No, An Apple Device Won't Tell You If You're Having A Heart Attack

Feb 17 2014, 12:13pm CST | by

No one knows for sure but Apple appears to be strongly interested in adding medical applications and technologies to its current and future products. We know that Apple has patented a heart sensor that could be incorporated in a future iPhone or iWatch, though it seems more likely that it would be used for security rather than health purposes. We also know that top Apple executives have met with FDA commissioner Margaret Hamburg and top FDA device regulators, though the details of their discussion have not been disclosed.

But one new report on SF Gate is almost certainly wrong: an Apple device won’t be able to tell you if you’re about to have a heart attack.

 Apple is exploring ways to measure noise “turbulence” as it applies to blood flow. The company wants to develop software and sensors that can predict heart attacks by identifying the sound blood makes as it tries to move through an artery clogged with plaque, the source said.

Even with Apple’s astonishing $150 billion cash reservoir, this type of advance seems unlikely any time soon. Cardiovascular researchers have been working for decades trying to find better ways to accurately predict heart attacks. They’ve learned a lot over the years but there’s nothing that’s even close to clinical reality.

I asked a bunch of cardiologists for their thoughts. None thought very highly of the prospect.

Sameer Bansilal, a cardiologist at Mt. Sinai in New York, said:

While its enticing to imagine that the watch will magically predict heart attacks, the reality is that such sensors rely on surrogates such as heart rate, sympathetic tone and peripheral vascular resistance which can only provide part of the story, let alone predict a specific artery being clogged.

Dave Albert, the inventor of the AliveCor mobile ECG,

Heart Attacks occur most often when a coronary plaque ruptures, creating a clot and obstructing blood flow to the heart. This obstruction in the coronary arteries has NOTHING to do with turbulent blood flow in the radial or ulnar arteries in the wrist.

(The AliveCor is a great example of mobile health technology now available in the real world. Just last week the company announced that it had gained FDA clearance to market the device over-the-counter. Previously, purchase of the device had required a physician’s prescription.)

Even Eric Topol, a well-known cardiologist and technology evangelist who is often enthusiastic about new technology, thinks this method is unlikely to fulfill the hype. In a tweet he said, “We’d all like to get this done, but this method unlikely.”

But these negative remarks shouldn’t suggest that the converging trends of wearable computers and improved biosensors won’t be important. I suspect that new devices– in your pocket, on your wrist, in your eyeglasses– will eventually bring a new computing revolution, and there can be little question that health care will be transformed along with everything else. But for now I wouldn’t count on new technology to tell you when and if you are having a heart attack.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Solaire Shines Light On Philippine Casino Ambitions
The Philippines hopes to be the next big thing in Asian gaming, and its biggest step toward that goal just completed its first year of operation. Solaire Resort and Casino opened in March last year (see page 77; payment...
 
 
Innovators In The UK: Male, Affluent And Long-Term Planners
For decades, innovation policy has been the domain of technocrats and of party–political consensus. Whilst in other fields – such as science – regular surveys help inform public debate and policy-making, there has been...
 
 
Want To Earn $5,000? Stop Working
If you work for Amazon, Jeff Bezos will pay you a bonus of up to $5,000.  Generous, right?  And what do you have to do to get the bonus? Quit your job. It may seem crazy, but it’s true – a recent article in Time notes...
 
 
Your Local Mall, Re-digitized
As part of the never-ending battle for the consumer dollar, General Growth Properties, which owns some 120 high-end malls through the U.S., has recruited RetailMeNot to its side. Under a new agreement the two announced...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Aaron Sorkin Gives More Details On Jobs Movie
The upcoming Steve Jobs movie based on the Walter Isaacson biography is still in the works, with Aaron Sorkin in charge of writing the script. Unfortunately, that is almost all that we currently know about the film.He...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Innovators In The UK: Male, Affluent And Long-Term Planners
For decades, innovation policy has been the domain of technocrats and of party–political consensus. Whilst in other fields – such as science – regular surveys help inform public debate and policy-making, there has been...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Cameron Diaz planning holiday for Gwyneth Paltrow
Cameron Diaz is organizing a girls' holiday to help Gwyneth Paltrow get over her marriage split. The 'Other Woman' actress is keen to cheer up her friend following the end of her 10-year marriage to Chris Martin and is...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Want To Earn $5,000? Stop Working
If you work for Amazon, Jeff Bezos will pay you a bonus of up to $5,000.  Generous, right?  And what do you have to do to get the bonus? Quit your job. It may seem crazy, but it’s true – a recent article in Time notes...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Your Local Mall, Re-digitized
As part of the never-ending battle for the consumer dollar, General Growth Properties, which owns some 120 high-end malls through the U.S., has recruited RetailMeNot to its side. Under a new agreement the two announced...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Jon Hamm slams Justin Bieber
Jon Hamm has branded Justin Bieber a "sh**head." The 'Mad Men' star thinks the 20-year-old singer - who is facing charges for Driving Under the Influence (DUI), resisting arrest and possessing an invalid driver's...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Can Urban WebSlams STEM The Dropout Tide?
On Saturday, April 12, twenty L.A. charter high school students received an opportunity not easily available to them during the regular school day. The mostly black and Hispanic cohort — who hailed from three of...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Are You Too Tentative? Four Ways To Take Smarter Risks, Not Just Safe Ones
When making decisions, most people like to think they are pretty good at weighing up the pros and cons and choosing the smartest course of action.  Unfortunately though, when it comes to assessing potential risks,  most...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Josh Hartnett regrets dating co-stars
Josh Hartnett has hinted he regrets dating Scarlett Johansson. The 35-year-old actor - who is currently in a relationship with British actress Tamsin Egerton - claims that romancing some of his former co-stars has had a...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla