A Sunday Column. IVF Treatment: Better, but not yet Good Enough

Feb 23 2014, 11:19am CST | by

On the occasion of the CDC’s yearly release of IVF clinic success rates, I remind myself and my old colleagues that we should always strive to do better.

Every baby, whether conceived by in vitro fertilization or dropped by a stork down the chimney, is a miracle. 

As a reproductive endocrinologist, I had a unique opportunity to make small contributions to some of these miracles. But as I constantly reminded myself and my colleagues: the miracles are the babies, not the procedures.

That is still true today. Assisted reproduction as it exists in the year 2014 is still a pretty primitive set of procedures and tools.

We blast away at the eggs remaining in the ovaries with hormone levels far higher than nature ever intended. We pull the eggs out of the ovaries at warp speed and place the eggs into a laboratory that, no matter how advanced, is still a more hostile environment than the one nature designed. In some cases we fertilize enough eggs to fill a school classroom and then we take often more than the ideal number of the absolute best developing embryos and transfer them back into the uterus — where in the best of circumstances one will turn into a baby about half the time. Put this way, the “miracle” may not be so much the result that we achieve as the fact that we are allowed to charge for the process. Maybe I overstate this, but I do think that we should hold off on applying for “miracle maker” status until we’re somewhere close to a 100% pregnancy rate putting back one embryo at a time.

I dislike the way the term “miracle” (as in “miracle baby” or “miracle procedure”) is used. The term can be harmful.

It can be harmful to patients’ abilities to cope with the already significant stress of an in vitro fertilization cycle. 

What happens when a cycle fails and a patient thinks,  ”Maybe I don’t deserve the miracle?”

If a patient believes that the outcome of an IVF cycle is a miracle, and is therefore not based in very real and very limiting probabilities, then she is going to very naturally feel that the outcome will reflect whether she is worthy of such a miracle or not.

The truth is, when IVF fails a patient, IVF has failed. Not the patient.

If every patient at the IVF starting line feels that he or she is as equally deserving of a miracle as the next person, then they’re going into their IVF cycle with much more on the line than the obviously very important things that the outcome will or will not bring. How many women have I had say to me that “anything bad that can happen in their treatment and their attempts to get pregnant will happen to me.”As much as I hate to even bring up some of the more sobering statistics about IVF outcomes, or to point out to a couple that their prognosis may be somewhat worse than many of the other couples we see, doing so is a hedge against the very real risks that they’re putting not only their future family structure but also their very self-image on the line. This is far too much pressure for any couple to have to bear.

The second insidious effect of allowing ourselves and our patients to think that the outcomes of procedures are miracles, is that we are suddenly shifting the blame from the outcome of a negative cycle from ourselves as doctors and scientists and from our procedures —  to the patients themselves. Self blame is never far away from assisted reproduction. Unspoken or not, many people feel they are being punished for something in their past and the punishment is their infertility. In this setting, some are all too ready to unfairly blame themselves for the bad outcome of a cycle in which the pregnancy test is negative.

 As doctors we can unwittingly feed right into this. Look at some of the dictates and rules sometimes set on IVF cycles, often with no more backing than “it seems like a good idea.”

Rule number one: stay in bed or stay on bed rest for many hours or even days after the embryo transfer.

Rule number two: no intercourse during the IVF cycle.

Rule number three: no exercise during the IVF cycle.

There is little or no evidence that any of these things is actually true. I actually had women ask me, in states of panic after having had an orgasm sometime between their embryo transfer and the pregnancy test, whether they had ruined the outcome of their IVF procedure. Someone somewhere had told them that any type of sexual arousal would have a negative effect on their IVF cycle.

What complete crap!

The fact is that the uterus, and its ability to protect early embryos in their development, is one of the biggest assets we have in assisted reproduction.

While it is completely understandable for patients to seek reasons and even get superstitious over the outcome of an IVF cycle, it should be the job of physicians and medical professionals to go out of our way with reassurance that the reason IVF cycles don’t work when they don’t work is because of the limitations of the procedure itself and not because of some extraneous factor that just allows us to shift the blame over to the patient or couple./>/>

The field of assisted reproduction has made taken some wonderful strides over the decades. We don’t need to artificially inflate what we’ve done, nor do we need to diminish the role and the importance of the patients themselves. So let’s leave off all the talk about miracles, except when we’re talking about the babies themselves.

Babies who are born because of, in spite of, or independent of anything else that IVF may do.

Source: Forbes Business


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Global entrepreneurship summit boost for SMEs
Marrakech, Nov 22 (IANS) Nine agreements were signed between the Moroccan General Confederation of Enterprises (CGEM) and several small and medium enterprises (SMEs) as well as between major Moroccan banks and start-ups at the 5th Global Entrepreneurship Summit (GES 2014) held in Morocco.
NASA's flying saucer among 'Best of What's New'
Washington, Nov 22 (IANS) NASA's Low-Density Supersonic Decelerator (LDSD), a spacecraft that aims to facilitate the safe landing of future Mars missions, has earned a place in the the Popular Science magazine's "Best Of What's New" list.
Indian helping to light up Gambia (Diaspora Feature)
Banjul (Gambia), Nov 22 (IANS) Like many Indians who are proving to be philanthropists around Africa, Ram Mohan has set up a social business called Comafrique Intelizon Initiative and has embarked on the replacement of candles in villages in the Gambia with solar lights from India.
Leopards in human areas not conflict animals: Study
New Delhi, Nov 22 (IANS) Leopards in human areas are not always "stray" or "conflict" animals but residents with strategies to thrive in human dominated areas, says the first GPS-based study of leopards in India.

Latest from the Network

US condemns Kenya bus attack, terms it 'horrific'
Washington, Nov 23 (IANS) The US condemned "in the strongest terms", the attack on a bus in Kenya that killed 28 people, terming it as "horrific". The US extends its deepest condolences to the families and loved ones...
Read more on Politics Balla
Heidi Montag wants to age gracefully
Los Angeles, Nov 23 (IANS) Singer Heidi Montag, who has undergone ten cosmetic procedures, says she wants to "age gracefully". The 28-year-old singer discussed about her wish with Extra, reports contactmusic.com. The...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Kourtney Kardashian hints at Scott Disick split
Kourtney Kardashian has hinted her relationship with Scott Disick is on the rocks. The reality television star has been dating the 31-year-old hunk since 2006, but posted quotes from the Disney film 'Lilo & Stitch'...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Kelly Brook engaged again?
Kelly Brook has sparked rumours that she is engaged again. The model - who will turn 35 on Sunday (23.11.14) - was seen sporting a huge jewel on her ring finger at the Teens Unite Charity Ball at Underglobe in London...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Heidi praises Spencer for 'best 8 years of my life'
Heidi Montag has praised Spencer Pratt for the ''best 8 years of my life (sic)''. The former 'The Hills' star gushed over her beau in a message online on Friday (21.11.14) to celebrate their sixth wedding anniversary....
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Bahrain sees 51.5 percent voter turnout in national elections
Manama, Nov 23 (IANS) Bahrain registered 51.5 percent turnout in the parliamentary and municipal elections Saturday, notwithstanding the opposition's call to boycott the elections. "The turnout today was 51.5 percent...
Read more on Politics Balla
Black Friday 2014 Sales and Deals for 11/22
Friday was already a wild Black Friday 2014 sales day with $115 40-inch TVs and other hot doorbuster deals that Walmart matched. Saturday has not these dramatic deals like on Friday. There are still though plenty of...
Read more on Black Friday Countdown
I was original: Aniston on Kardashian's nude picture
Los Angeles, Nov 23 (IANS) Shunning the hype around reality TV star Kim Kardashian's derriere picture, actress Jennifer Aniston says she bared her derriere way before Kardashian and it was original. Aniston posed nude...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Davis Cup final: Switzerland nudges ahead with doubles win
Lille, Nov 23 (IANS/EFE) Superstar Swiss duo of Roger Federer and Stanislas Wawrinka put their country ahead in the Davis Cup final with a 6-3, 7-5, 6-4 victory over the French pair of Richard Gasquet and Julien...
Read more on Sport Balla
Former police official arrested over students' disappearance in Mexico
Mexico City, Nov 23 (IANS/EFE) A former deputy police chief and suspected member of the Guerreros Unidos ("United Warriors") drug cartel, that allegedly, is involved in the disappearance of 43 students in Mexico...
Read more on Politics Balla