Who Needs Legislation? Dems Want To Extend Tobacco Settlement To E-Cigarettes

Feb 24 2014, 9:05pm CST | by

The state attorneys general who negotiated Master Settlement Agreement with the tobacco industry took care of themselves, the leading cigarette manufacturers and the private attorneys who contributed so generously to their campaigns with the $200 billion pact. But they left a rather large loophole that Democratic leaders in Congress want to close: E-cigarettes.

Representatives Henry Waxman of California and Peter Welch of Vermont, along with Sen. Tom Harkin of Iowa, have sent letters to the AGs in their respective states asking them to fold e-cigarettes into the MSA as a way of keeping the electronic devices out of the hands of children. The letter focuses on the restrictions on advertising and marketing that the big tobacco companies agreed to under the settlement.

“Inclusion of these products in the definition of cigarette is consistent with the MSA’s overarching goal of protecting America’s youth from the harms of tobacco use,” the legislators say.

Not mentioned are the other overarching goals of the settlement: Money, and protecting the cartel enjoyed by Philip Morris and other large cigarette manufacturers.

E-cigarettes present a problem for states that have grown addicted to the additional cash thrown off by the MSA, on top of their already steep taxes on cigarettes. The payments under the MSA are for all intents and purposes an excise tax, except they were negotiated with the leading companies, supposedly as retribution for their fraudulent marketing practices and the costs smoking imposed on the states.The problem with that approach — and one good reason why taxation should be left to elected representatives — was that new cigarette companies could enter the business unburdened by the MSA payments and steal market share from the incumbents.

To fix that, the AGs “negotiated” similar terms on behalf of all future entrants into the cigarette business. But either by design or incompetence, they left a major loophole: The  agreement covers “any product that contains nicotine, is intended to be burned or heated,” but also contains “tobacco, in any form, that is functional in the product.” E-cigs heat nicotine, but don’t contain tobacco. In fact one e-cig, Greensmart, has avoided the largely similar language in Minnesota’s excise tax on e-cigs because it derives its nicotine from eggplants.

The Waxman letter hasn’t gotten much press and perhaps their plea will go unanswered. (One journal that did pick up on it is Grant’s Interest Rate Observer, which noted it could be bullish for state bonds backed by MSA tobacco revenue.)

It hasn’t caught the attention of many of the e-cig manufacturers meeting this week at a wholesale conference in Las Vegas, either. But I spoke with one Big Tobacco veteran who is a little worried.

“The industry doesn’t understand it enough to be upset about it, but I’m concerned,” said Miguel Martin, a former Altria executive who now runs e-cig maker LOGIC Technology. “I think people are looking for revenue.”

While the AGs wrote in marketing and advertising restrictions and some of them attempted to steer the money to pet causes, most of the money ended up in state coffers. And the states did what states normally do, selling $34 billion worth of bonds backed by the new streams of revenue so they could spend it up front. As Grant’s notes, cigarette shipments fell 4.6% in 2013, continuing a long-term slide and casting doubt upon the cigarette companies’ willingness or ability to continue increasing their payments by 3% a year, as spelled out in the MSA (“Never mind TIPS: Here are truly inflation-protected securities,” Grants says.)

Folding e-cigs into the deal might relieve some of that pressure, although it might also stretch the law past the breaking point. The original settlement was based upon the idea that states were losing money because of smoking-related illness — on balance, after throwing in tax revenue, a dubious proposition — and that the existing companies had committed fraud.

The e-cig companies couldn’t have participated in that fraud because they didn’t exist. The current version, which vaporizes nicotine using tiny lithium batteries, was patented by a Chinese pharmacist in 2003.  There is also no evidence e-cigs cause lung cancer or other diseases associated with the tar in burning tobacco.

“This is a product that didn’t even exist at the time of the MSA,” said W. Kip Viscusi, a professor at Vanderbilt Law School and author of Smoke-Filled Rooms: A Post-Mortem on the Tobacco Deal. To the extent that the MSA was designed to compensate for the harm done by cigarettes, e-cigs certainly were not responsible for that.”

Another big question is whether private attorneys, most of them big Democratic Party contributors, who are still earning hundreds of millions of dollars in fees from the MSA would get a bump in revenue if the new products were added to the deal. The terms of their fee agreement were kept secret, as a deal between them and the tobacco industry. It would be interesting to know if they exempted themselves from e-cigs.

Martin of LOGIC Technology said the industry is hoping it can avoid piecemeal state-level regulation and taxation. The leading manufacturers are hoping the Food and Drug Administration soon announces regulations that apply to all companies. Minnesota was the first state to tax e-cigs, meanwhile, but since they are widely available on the Internet and there are no legal restrictions on interstate shipments, that law “is a joke,” he said.

“If you’re going to go state by state all you’re going to do is create a massive gray market or punish retailers, who are the best people to age-verify,” he said.

 />/>

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Sports meet in Kenya cancelled over Ebola fears
Nairobi, Aug 21 (IANS) The International Netball Federation (INF) cancelled an international meeting in Nairobi owing to deadly Ebola virus attack that has visited parts of Africa, Xinhua reported Wednesday.
 
 
UN chief condemns American journalist's killing
United Nations, Aug 21 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon Wednesday strongly condemned the killing of American journalist James Foley by extremist Islamist militants, calling it "an abominable crime".
 
 
Russia suspends four McDonald restaurants
Moscow, Aug 21 (IANS) Russia's consumer rights watchdog said Wednesday it has temporarily shut down four McDonald's restaurants here, including the first ever outlet in the country, citing sanitary violations.
 
 
Egypt mufti's adviser slams killing of US journalist
Cairo, Aug 20 (IANS) Ibrahim Negm, advisor to the mufti of Egypt, Wednesday denounced the beheading of US journalist James Foley by the Islamic State (IS) Sunni extremist group in Iraq, state-run MENA news agency reported.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

US eager to engage Modi government: Congressional report
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) The US, which had shunned Narendra Modi for nearly 10 years, is eager to engage India's new government led by him and re-energize what some see as a flagging relationship, according to a new...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Barcelona agree deal for Sao Paulo defender
Rio de Janeiro, Aug 21 (IANS) Spanish football giant Barcelona have agreed to sign defender Douglas from Sao Paulo for six million euros, the Brazilian club said. But the 24-year-old will not join the Catalan outfit...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Barcelona to appeal to CAS against FIFA ban
Madrid, Aug 21 (IANS) Spanish football giant Barcelona confirmed that they will appeal to the Court of Arbitration in Sport (CAS) after FIFA upheld its decision to ban the club from signing for the next two transfer...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Rihanna and Drake are just friends
Rihanna and Drake are reportedly working on their friendship. The on-again, off-again couple, who were spotted partying together in New York City twice this week, ''seemed happy to see one another'' as they sat side-by-...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Rita Ora doesn't understand love
Rita Ora admits she doesn't understand love. The British singer, who split from Scottish DJ Calvin Harris in June after a year of dating, says she is still ''fascinated'' with the feeling, despite finding it confusing....
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Learning from Meghalaya village to keep India clean (Environment Feature)
Mawlynnong (Meghalaya), Aug 21 (IANS) If Indians want to make their country a clean and healthy place, then they should learn from the Khasi tribesmen of Meghalaya's Mawlynnong village, says tourist Michael Dough. "I...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Health conscious Crawford pulls children out of school
Los Angeles, Aug 21 (IANS) Model Cindy Crawford and her husband Rande Gerber recently pulled their two children out of school over health concerns. Crawford and other parents made the decision after testing found high...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
US admits failure to rescue journalist in Syria
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) The US had recently attempted to rescue a number of American hostages, including slain journalist James Foley held in Syria by the Islamic State, but the mission failed, Pentagon Press...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Zoe Saldana finally admits pregnancy
Los Angeles, Aug 21 (IANS) "Avatar" actress Zoe Saldana has for the first time acknowledged that she is pregnant via a video of her ALS Ice Bucket Challenge, an activity where people dump a bucket of ice water on one's...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Robin Williams to be honored by Billy Crystal
Billy Crystal will honor the late Robin Williams at the upcoming Emmy Awards. The 66-year-old comedian will lead tributes to his longtime friend, who was found dead at his home in Tiburon, California on August 11 after...
Read more on Celebrity Balla