Charging Orders and the Contemptuous Partnership

Jan 30 2014, 11:59pm CST | by

Brothers Robert and Kenny Joslin owned an irrigation company together, Joshlin Brothers Irrigation, organized as a partnership. I’ll refer to that as the “Joshlin Partnership”.

Separately, Robert had an outside business unrelated to the partnership with his brother. For that other business, Robert borrowed some money from Sunbelt Rentals, failed to pay back Sunbelt Rentals, was sued by Sunbelt Rentals, and suffered a default judgment to Sunbelt Rentals.

To collect its judgment, Sunbelt Rentals obtained a Charging Order against Robert’s interest in the Joshlin Partnership. The terms of the Charging Order, as most do, specifically required the Joshlin Partnership to direct any payments that were due to Robert, to Sunbelt Rentals instead.

As a partner of the Joshlin Partnership, and in defiance of the Charging Order, Robert wrote checks to himself that were drawn on the Joshlin Partnership’s bank account.

Then, Robert committed suicide.

Sunbelt Rentals moved to hold the Joshlin Partnership in contempt. The Joshlin Partnership (read: surviving brother Kenny) argued that Robert’s actions were unauthorized and amounted to fraud by Robert on the Joshlin Partnership, and thus should not be imputed to it.

The trial court disagreed and held the Joshlin Partnership in contempt, and the Joshlin Partnership appealed.

I could talk about the appeal, but the bottom line is that the Joshlin Partnership didn’t raise any of its appellate arguments at the trial court level, and so they were all deemed waived.

ANALYSIS

The point of this case doesn’t go to any particular technical issue, but rather to how Charging Orders work in real life — as opposed to how they are usually wrongly described in asset protection seminars.

That point is that Charging Orders basically work to “seal up” the partnership (or LLC) from the debtor, so that the debtor can’t get any financial benefit from the partnership. If the debtor is due any benefit from the partnership, or the partnership pays or distributes something to the debtor, then it goes to the debtor’s creditor instead.

While Charging Orders are really very simple in theory, the actual language of such orders is often very long and complex, and covers everything to salary and management fees paid to the debtor, loans made to the debtor, payments of debtor’s credit cards, etc.

If the partnership violates the Charging Order, as here, then the partnership is in contempt — and to purge the contempt must make a like payment or distribution to the creditor to purge the contempt. Note that this means that the partnership can end up making what amounts to a “double payment”, i.e., one payment to the debtor and another to the creditor.

It is also important to note that a Charging Order binds the debtor. If the debtor receives something in violation of the Charging Order, the debtor must turn it over to the creditor immediately, or else face contempt.

However, a Charging Order does not allow a creditor to invade the assets of the partnership, so unless a payment or distribution is made to the debtor, the creditor gets nothing.

Of course, the debtor gets nothing, either, so then it can become a matter of who can wait the other out the longest. If the debtor needs funds from the partnership to live off of, as Robert apparently did in this case, the debtor is probably going to lose this standoff.

From the debtor-planning side, it is usually better to give the debtor a fixed salary. That way, the debtor will get some money to live off of, as the creditor’s garnishment of the debtor’s wages is limited to 25% of the debtor’s disposable income. Yes, the creditor will get some money, but considerable pressure will be off the debtor./>/>

If you go to most of the asset protection seminars that are advertised in the sports pages or wherever, the speakers will usually talk about “Charging Order Protection” with great glee, and then with a wink and a nod hint around that even if a Charging Order is entered, the debtor will still have some ways of getting money out of the partnership.

Maybe, but more likely, maybe not. The Courts have little sympathy for debtors who play games instead of paying their debts, and as shown here, the contempt remedy is available against partnerships (and LLCs) that make payments to debtors in violation of Charging Orders.

Stashing valuable assets in a partnership or LLC without other significant structuring might just be putting assets into a lockbox for the the benefit of creditors, until the pressure on the debtor to pay builds up to where it is unbearable.

And that is nothing to wink and nod about.

 CITE AS

Joshlin Bros. Irrigation v. Sunbelt Rental, Inc., 2014 WL 248104, 2014 Ark. App. 65 (Ark.App., Unpublished, Jan. 22, 2014). Full Opinion at  http://goo.gl/aHI0tk

This article at http://onforb.es/1iRVXRE and http://goo.gl/Ed5xXD

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Soyuz rocket carrying two Galileo satellites lifts off
Brussels, Aug 22 (IANS) A Soyuz rocket carrying two Galileo satellites, the fifth and sixth of Europe's Galileo global satellite navigation system, lifted off from the spaceport in French Guiana Friday, the European Space Agency (ESA) has announced.
 
 
Fresh cases of Ebola recorded in Nigeria: Official
Abuja, Aug 22 (IANS) Fresh cases of the Ebola virus disease have been recorded in Nigeria, where the highly contagious disease has already claimed five lives, Minister of Health Onyebuchi Chukwu said Friday.
 
 
Fuel cell technology gets a boost
Washington, Aug 22 (IANS) In an impetus for fuel cell technology to build "smart" cars, scientists at Stanford University have developed a low-cost, emissions-free device that uses an ordinary AAA battery to produce hydrogen by water electrolysis.
 
 
3D-printed technology to make drug delivery better
Washington, Aug 22 (IANS) The US researchers have developed an innovative method for using affordable, consumer-grade 3D printers and materials to fabricate custom medical implants that can contain antibacterial and chemotherapeutic compounds for targeted drug delivery.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Pakistan: Tensions ease as PTI agrees to resume talks (Roundup)
Islamabad, Aug 22 (IANS) Tensions in the Pakistani political landscape eased Friday with the Imran Khan-led Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) party agreeing to return to the negotiating table as the Senate or the upper...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Ukrainian rebels kill four soldiers
Kiev, Aug 22 (IANS) At least four security personnel have been killed and 23 wounded in clashes with rebels in eastern Ukraine, authorities said Friday. Four Ukrainian servicemen were killed Thursday overnight in...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Miley Cyrus concert banned in Dominican Republic
Santo Domingo, Aug 22 (IANS/EFE) The Dominican Republic government has banned a concert where US pop star Miley Cyrus was scheduled to perform in the nation's capital Sep 13. In a notice sent to the SD Concerts and...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
George Clooney's ex Elisabetta Canalis engaged
George Clooney's ex Elisabetta Canalis has got engaged. The 35-year-old beauty is set to tie the knot with Brian Perri in Italy next month, as is George and his new fiancée Amal Alamuddin, after the orthopedic surgeon...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Mariah Carey's jealously to blame for split?
Mariah Carey's jealousy is reportedly partly to blame for her and Nick Cannon's split. The 44-year-old singer is said to have trust issues with her spouse - with whom she has four-year-old twins Moroccan and Monroe -...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Jessica Alba is 'fearless' after motherhood
Jessica Alba has become ''fearless'' since motherhood. The 33-year-old actress admits her whole perspective of her career has changed since welcoming her daughter Honor, six, and Haven, three, into the world with her...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Daniel Radcliffe wants fans to forget Harry Potter
Daniel Radcliffe wants his fans to forget about 'Harry Potter'. The 25-year-old actor is currently starring in romantic comedy 'What If', and despite its success, the actor is resigned to the fact the comparisons to his...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Hamas executes 18 alleged collaborators with Israel
Gaza, Aug 22 (IANS/EFE) Palestinian militias Friday executed 18 people accused of collaborating with Israel, 48 hours after three top military leaders of the Islamic Palestinian movement Hamas were killed in an Israeli...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
27 killed in CAR gold mine collapse
Yaounde, Aug 22 (IANS) At least 27 miners have been killed in a gold mine collapse in the Central African Republic (CAR), authorities said Friday. The Ndassima mine is situated 400 km north of the country's capital...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Austrian humanitarian aid for 100,000 people in Iraq
Vienna, Aug 22 (IANS/WAM) The Austrian government has approved one million euros ($1.3 million) in emergency aid from the Foreign Disaster Relief Fund (FDRF) to the UN in northern Iraq, the country's foreign ministry...
Read more on Politics Balla