Will Death Suit Bring Über Big Liability For Uber?

Jan 28 2014, 7:11am CST | by

Will Death Suit Bring Über Big Liability For Uber?

America is a nation of laws and lawyers, yet the law often plays catch-up to technology. Although taxi companies complain of unfair competition, many cities and consumers react favorably to new smartphone ride-sharing choices Uber, Lyft and Sidecar. But if you are in an accident, you may not be so pleased, particularly if the liability is big and beyond the driver’s insurance limits.

Uber fans and foes alike know of the tragic death of a 6-year-old girl on New Year’s Eve in San Francisco. Sofia Liu was struck while walking across the street with her family. Several family members were injured too. The driver, Syed Muzzafar, faces charges of vehicular manslaughter with gross negligence and failure to yield.

Now, a wrongful death lawsuit has been filed against Uber. The suit claims that Uber is responsible for Sofia Liu’s death, saying that Mr. Muzzafar was on Uber’s app at the time of the accident. Uber says it isn’t responsible and notes that Mr. Muzzafar was not carrying a passenger at the time of the accident. See Statement on New Year’s Eve Accident.

Less serious lawsuits have ensnared Uber, Lyft or Sidecar. For example, in one lawsuit, Uber was sued along with the driver, Djamol Gafurov, whose insurance policy has a $750,000 limit. But the new suit is the first wrongful death case and the first involving big damages.

One of the direct liability issues is the vetting process the company uses with drivers. That is a type of direct liability about Uber’s own actions. Another is the extent to which drivers can import agency liability of the type that makes companies liable for the acts of employees.

The companies claim they merely take a fee for putting passengers and drivers together. The drivers have their own insurance, but a serious or fatal accident can involve millions in damages, far exceeding most driver insurance policies. Some say the Communications Decency Act prevents liability because these companies are information content providers.

But it is not far-fetched to imagine verdicts for injured plaintiffs. A close parallel can be found in suits involving independent contractors like many taxi and delivery drivers. If a taxi injuries someone, despite the “taxi leased to driver” on the door, the plaintiff is likely to sue the driver and the cab company.

Arguing that the independent contractor arrangement is a sham, the plaintiff may prevail. The same happens with newspaper carriers and other deliveries, including pizza. In Texas, Domino’s Pizza is appealing a $32M Verdict against it relating to a delivery driver who killed a 65 year-old woman.

The driver was liable, as was the independent Domino’s franchise store that sold the pizza. But the jury found Domino’s company (technically, the franchisor) liable too. One reason was because the driver was speeding to meet Domino’s corporate 30-minute delivery policy.

Interestingly, the wrongful death suit against Uber claims that drivers must respond quickly, and suggests this rule encourages carelessness. The policy may not be as concrete as Domino’s 30-minute guarantee, but it still could have a legal impact. Of course, the entire business model of Uber, Lyft and Sidecar is in its infancy. The courts may say they are simply not responsible.

However, one might look for parallels in the Domino’s case, as well as in taxicab and newspaper delivery cases from around the country. Legal issues aside, it seems likely that the cases will turn on their facts. The contracts and the actual course of conduct of the parties are likely to count, as should the status of the injured person.

After all, it may be one thing for a passenger in an Uber car to sue if he or she is injured. One might argue that an Uber passenger assumes the risk of ride sharing by signing on. But what about a pedestrian hit in a crosswalk? The pedestrian hasn’t agreed to any kind of arrangement with Uber.

There are taxicab, limo and package delivery cases that raise such issues. Admittedly, though, most involve the age-old line between independent contractors and employees. That line is pivotal on the agency liability a company faces when an employee (but not an independent contractor) acts up.

It is too soon to say how the Uber, Sidecar and Lyft liabilities will be sorted out. In the short term, though, as multiple cases work through multiple courts, the answer may not be a bright or consistent line.

You can reach me at Wood@WoodLLP.com. This discussion is not intended as legal advice, and cannot be relied upon for any purpose without the services of a qualified professional.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Christopher H. Skinner, Senior Associate, Squire Sanders to Speak at Knowledge Group's Iranian Sanctions for 2014 and Beyond Live Webcast
New York, NY, April 24, 2014 --(PR.com)-- The Knowledge Group/The Knowledge Congress Live Webcast Series, the leading producer of regulatory focused webcasts, has announced today that Christopher H. Skinner, Senior...
 
 
Is The Future Of Television Social?
Today at the Brand Innovators’ Future of Television conference in New York, social media expert Ted Rubin will be sharing his perspective on the symbiotic relationship between TV and social media. In advance of his...
 
 
How To Screw Up On Social Media
Election 2012: Billionaires Speak Out On Social Media It’s not just the small companies and amateurs that make mistakes on social media. The fresh example of the NYPD and its attempt to get people to put pictures of...
 
 
London Live's Disastrous Ratings: 2,400 Watch Breakfast Show In City Of 9million
Last month, I wrote for Forbes.com about the imminent arrival in London of a media first – a local TV channel devoted solely to the UK’s capital city. I’d already been behind the scenes at the channel before its March...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Christopher H. Skinner, Senior Associate, Squire Sanders to Speak at Knowledge Group's Iranian Sanctions for 2014 and Beyond Live Webcast
New York, NY, April 24, 2014 --(PR.com)-- The Knowledge Group/The Knowledge Congress Live Webcast Series, the leading producer of regulatory focused webcasts, has announced today that Christopher H. Skinner, Senior...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Is The Future Of Television Social?
Today at the Brand Innovators’ Future of Television conference in New York, social media expert Ted Rubin will be sharing his perspective on the symbiotic relationship between TV and social media. In advance of his...
Read more on Business Balla
 
How To Screw Up On Social Media
Election 2012: Billionaires Speak Out On Social Media It’s not just the small companies and amateurs that make mistakes on social media. The fresh example of the NYPD and its attempt to get people to put pictures of...
Read more on Business Balla
 
London Live's Disastrous Ratings: 2,400 Watch Breakfast Show In City Of 9million
Last month, I wrote for Forbes.com about the imminent arrival in London of a media first – a local TV channel devoted solely to the UK’s capital city. I’d already been behind the scenes at the channel before its March...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Report: A Year After Bangladesh Disaster, Retailers Fail To Address Biggest Factory Risks
When Sarah Labowitz arrived in Bangladesh’s capital city of Dhaka this past February, it certainly didn’t look like nine months had passed since the factory collapse that claimed 1,129 lives. Outside the ruin of the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
How A Car-Crazy Entrepreneur Turned A Lifetime Passion Into A Lifetime Career
Elo has loved cars since he was a child and uses his mechanical and design skills to create unique vehicles. His customisations are second to none and clients from across the world seek him out to revitalise their...
Read more on Auto Balla
 
ITF Seniors World Championships at Polo Club Boca Raton
Boca Raton, FL, April 24, 2014 --(PR.com)-- Polo Club Boca Raton Hosts Opening Ceremonies of the ITF Seniors World Championships Margaret Court Cup (Women Age 45) and Dubler Cup (Men Age 45) Competition: April 21-26...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Code for India Announces First Ever Simultaneous Hackathon Event in Bangalore and Mountain View
Mountain View, CA, April 24, 2014 --(PR.com)-- Engineers in US and India Team Come Together to Create Apps Making India More Resilient to Natural Disasters Code for India, the non-profit organization that inspires...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Tori Spelling: Sex life was 'very good'
Tori Spelling thought she had a "very, very good" sex life with Dean McDermott. The 'True Tori' star - who has children Liam, seven, Stella, five, Hattie, two, and Finn, 20 months, with her husband - was left stunned...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla