Senate GOP Obamacare Replacement Is A Net Tax Cut

Feb 6 2014, 3:43pm CST | by

Senate GOP Obamacare Replacement Is A Net Tax Cut

Last week, three GOP senators–Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, Richard Burr of North Carolina, and Orrin Hatch of Utah–unveiled the latest “repeal and replace” Obamacare plan.  One of the key questions people are asking is whether this plan (dubbed the “Patient Care Act“) is a net tax cut, a net tax hike, or revenue-neutral.

Welcome to the Party

The first thing to say is that this is the third major Obamacare replacement plan which has been introduced.  The House conservative “Republican Study Committee” introduced H.R. 3121, “The American Health Care Reform Act” last year with Congressman Phil Roe (R-Tenn.) taking the lead.  Before that, Congressman and doctor Tom Price (R-Ga.) introduced H.R. 2300, the “ Empowering Patients First Act” (Senator John McCain has since introduced the Senate version, S. 1851).

Each of these bills is different in many ways.  Some anticipate using exchanges, and some do not.  Some like tax credits, and some like tax deductions.  Conservatives looking for an Obamacare alternative might like one bill or the other, or might want to build their own Frankenstein monster out of pieces from all three plans.  But they all have the most important part in common: Title I of each bill is a repeal of the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare.

Three Families of Tax Cuts

From a tax perspective, repealing Obamacare gets each bill off to a good start.  According to the best/latest numbers we have from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), repealing the 20 new or higher taxes in Obamacare results in a net tax cut of $1 trillion over a decade (it’s likely quite a bit larger than that since the score is a couple of years old).  The individual and employer mandate penalties, the saver and investor surtax, the Medicare payroll tax hike, the “medicine cabinet tax,” etc. all add up.  Each bill deserves credit for this very large gross tax cut.

The Patient Care Act has two other tax relief provisions on top of Obamacare repeal.  The first is some common-sense enhancements to health savings accounts (HSAs).  The most important reform here is allowing HSA-qualified health insurance premiums to be paid for directly out of an HSA, giving a tax benefit to any American purchasing HSA-qualified coverage.  This is perhaps a tax cut over a decade of an additional $10 to $15 billion.

The bill’s other tax relief provision is a hybrid of spending and taxes.  A new tax credit is created which phases out at three times the federal poverty level (about $36,000 for a single person and $71,000 for a family of four).  Essentially, this tax credit provides a bridge between exiting Medicaid and being able to more comfortably afford health insurance.  The credit is advanceable (meaning it lowers insurance premiums in real time) and refundable (meaning the recipient gets the credit irrespective of income tax liability).  Because credit recipients in this income band are unlikely to have much of an income tax liability at all, this tax credit should score out as mostly spending, with some tax relief effects.  It’s still safe to say, however, that the tax cut effects of this credit should come out to somewhere between $25 to $50 billion over a decade.

So there’s three families of tax cuts in the Patient Care Act: Obamacare repeal, HSA expansion, and the creation of a credit.  Altogether, that amounts to (roughly) $1.1 trillion to $1.2 trillion in tax relief over the ten-year scoring window.


Capping Employer-Provided Health Insurance’s Exclusion from Taxation

Offsetting this is one and only one gross tax increase.  Under the Patient Care Act, the amount of employer-provided health insurance that employees could exclude from their taxable income would be capped.  This cap would be set at 65 percent of the average market price for an expensive, high-option plan.  To the extent an employee receives health coverage at work above this cap, the employee would have to pay taxes on the compensation like they do on wages.

Because the plan is currently only in detailed outline form, this portion of it is less clear (e.g., 65 percent of what?).  But we can take a cue from one of the tax increases contained in Obamacare itself.  Starting in 2018, Obamacare is supposed to impose a 40 percent excise tax on “Cadillac plans” (defined as those costing more than about $10,000 for singles or about $28,000 for families).  This is expected to raise about $400 billion to $500 billion in tax revenue over the first ten years of its existence.

Just to be pessimistic and to give the Patient Care Act the strictest of scrutiny, let’s double that revenue estimate for their plan.  Under a worst case but still reasonable scenario, let’s say that their employer coverage cap raises $800 billion to $1 trillion in taxes.

A Net Tax Cut

What results, of course, is a net tax cut.  The Patient Care Act raises taxes by (at most) $1 trillion over a decade, and cuts taxes by (at least) $1.1 trillion over a decade.

Therefore, the Patient Care Act is not only not a tax increase–it’s a tax cut.  How large a tax cut is still to be determined by full legislative language, but it’s in that territory.

Plan authors have also said publicly and privately that if they get a surprise score from the Congressional Budget Office, they will re-jigger the plan accordingly to make certain it’s not a net tax increase.  I very much doubt they will have to do that.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Pebble Is Winning The Wearables War and What That Means For The iWatch
Some suggestive data indicates that the Pebble smartwatch, which sold 400,000 units in 2013, has the most staying power of the first batch of consumer wearables. null Want a clear indication that what these numbers show...
 
 
Sberbank Denies Funding Pro-Russia 'Terrorists' In East Ukraine
As chapters in the Russia-Ukraine political drama unfold, Russia’s largest bank takes center stage. Sberbank, Russia’s largest, is being investigated by Ukraine’s Attorney General for allegedly paying Ukrainian soldiers...
 
 
Cyphort Adding Context To Advanced Malware Detection
Cyphort Adding Context To Advanced Malware Detection
This series of articles and the accompanying videos are part of an ongoing project to illuminate the people, products, and vendors that make up the IT security industry. The vendors paid a fee to cover the expense of...
 
 
Hearthstone vs. Rollercoaster Tycoon 4: The Battle For The Soul Of Mobile Games
It’s been an interesting month for mobile games, one that I believe clearly illustrates a split for the scene with the release of two high profile games, Blizzard’s Hearthstone and Atari’s RollerCoaster Tycoon 4....
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Melissa Joan Hart: Celebrity pressure is gym motivation
Melissa Joan Hart admits the pressure of being a celebrity encourages her to go to the gym. The 38-year-old actress - who gained 60lbs while pregnant with her third child in 2012 - recently lost a dramatic 40lbs and...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
iPad Sales Predicted to Decrease in Q2 2014
The iPad might be unable to generate a blockbuster sale in the second quarter of 2014, as a new report claims that the device might experience a declined sale in the specific period.The report has been published by...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
New Photos Reveal the iPad Air 2 with Integrated Front Panel and Display
The next model of iPad Air might get a thinner shape, as a number of photos reveal that the device will include its front panel integrated with the display, rather than being separated.The photos have been unveiled by...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Pebble Is Winning The Wearables War and What That Means For The iWatch
Some suggestive data indicates that the Pebble smartwatch, which sold 400,000 units in 2013, has the most staying power of the first batch of consumer wearables. null Want a clear indication that what these numbers show...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Sberbank Denies Funding Pro-Russia 'Terrorists' In East Ukraine
As chapters in the Russia-Ukraine political drama unfold, Russia’s largest bank takes center stage. Sberbank, Russia’s largest, is being investigated by Ukraine’s Attorney General for allegedly paying Ukrainian soldiers...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Cyphort Adding Context To Advanced Malware Detection
This series of articles and the accompanying videos are part of an ongoing project to illuminate the people, products, and vendors that make up the IT security industry. The vendors paid a fee to cover the expense of...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Hearthstone vs. Rollercoaster Tycoon 4: The Battle For The Soul Of Mobile Games
It’s been an interesting month for mobile games, one that I believe clearly illustrates a split for the scene with the release of two high profile games, Blizzard’s Hearthstone and Atari’s RollerCoaster Tycoon 4....
Read more on Business Balla
 
Insurers Fret Hepatitis C Pill Costs Along With Obamacare
As health insurance companies reveal much anticipated first-quarter earnings, it’s the unpredictable impact from the five-figure cost of new Hepatitis C treatments that are the subject of as much  Wall Street worry as...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Friday Box Office: 'Heaven Is For Real' Earns $7.85M, Johnny Depp's 'Transcendence' Flops
Heaven Is For Real is to The Grudge as God’s Not Dead is to The Ring. As the first major Christian-centric film to drop after the surprisingly successful God’s Not Dead, Heaven Is For Real got to capitalize on being the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
The Wealthiest Are Getting Wealthier Three Times Faster Than Any Other Group
The denizens of Forbes’ 400 Rich List and Billionaire’s Row would have been ecstatic yesterday when French economist Thomas Piketty, much-heralded author of “Capital in the Twenty-First Century” made his debut at the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla