A Dangerous WSJ Column On 'Collective' U.S.-Japan Defense

Feb 13 2014, 3:03am CST | by

A Dangerous WSJ Column On 'Collective' U.S.-Japan Defense

Warning: Reading The Wall Street Journal on China-Japan relations is dangerous to your intellectual health. Exhibit: the Review & Outlook (Asia) column entitled “A ‘Collective’ U.S.-Japan Defense” published on February 5, 2014.

What kind of East Asia do the people of this region yearn for and deserve? No thought is required to answer:  a region of harmony, peace and security.

That the editors of the Wall Street Journal do hot share this view, do not sympathize with it, or do not believe that it is possible, is evident in this column. Like an unfortunately large number of foreign interested parties, the WSJ seems able to conceive of only two conditions of Asian interstate relations:  armed-to-the-teeth standoff Cold War, or hot war.

An unchallengeable U.S.-Japan military alliance as the “cornerstone” of the U.S. and Japanese relations, and military power as the principle (or at least the key) element in political relations, are the organizing principles for both U.S. and Japanese bi-lateral and regional policy,  according to the WSJ’s view.

That the WSJ is faithfully representing the Pentagon and the rest of the U.S. and Japanese political-military-industrial complexes is obvious.

Also obvious is that the WSJ’s view–again, unfortunately, representing a broad range of deeply entrenched bureaucratic, political and economic vested interests–creates a convenient self-fulfilling prophesy, as a “national security” militarized approach and mentality by Japan and the U.S. inevitably engenders a militarized response from the regional counterparties–especially (as everyone must and does expect) China.

In the February 5 column, the WSJ writes:

“U.S. and Chinese officials continue to spar over China’s recent declaration of a huge new air-defense zone, which makes even more important Shinzo Abe’s move to reinterpret the Japanese constitution and end a 67-year ban on collective self-defense….

“Because of the way the constitution’s Article 9 is interpreted now, Japanese forces could do nothing to help the U.S. if it were under attack. That’s especially relevant given North Korea’s nuclear and missile programs….”

The point is correctly made that the U.S.-Japan “Mutual Defense Treaty” has never really been “mutual.” Article 9 prohibits Japan from possessing army, navy, or air forces and foreswears the use of force to resolve international disputes. The “interpretation” of the Constitution that has allowed “self defense forces” is clearly a violation of both the letter and spirit of the constitution.

The WSJ column continues:

“The two countries are now revising their bilateral defense guidelines, and past revisions have expanded Japan’s role in support of U.S. operations in a regional crisis… and the U.S. has in the past urged Japan to move toward collective self-defense….”

Yes, U.S. pressure on Japan’s military to build or buy more weapons, increase troop levels, expand missions, and generally to increasingly adopt an offensive, rather than defensive capability and raison d’etre is long standing. (And this is always ‘incremental’ within the alliance. Never considered is a substantial reduction in U.S. forces or bases in Japan or in the USD 2 billion paid annually by Japan to the Pentagon. On the contrary, in the case the “relocation” of the Futenma U.S. Marine airbase what is really happening is building of a huge new base the use of which will be unrestricted.)

With the Pentagon and, now, under Abe, Tokyo defense bureaucracies, the only choice is between more and deadlier armaments and offensive reach, and much more of both. “Collective defense” would have Japan attacking and submitting itself to attacks in circumstances where it had not been attacked first and could have avoided hostilities.

The WSJ continues with painfully familiar breast-beating, Cold War rhetoric:

“The principle that democracies should band together to face the threat of dictatorships is a linchpin of the post-World War II world order…The rise of China is putting stress on this Pax Americana, as the Obama Administration’s ‘pivot’ implicitly acknowledges. Washington now needs its allies to work cooperatively, not merely as spokes on a security wheel.”

And, so there can be no mistake, this line:

“…. A coalition of democracies could be a more effective counterweight to China’s encroaching militarism.”

We must ask: “More effective that what?” “The status quo?” The WSJ is blind to the militarism of its own mentality and approach, as well as to the essential militarism of the U.S. alliance system in Asia, with its “cornerstone” of U.S. bases, including the headquarters and the Seventh Fleet, and some 100,000 force personnel in Japan and South Korea.

But it is not militarism that most concerns the WSJ, it is the absence of militarism and the desire of almost all the people in Japan to avoid war, a people who–unlike most Americans–know the horrors of modern war in their own country.

The WSJ continues:  “….Japan can fill the breach if it can navigate the tricky politics. The majority of the Japanese public is against collective self-defense…. While Mr. Abe probably can get the votes, New Komeito might then leave the government. One possible scenario is a reorganization of Japan’s parties in which right-of-center elements in the opposition come over to the LDP.”

This may, indeed, happen. Abe, seizing the chance provided by the crisis in relations with China–a crisis caused by Japan’s “nationalization” of the Senkaku/Diaoyu islands and exacerbated by U.S. policies–may succeed in getting the constitutional “reinterpretation” he wants to permit “collective defense” with the U.S.

But this will be a great and grave (though not uncorrectable) mistake. What most Japanese believe is that modern war is, and must remain, unconscionable and unthinkable, a non-option. They are right and just to so believe.

The natural and correct path for Japan today and tomorrow is pacifism and essential neutrality between the United States and China. Advancing along this path requires abrogating the U.S.-Japan “alliance,” not expanding it through a doctrine of “collective defense.”

Abe’s “collective defense” initiative should be defeated, and the Cold Warriors at the WSJ should be retired.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Global Ad Men, Techies Salivate Over Death Of Television
Global Ad Men, Techies Salivate Over Death Of Television
Your television is now nothing but an extension of your X Box One. And from there, you’ll be hooked into Netflix or Hulu, or if you’re in China, maybe Youku. But it won’t be ABC in Sydney or CBS in New York or NDTV in...
 
 
The NBA's Top-Selling Jerseys: Public Perception Beats Stats And How The League Must Respond
Today the NBA released a list of the league’s most popular jerseys for the 2013-14 season based up on sales of players’ jerseys on NBAStore.com.  While the names of the 15 players who made the list arguably are not...
 
 
Advisors Versus Directors: How to Build Better Boards
Advisors Versus Directors: How to Build Better Boards
Putting together a board of directors or advisors is an opportunity. It shouldn’t be considered a hassle. It’s a rare chance to build a qualified pool of loyal mentors and colleagues who care that you succeed, in part...
 
 
Forbes Five Hip-Hop Richlist 2014: Aftermath & Analysis
Forbes Five Hip-Hop Richlist 2014: Aftermath & Analysis
The Forbes Five: Hip-Hop's Wealthiest Artists 2014 Sean “Diddy” Combs topped the latest edition of the Forbes Five list of hip-hop’s wealthiest acts with a fortune of $700 million, and in a little over 24 hours since...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Rachel Weisz and Daniel Craig want a baby
Rachel Weisz and Daniel Craig want to have a baby. The couple, who tied the knot in a secret ceremony in New York City in front of just four guests, including the 'Skyfall' star's daughter Ella, 22, and the actress' son...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Global Ad Men, Techies Salivate Over Death Of Television
Your television is now nothing but an extension of your X Box One. And from there, you’ll be hooked into Netflix or Hulu, or if you’re in China, maybe Youku. But it won’t be ABC in Sydney or CBS in New York or NDTV in...
Read more on Business Balla
 
The NBA's Top-Selling Jerseys: Public Perception Beats Stats And How The League Must Respond
Today the NBA released a list of the league’s most popular jerseys for the 2013-14 season based up on sales of players’ jerseys on NBAStore.com.  While the names of the 15 players who made the list arguably are not...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Advisors Versus Directors: How to Build Better Boards
Putting together a board of directors or advisors is an opportunity. It shouldn’t be considered a hassle. It’s a rare chance to build a qualified pool of loyal mentors and colleagues who care that you succeed, in part...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Forbes Five Hip-Hop Richlist 2014: Aftermath & Analysis
The Forbes Five: Hip-Hop's Wealthiest Artists 2014 Sean “Diddy” Combs topped the latest edition of the Forbes Five list of hip-hop’s wealthiest acts with a fortune of $700 million, and in a little over 24 hours since...
Read more on Business Balla
 
When Experience Is Worth More Than Cash: The Rise Of The Entrepreneur-Investor
Startups, they’re so needy. A check from an angel investor or venture capital firm doesn’t quite cut it anymore. Founders are increasingly looking for hands on operational help and industry expertise as well, according...
Read more on Business Balla
 
'Captain America' Tops $500 Million To Surpass Other Superhero Franchises
As you know by now, Marvel’s Captain America: The Winter Soldier opened to a record-shattering $95 million domestic, while overseas it scored massive back-to-back weekends, bringing its worldwide total to $302 million...
Read more on Business Balla
 
SEC Halts TelexFree Pyramid Scheme
The Securities and Exchange Commission has announced it has filed charges against TelexFREE, Inc. and TelexFREE, LLC (“TelexFREE”), accusing the companies of orchestrating a massive pyramid scheme that targeted...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Social Networking Is One Thing, But What About Business To Business Networking?
LinkedIn has always been recognized as the go-to social media platform for business-minded individuals that want to network with others. It has served as a great way for entrepreneurs to publicize their credentials and...
Read more on Business Balla
 
How A False Sense Of Security Can Doom Job Seekers
By Jayne Mattson, Next Avenue Contributor It’s great to have a positive outlook if you’re an unemployed job seeker. But being unrealistically optimistic, assuming you’ll get hired immediately, is just setting yourself...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla