Sour Grapes From Some Conservatives On The MyRA

Feb 5 2014, 3:47pm CST | by

Sour Grapes From Some Conservatives On The MyRA

It’s been a week since President Obama’s “State of the Union” speech where he detailed a new savings plan for lower-income families called the “myRA.”

Since then, it’s come under fire from some conservative quarters: the Wall Street Journal editorial page, the Cato Institute’s Dan Mitchell, and pundit Star Parker to name a few.  Each of these middling-to-negative reviews of the myRA come down to two things: the myRA is a not a carve-out Social Security personal account; the myRA is created by government and therefore is suspect.

First, to acknowledge the obvious: the myRA is really thin gruel for the working poor compared to, say, large Social Security personal accounts.  MyRA dollars have to come from workers’ own after-tax earnings, whereas Social Security personal accounts could be funded using payroll tax dollars these workers are already losing.  And it’s fair to be skeptical (even highly skeptical) of government-originated solutions to public policy problems.

But both those concerns are off-base with regard to the myRA.

First, Social Security personal accounts a’int happening.  It not only takes a Republican House to pass the idea and a Republican president to sign it into law, it also takes a Republican Senate with at least 60 pro-account votes (unless Harry Reid makes this easier by triggering the nuclear option on legislative filibusters, too).  Even if you’re bullish on GOP White House prospects in 2016, no one but no one thinks the GOP will sniff 60 votes in the Senate for at least a decade, if ever.  Back in 2005, President Bush couldn’t even get a GOP House to vote on personal accounts, much less pass them.

Second, the myRA doesn’t have the same mandate/paternalism problems that most of these think tank-bred schemes tend toward.

  • Nothing new is really being created: these are basically Roth IRAs with a new name.  That means after-tax money goes in, and the money grows tax-free for retirement.  Contributions could be withdrawn under the usual Roth IRA rules
  • It’s only available in workplaces that don’t have a 401(k) or other retirement plan
  • Employers only participate if they want to
  • Employees of these willing employers only participate if they want to
  • Financial institutions only participate if they want to
  • The bulk of the cost will be picked up by the willingly-participating financial institutions
  • Once a participant’s myRA reaches $15,000, they are required to transfer it over to a big boy Roth IRA in the real world

The only role for government (besides being the host of the myRA party) is to provide the financial instruments–Treasury debt, something the government makes available in all sorts of innovative ways from time to time (think war bonds and what your grandma put in your sock drawer).  The bonds in question will be like the “G Fund” option available today in the federal employee Thrift Savings Program.  Nothing particularly statist there.

From a bigger picture perspective, this myRA effort represents the best shot we have of not only getting the working poor into the retirement savings game, but also getting at least a few of them to join what President George W. Bush called the “investor class.”

According to the Employee Benefits Research Institute, fully one-third of workers at large and medium-sized firms don’t participate in workplace retirement plans.  It’s even worse at very small firms, where two-thirds of employees don’t save anything at work for retirement.  Social Security personal accounts are not on the way for these people, and there’s a very good chance they will spend much or all of their working careers saving nothing for retirement.

The myRA is a start, a baby step in the direction of responsible financial planning.  Workers can start an account for as little as $25, and can contribute as little as $5 per pay period.  There would be no fees, as the firms administering these accounts would use them as a loss leader to attract potentially profitable customers of tomorrow.  Once an account hits $15,000 and the owner has to leave the myRA nest, the odds are very good that this policy will have created another mutual fund or ETF owner.

Conservatives would do well to acknowledge that even a broken clock tells the right time twice a day.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Bird flu hits third poultry farm in Netherlands
The Hague, Nov 22 (IANS) An outbreak of bird flu was detected at a third Dutch poultry farm, the country's ministry of economic affairs announced Friday.
 
 
Hollande to visit Guinea next week, focus on fighting Ebola
Paris, Nov 22 (IANS) French President Francois Hollande will visit the West African countries next week, including the Ebola-hit Guinea-Conakry Nov 28 and will focus on ways to eradicate the deadly virus, media reported Friday.
 
 
Carla Bruni to lend voice to combat Ebola
Paris, Nov 22 (IANS/EFE) Former model and former first lady of France, Carla Bruni, will lend her voice to the French version of the song "Do They Know It's Christmas?" to raise funds to help combat Ebola.
 
 
Spanish health worker flown home after possible Ebola contagion
Madrid, Nov 21 (IANS) A Spanish health worker with Doctors Without Borders (MSF) arrived back in Spain Friday morning from Mali after being deemed at risk of contagion from the Ebola virus.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Noel Gallagher gave up cocaine because he was 'bored'
Los Angeles, Nov 22 (IANS) Singer Noel Gallagher says that while he still enjoys a bit of alcohol and cigarette, he no longer takes cocaine because he got "bored". The 47-year-old says that he spent hours "talking...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Bahrain set for first election since 2011 protests
Manama, Nov 22 (IANS) Bahrain will hold its first parliamentary elections Saturday, since a failed protest against the monarchy in 2011, though the Shiite opposition has called for a boycott of the elections. About...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Fiji a sincere friend and important partner: China
Nadi (Fiji), Nov 22 (IANS) China sees Fiji as a sincere friend and an important partner in the Pacific Islands region, Chinese President Xi Jinping said, during his visit to the island country. The Chinese president...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Ricki Lake's estranged husband wants prenup to be thrown out
Ricki Lake's estranged husband wants a judge to invalidate their prenuptial agreement. The talk show host, who filed for divorce from Christian Evans on October 16 after two and a half years of marriage, citing...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Jennifer Aniston says losing weight wasn't easy
Jennifer Aniston admits it wasn't easy to lose weight after filming 'Cake'. The 45-year-old actress ''just didn't work out for two-and-a-half months'' and relaxed her healthy diet to prepare for her role in the upcoming...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Chris Pine has more respect for Broadway
Chris Pine has more respect for Broadway stars after taking singing lessons for 'Into The Woods'. The 34-year-old actor, who stars in the upcoming movie adaptation of Stephen Sondheim's Tony Award-winning musical '...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Cody Simpson reunites with Gigi Hadid?
Cody Simpson and Gigi Hadid have sparked rumors they're back together. The 17-year-old singer and the 19-year-old model, who split in May after a year of dating due to their busy schedules, were reportedly ''inseparable...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
I felt the pressure of classism as child: Hilary Swank
Los Angeles, Nov 22 (IANS) Actress Hilary Swank says that she felt like an "outsider" at school because of her humble background. "I think we've all felt like an outsider at some point in our lives, and for me,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Sharif urges Obama to take up Kashmir issue with India
Islamabad, Nov 22 (IANS) US President Barack Obama spoke to Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif over telephone Friday and urged him to take up the Kashmir issue with India. Sharif said an early resolution of the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Bayern Munich's Schweinsteiger to be back in action
Berlin, Nov 22 (IANS) Bayern Munich midfielder Bastian Schweinsteiger will recover in time for Saturday's Bundesliga home game against Hoffenheim. Bayern coach Pep Guardiola confirmed Schweinsteiger's return, but did...
Read more on Sport Balla