pocket
Washington, Nov 20 (IANS) Researchers, including an Indian-origin scientist, are working on a highly accurate atomic clock the size of a Rubik's cube, measuring about 2 inches in each dimension.
 
 
New insight into cells may lead to better drugs
London, Nov 20 (IANS) In a significant revelation that may help scientists create better drugs, a team of British researchers have found how different types of immune cells communicate with each other and how they kill cancerous or infected cells.
 
 
Fragrant rice of Cambodia, Thailand named world's best
Phnom Penh, Nov 20 (IANS) Fragrant rice from Cambodia and Thailand was awarded the world's best rice for 2014 prize during the 6th World Rice Conference here Thursday.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Modi among contenders for Time's Person of the Year
New York, Nov 20 (IANS) Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is in the list of 50 contenders for Time magazine's Person of the Year. Time's Person of the Year will be announced Dec 10. Modi, "once a controversial...
Read more on Ad Balla
 
Indonesian police confirm virginity tests for female cadets
Bangkok, Nov 20 (IANS/EFE) Indonesian National Police Thursday confirmed carrying out virginity tests on female recruits to prove their physical and moral strength, a test that Human Rights Watch (HRW) has branded as...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Vettel joins Ferrari on three-year deal, Alonso exits
Maranello (Italy), Nov 20 (IANS) Four-time world champion Sebastian Vettel signed a three-year deal with Ferrari following Fernando Alonso's departure, the F1 team announced Thursday. The Italian team's driver line-up...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Duchess of Alba, aristocrat with most titles, dies at 88
Seville, Nov 20 (IANS/EFE) The Duchess of Alba, the aristocrat with most titles in the world and one of Spain's biggest fortunes, died Thursday in Seville at age 88 following a short illness, the city's Mayor, Juan...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Black Friday 2014 move to 11/21
Black Friday 2014 is going to be bigger than ever. Walmart and Amazon already begin their Black Friday 2014 sales events this Friday, November 21. This is Tomorrow. We are not talking about early Black Friday sales...
Read more on Black Friday Countdown
 
Seven stabbed to death in Chinese hospital
Beijing, Nov 20 (IANS/EFE) Seven people, six of them nurses, and one security officer, were stabbed to death Thursday in a hospital in northern China in the latest episode of violence in Chinese hospitals. The...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Three injured in US varsity shooting, gunman dead
Washington, Nov 20 (IANS/EFE) A gunman wounded at least three people in a shooting in the library of Florida State University (FSU) in Tallahassee before police shot him dead, authorities said Thursday. Mary Coburn,...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Nick Jonas: I'm not a virgin
Nick Jonas has confirmed he is no longer a virgin. The 22-year-old singer famously wore a purity ring - which symbolized a promise not to have sex before marriage - as a member of the Jonas Brothers, which he formed...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Kim Kardashian West would support North in 'anything'
Kim Kardashian West would ''support'' her daughter if she wants to pose nude when she grows up. The 34-year-old reality star recently bared all for Paper magazine and found the shoot ''empowering'', so wouldn't have a...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Zac Efron's solo fun
Zac Efron has joked he pleasures himself 17 times a day. The former 'High School Musical' star made the claim in a spoof interview with James Franco, who was appearing as his 'The Interview' character Dave Skylark, and...
Read more on Celebrity Balla