60 Minutes' Shortsighted Report On Cleantech And Vinod Khosla Is A Dangerous Attack On American Innovation

Jan 28 2014, 8:16pm CST | by


“Innovation distinguishes between a leader and a follower.” – Steve Jobs

About two weeks ago, 60 Minutes ran a story evaluating Vinod Khosla’s investments in the Cleantech industry and interviewed several industry “experts” about the financial performance of these early-stage companies. If we completely ignore the fact that 60 Minutes’ Leslie Stahl has numerous factual inaccuracies as pointed out by Vinod himself on the Khosla Ventures site, it is more striking to me that the debate over the actual motivation behind this story has not been more prevalent in subsequent dialogue. We are in a fragile time as a country: for each day that passes, China becomes more of an economic threat with a cheaper, more educated, and harder-working workforce. Our competitive advantage as a country is our comfort with taking risks on crazy ideas. The US has been the epicenter of technological innovation for the past century and that has only been the case because we invest in growth even when we don’t know if there will be a return in the future.

However, there has been a fundamental shift in our mindset over the past decade — the country as a whole has become more risk averse. Job growth is paramount as always, but speculative investments such as Cleantech are frowned upon to the point that the most “critically acclaimed” journalists are declaring war on speculators like Vinod. While there are divergent opinions about whether investing billions of dollars in unproven industries is a good idea or a bad idea, there is one truth that always holds true: from many failures comes few successes. Innovation is messy and only through learning can we be successful. I believe the majority of the scrutiny from Stahl is generally with regards to the US Government’s policy to pour $150+ Billion into cleantech. This is a valid concern, however, the amount of Government investment in Cleantech and growth industries is in no way comparative to the Government’s expenditures on zero growth industries such as agriculture subsidies.

Stahl’s scrutiny of venture capital and Khosla is significantly more risky than it seems. If the notion that venture capital is a scummy industry becomes common belief, we as a country will be at a drastic disadvantage to China and other competitive nations. In fact, it is possible that the reason a few of Khosla’s cleantech companies have struggled is because new investors are afraid and becoming more risk averse. I cannot stress that this behavior — which is characteristically un-American — is becoming more pervasive in the investment community. Venture investors are more focused on chasing trends and investing in markets that are developed rather than markets where there is little precedent.

Stahl prefaces her report with “the smart people who funded the Internet…have now turned their [sights] toward [cleantech]” and her tone echos shades of mockery rather than respect. She has preconceived disdain for investment in underdeveloped or “ experimental” markets. However, she fails to qualify that these cleantech investments are just as speculative and just as risky as investments in Apple or Sun Microsystems (the company Vinod founded along with Scott McNealy in the 80s). In fact, 60 Minutes has a track record of unnecessarily criticizing speculative and innovative companies — even going so far as to say Facebook would never figure out how to make money during an interview in 2007.

The media’s job is to explain complicated subjects to the mainstream and allow viewers to consider negative or positive implications of a situation. In this case, we see another example of sensationalism at the cost of innovation and growth in a new and undiscovered market. We ought to celebrate risk and celebrate our learnings through failure; we should never admonish people for attempting to improve the world, especially when those investments have the chance to reduce our reliance fossil fuels. If we’re ridiculed even for taking a risk, we’ll never improve.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Bryan Singer Accusation Raises Uncomfortable Questions About Which Movies We Choose To See
Bryan Singer Accusation Raises Uncomfortable Questions About Which Movies We Choose To See
No film is getting more publicity right now than X-Men: Days of Future Past. The Fox franchise has been the lowest earner of the Marvel series with no individual movie earning more than $500 million at the box office....
 
 
Sabre, Weibo Jump Through Closing IPO Window
Sabre, Weibo Jump Through Closing IPO Window
The two-year anniversary of Facebook’s 2012 IPO is just a month away, and if recent trends continue the demand for new offerings may start resembling the freeze that followed the social network’s debut. After that...
 
 
Russia Recession Not Out Of The Question
Investors won’t be surprised if the Market Vectors Russia (RSX) exchange traded fund wipes out Thursday’s nice 6.15% pop in the days head, as economic data out of Russia points to a slowdown. Or even worse: a recession...
 
 
How To Use A Secured Card To Rebuild Your Credit
Who among us hasn’t needed a second chance? Or a first opportunity? For the millions of Americans who were battered by the Great Recession and came out of it with a tattered credit score, plus the legions of young...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Bryan Singer Accusation Raises Uncomfortable Questions About Which Movies We Choose To See
No film is getting more publicity right now than X-Men: Days of Future Past. The Fox franchise has been the lowest earner of the Marvel series with no individual movie earning more than $500 million at the box office....
Read more on Business Balla
 
Sabre, Weibo Jump Through Closing IPO Window
The two-year anniversary of Facebook’s 2012 IPO is just a month away, and if recent trends continue the demand for new offerings may start resembling the freeze that followed the social network’s debut. After that...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Russia Recession Not Out Of The Question
Investors won’t be surprised if the Market Vectors Russia (RSX) exchange traded fund wipes out Thursday’s nice 6.15% pop in the days head, as economic data out of Russia points to a slowdown. Or even worse: a recession...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Janet Yellen's Lunchtime Speech -- The Market Heard a Dove, But That Wasn't the Message
At some point during Chair Yellen’s tenure people will likely begin to see the pragmatic central banker she has been. Wednesday’s luncheon speech to the Economic Club of New York was a step in that direction, once...
Read more on Auto Balla
 
Aereo CEO speaks on future of company, industry
NEW YORK (AP) — The future of Aereo, an online service that provides over-the-air TV channels, hinges on a battle with broadcasters that goes before the U.S. Supreme Court next week. For as little as $8 a...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
How To Use A Secured Card To Rebuild Your Credit
Who among us hasn’t needed a second chance? Or a first opportunity? For the millions of Americans who were battered by the Great Recession and came out of it with a tattered credit score, plus the legions of young...
Read more on Business Balla
 
An Egypt Expert Doesn't Share IMF's Hopeful View
Before you think that Gen. Abdul-Fatah al-Sisi’s booting of the Muslim Brotherhood from power and legitimacy in Egypt has restored a sort of Mubarak-y order, consider this week’s grim report:  The senior fellow for the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Why Brazil's Unemployment Rate Is So Low
The unemployment rate can baffle a Brazil watcher.  How can the economy be growing at its lowest level since the credit crisis of 2008-09, yet unemployment continue to decline. On Wednesday, Brazil’s unemployment...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Social Security's Proper Role In Your Retirement Plan
Could you live on Social Security? That seems to be a stock answer for many folks nearing retirement, and it’s a tremendously misguided view. According to the Social Security Administration’s latest statistical snapshot...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Kinder Morgan Energy Partners Named Top Dividend Stock With Insider Buying and 6.95% Yield (KMP)
In this series, we look through the most recent Dividend Channel ”DividendRank” report, and then we cherry pick only those companies that have experienced insider buying within the past six months. The officers and...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla