The Curious Incident Of The New York City Ballet Dancing In The David H. Koch Theater

Feb 24 2014, 4:13pm CST | by

The Curious Incident Of The New York City Ballet Dancing In The David H. Koch Theater
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

Part of understanding doing good by doing the right thing is understanding absent acts of conscience, those times when people should step up but they do not. The near silence surrounding the New York City Ballet dancing in the David H. Koch Theater is one such situation.

Such absent acts of conscience are easy to ignore. Silence is hard to hear. But it is surprisingly meaningful, like the silent dog in the Sherlock Holmes story “Silver Blaze.” The following is the exchange between Holmes and Inspector Gregory from Scotland Yard:

“Is there any point to which you would wish to draw my attention?”
“To the curious incident of the dog in the night-time.”
“The dog did nothing in the night-time.”
“That was the curious incident,” remarked Sherlock Holmes.


Here’s why silence by patrons of the New York City Ballet is a similarly curious incident.

In 2008, to honor his $100 million donation, the New York State Theater, long home to the New York City Ballet, was renamed the David H. Koch Theater. Since getting started in 1948, the New York City Ballet has been the artistic home to choreographers George Balanchine, Jerome Robbins and Peter Martins, and to legions of talented dancers. It is now the “largest dance organization in America.”

And in case you are still not sure: yes, that David H. Koch. Along with his brother Charles, he is a primary funder of climate change denial disinformation. The brothers have been major stealth funders for anti-climate and anti-renewables organizations like Americans for Prosperity, the Competitive Enterprise Institute, the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) and the backdoor group Donors Trust which work to deny climate change, attack climate scientists and block effective clean energy policies.

In contrast to Koch’s leadership on climate-change denial, New York City is a progressive, pro-science and well-educated town. Our new mayor, Bill de Blasio, won in a landslide on a progressive platform. He’s on record in favor of the sustainability the Koch brothers work to deride. And our former mayor, Michael Bloomberg, frequently taken to task by progressives for, well, not being progressive, was just named by U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon as his special envoy for cities and climate change. According to Reuters, “Bloomberg said cities had emerged as a leading force in the battle against climate change.”

Because of this sharp conflict between Koch’s record and the values of most New Yorkers, including ballet-lovers, protests about the renaming should be as popular as Citi Bikes and cronuts. But that has not happened. Instead, David H. Koch has his name on the theater and there has been barely a moral peep from well-educated, progressive New Yorkers. It is a curious incident of silence, like silent watchdogs signaling the familiarity of the thief.

Some may say this is just partisan politics, no big deal, nothing curious about it at all. Well, no. The Koch brothers have crossed the moral line from aggressive politics into fomenting climate-change denial. They are not just trying to help formulate conservative and partisan solutions to what many consider the central struggle of the 21st-century. What they are doing is propagating distortions, myths, and lies that have made any action in the direction of a sustainable future so far impossible. Their aim is to do public harm for private gain.

Of course $100 million buys a lot of good will. But not this much. There should be some sort of response to Koch’s perfidy, something not nothing. The dog should have barked.

To better understand I reached out to several friends and colleagues who are regular ballet-goers (which I am not) to ask about their experience. What I learned was how emotionally difficult action would be when the moral conflict pits the existential challenge of climate-change against the immediate, tangible reality of a cherished subscription to the NYC Ballet.

One response was an anxiety-modulating absence of even noticing the problem. Someone said, “Oh, I didn’t think think this Koch was that Koch.” Others felt the conflict. They were troubled, trapped even by wanting to do something effective, but not wanting to harm the Ballet. They were paralyzed into uncomfortable inactivity.

One side of the inaction-causing conflict requires keeping in mind the unimaginable catastrophe that our way of life is dangerous and not sustainable. The other side has the tangible emotional immediacy of appreciating an artistic performance. One side is full of anxiety and guilt and can not be imagined; the other side has deep pleasures that can not be forgotten. Resolving the conflict of this curious incident in the direction of silence is, therefore, no surprise. It makes psychological sense.

Inaction in the face of climate change is not just limited to ballet. When it comes to climate change many rational, scientifually literate people are silent about the need for immediate action. This general silence is partly why it is such big news when a billionaire financier Tom Steyer funds a political group, NextGen Climate Action, to “pressure federal and state officials to enact climate change measures through a hard-edge campaign of attack ads against governors and lawmakers.” Apparently, our curious incident is quite common. In response, a growing group of climate-change psychologists have been studying, among other things, the “psychological barriers that limit individual and collective action on climate change.”

One psychologist, Renee Lertzman, has  convincingly argued that when it comes to climate-change inaction is not apathy. Like I found among my friends and colleagues, it’s anxiety. Lertzman was recently quoted saying “People are becoming increasingly anxious, and therefore either activated, or paralyzed and despairing—and there’s a whole spectrum in between.”

One consequence of understanding the central role anxiety and conflict plays in climate change inaction is being able to see that tremendous leadership opportunities are present. Steyer and NextGen Climate Action is on to something that even social entrepreneurs lacking billions may want to emulate; there is tremendous potential energy locked in anxious inactivity about climate change. As I described in the previous post, effective acts of conscience are often led by those with an inclusive, positive, and participatory vision. Let’s hope someone with those qualities steps up to address the curious incident of the silence surrounding the New York City Ballet dancing in the David H. Koch Theater.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Pro2col Announces Its Presence at InfoSec and an Exclusive Distribution Deal with Thru
Leading independent file transfer specialists Pro2col who will be exhibiting at InfoSec, is also pleased to announce an exclusive agreement with Thru to distribute their file transfer solution in the UK and Ireland.
 
 
Thousands of Retail Locations Ready to Service Future PinoyWallet Holders
PyxPay and Fuze Network entered into a participation agreement for Fuze Network to accommodate loading funds onto PyxPay’s closed-loop debit card accounts. The partnership, which has commenced on March 12, 2014, aims to open Fuze Network’s thousands of Alternative Financial Services (AFS) partner locations to PyxPay accountholders in the United States.
 
 
Abnormal Volume Stocks To Watch On Wednesday
Abnormal Volume Stocks To Watch On Wednesday
Looking through the closing trading data for the Russell 1000 components, there are some abnormal volume stand-outs that traders will be interested to watch during Wednesday’s upcoming session. To compile this list, we...
 
 
Northwestern MutualVoice: What You Should Know Before Taking A Loan From Your Life Insurance
Northwestern MutualVoice: What You Should Know Before Taking A Loan From Your Life Insurance
Aside from the death benefit, one of the great things about permanent life insurance is that it builds cash value. Your policy becomes an asset you own. As you build cash value in your policy, you can easily access that...
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Pro2col Announces Its Presence at InfoSec and an Exclusive Distribution Deal with Thru
London, United Kingdom, April 16, 2014 --(PR.com)-- Leading independent file transfer specialists Pro2col has today confirmed it will be exhibiting at InfoSec from 29 April to 1st May 2014 at Earl&#8217;s Court....
Read more on Business Balla
 
Johnny Depp: Age gap with Amber isn't an issue
Johnny Depp doesn't think the age gap between him and his fiancée Amber Heard is an issue. The 50-year-old actor believes the 27-year-old screen beauty, who he fell for on the set of 'The Rum Diary', has a lot to teach...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Lady Gaga praises 'admirable' Lily Allen
Lady Gaga thinks Lily Allen is "admirable" for calling her a "martyr". The singer is extremely grateful to her fellow pop star for defending her latest album 'ARTPOP', which hasn't been selling as well as her previous...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Thousands of Retail Locations Ready to Service Future PinoyWallet Holders
New York, NY, April 16, 2014 --(PR.com)-- PyxPay and Fuze Network entered into a participation agreement for Fuze Network to accommodate loading funds onto PyxPay&#8217;s closed-loop debit card accounts. The...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Abnormal Volume Stocks To Watch On Wednesday
Looking through the closing trading data for the Russell 1000 components, there are some abnormal volume stand-outs that traders will be interested to watch during Wednesday’s upcoming session. To compile this list, we...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Northwestern MutualVoice: What You Should Know Before Taking A Loan From Your Life Insurance
Aside from the death benefit, one of the great things about permanent life insurance is that it builds cash value. Your policy becomes an asset you own. As you build cash value in your policy, you can easily access that...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Spring Is Blossoming -- Are You?
With the spring in full swing here, I realize that nature has such wisdom to share with us as leaders if we let it. As I watch the bursting forth of the young bright green leaves on the trees, hear the symphony of the...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Five Keys To BRAVE Innovation
In most industries, the lowest cost player makes money selling large quantities of product or service at a low price with great discipline. The differentiated player makes money selling smaller quantities of product or...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Roads Versus Rail: The Big Battle Over Public Transportation
EDITOR’S NOTE: Forbes has just published Curbing Cars: America’s Independence From The Auto Industry, an eBook investigating why a growing number of Americans are giving up their cars. Written by Forbes contributor and...
Read more on Auto Balla
 
I Want To Work For Diddy: Meet Sean Combs' Real Revolt Recruits
Back in 2008, a program called I Want To Work For Diddy made its debut on VH1. As its title suggests, the program follows a handful of Millennials as they perform outrageous tasks in order to win approval—and,...
Read more on Business Balla
 
 
Auto Balla Sexy Balla Sport Balla TV Balla Politics Balla Movie Balla Apple Balla Business Balla Ad Balla Celebrity Balla