Obamacare: America's Greatest Legislation Since the Civil Rights Act?

Mar 4 2014, 1:37pm CST | by

Obamacare is the moniker for the Affordable Care Act.  Unfortunately, many people thought the last thing Obamacare would do was make health care more affordable.  Yet, early signs are pointing in the direction of a long-term change in America’s cost of providing health services or the better.

American health care is trending toward greater affordability

The November, 2013 White House report on “Trends in Health Care Cost Growth” provides a plethora of data supporting declining health care costs.  Growth in health care cost per capita at 1% in 2011 was the lowest since record keeping began in the 1960s.  Health care inflation now seems to be about the same as general inflation, after 5 decades of consistently outpacing other price increases.  And Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projections of Medicare/Medicaid cost as a percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) have declined substantially since 2010.

Of course, one could accuse the White House of being self-serving with this report.  But at a February National Association of Corporate Directors Chicago Conference on health care,

all agreed that, indeed, the world has changed as a result of Obamacare.  And one short-term outcome is American health care trending toward greater affordability.

How Obamacare promoted greater affordability is not at all obvious

Abdication: that is the word which best describes patient health care choices for the last several decades.  Patients simply did whatever they were told to do.  If a test was offered, or a procedure recommended, or a referral to a specialist given, or a drug prescribed patients simply did what they were told – “as long as the insurance paid.”

The process of health care implementation, how patients were treated, was specified by medical professionals in conjunction with insurance companies and Medicare.   Patients had little – or nothing – to do with the decision making process.  The service was either offered, and largely free, or it wasn’t offered.

In effect, American patients abdicated health care decision-making to others.

Decisions about what would be treated, when and how was almost wholly made without patient involvement.  And what would be charged, as well as who would pay, was also made by someone other than the patient.  The patient had no involvement in determining if there was any sort of cost/benefit analysis, or the comparing of different care options.

Insurance companies dickered with providers over pricing.  Then employers dickered with insurance companies over what would be covered in a plan, what the price would be and what percentage was paid by the insurance company and what would be paid by patients.  When a patient needed treatment either the employer’s insurance company paid, after a negotiation on price with the provider, or the insurance company did not.  And patients largely consumed whatever care was offered under their plan.

Or, if a patient was on Medicare the same process applied, just substitute for “employer” the words “a government agency.”

Americans abdicated the decision-making process for health care to a cumbersome process that involved medical professionals, insurance companies and employers.  Patients behaved like health care was free, even though everyone knew it was not free.  But the process of deciding what would be done, how it would be priced and measuring benefits had been abdicated by patients to this process years ago.

Obamacare moves Americans from a world of abdication to a world of accountability

Everyone now has to be insured, so the decision about what coverage each person has, at what level and cost, is now in the hands of the patient.  Rather than a single employer option, patients have a veritable smorgasboard of coverage options from which they can select.  And this begins the process of making each person accountable for their health care cost.

When people receive treatment, by and large more is now being paid by the patient.  And once people had to start paying, they had to be accountable for the cost (higher deductibles and co-pays had already started this process before Obamacare.)  When people became accountable for the cost, a lot more questions started to be asked about the price and the benefit.  Instead of consuming everything that was available, because there was no cost implication, patient accountability for some of the cost has now forced people to ask questions before committing to treatments.

Higher accountability now has consumers (patients) asking for more choices.  And more choices pushes providers to realize that price and delivery make a difference to the patient – who is now a decision-making buyer.

Health care demand and supply curves have changed dramatically/>/>

In economic lingo, accountability is changing the health care demand and supply curves.  Previously there was no elasticity of demand.  Patients had no incentives to reduce demand, as health care was perceived as free.  Providers had no incentive to alter supply, because the more they supplied the more they were paid.  Both supply and demand went straight up, because there was no pricing element to stand in the way of both increasing geometrically.

But now patients are making decisions using price, which alters demand. Increasingly they determine what procedures to have, based on price and expected outcomes. And suppliers are now evaluated based upon price, location, service history, provider experience, etc.  Patients can shop amongst hospitals and outpatient facilities to determine the cost of different procedures and decide which solution they prefer.  More services, at different locations and different price points creates a new supply curve, and impacts the demand curve.  We now have elasticity in both demand and supply.

A patient with a mild heart arythmia can decide if they really need an in-house EKG with a cardiologist review, or substitute an EKG detected from a smartphone device and diagnosed by an EKG tech remotely.  With both services offered at very different price points (and a host of options in the middle,) it is possible for the patient to change their demand for something like an EKG. And this impacts all the different aspects that are part of the total cost of cardiac care.  Patient/consumers may buy more of some care, such as services they find less costly or providers that are less pricey, and less of another service which is more costly due to the service, the provider or a combination of the two.

Thus accountability starts us down the road to greater affordability

In distribution terms, the old system was a “wholesale system” which had very expensive suppliers with pricing which was opaque – and often very bizarre.  Pricing was impossible to understand.  Middlemen in insurance companies hired by employers tried to determine what services should be given to patients, and at what prices for the employers (not the patient) to pay.  This wholesale distribution method of health care drove prices up.  Neither those creating demand (patients) or those offering the supply (medical providers) had any incentive to use less health care or lower the price.  And often it left both the patient and the supplier extremely unhappy with how they were treated by arbitrary middle-men more interested in groups than individuals.

The new approach is a retail system.  The patient no longer abdicates decision making to middle-men, and instead is accountable for the health care they receive and the price they pay. This retail approach to health care services consumption is creating a far more rational pricing system, and generating new curves that are starting to balance both demand and supply; while simultaneously encouraging the implementation of new options that provide the ability to enhance the service and/or outcome at lower price points.

Obamacare is just beginning its implementation.  “The devil is in the details,” and as we saw with the government web site for exchanges (Healthcare.Gov) there have been many, many glitches.  As with anything so encompassing and complex, there are lots of SNAFUs. The market is still far from transparent, and patients are far from educated, much less fully informed, decision-makers. There is a lot of confusion amongst providers, suppliers and patients.  Regulations are unclear, and not always handled consistently or judiciously.

But, America has made one heck of a start toward containing something which has overhung economic growth since the 1970s.  The health care cost trend is toward greater price visibility, smarter consumers, more options and lower health care costs both short- and long-term.

Obamacare is an economic game changer, similar to the Civil Rights Act of 1964

In the 1960s Congress, and the nation, was deeply divided over passing the Civil Rights Act.  Its impact would be significant on both the way of life for many people, and the economy.  How it would shape America was unclear, and many opposed its passage.  Called for by President Kennedy, President Johnson worked hard – and with lots of strong-arming – to obtain its passage after Kennedy’s death.

After a lot of haggling, some Congressional trickery, filibustering and a lot of legal challenges, the Civil Rights Act was passed in 1964 and it ushered in a new wave of economic growth as it freed previously under-used intellectual resources to grow the American economy instead of being held back.  It was a game changer for the nation, and 40 years later, it’s hard to imagine an America without the gains made by the Civil Rights Act.

Looking 40 years forward, Obamacare – the ACA – may well be legislation that is seen as an economic game changer.  Although its passage was bruising to many in the nation, it changed health care from a system of patient abdication to one of patient accountability, and thereby directed health care toward greater affordability for the country and its citizens – after years of health care cost escalation which hindered economic growth.

Connect with me on LinkedIn, Facebook  and Twitter.

Links:

How the President was damaged by the botched Healthcare.gov implementation

Economically, could Obama be America’s best modern President?/>/>

Why Wall Street missed predicting Obama’s “miracle market” of 2013

America’s wrong-headed jobs and innovation policies

Could Democrats be better economic stewards than Republicans?

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Sports meet in Kenya cancelled over Ebola fears
Nairobi, Aug 21 (IANS) The International Netball Federation (INF) cancelled an international meeting in Nairobi owing to deadly Ebola virus attack that has visited parts of Africa, Xinhua reported Wednesday.
 
 
UN chief condemns American journalist's killing
United Nations, Aug 21 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon Wednesday strongly condemned the killing of American journalist James Foley by extremist Islamist militants, calling it "an abominable crime".
 
 
Russia suspends four McDonald restaurants
Moscow, Aug 21 (IANS) Russia's consumer rights watchdog said Wednesday it has temporarily shut down four McDonald's restaurants here, including the first ever outlet in the country, citing sanitary violations.
 
 
Egypt mufti's adviser slams killing of US journalist
Cairo, Aug 20 (IANS) Ibrahim Negm, advisor to the mufti of Egypt, Wednesday denounced the beheading of US journalist James Foley by the Islamic State (IS) Sunni extremist group in Iraq, state-run MENA news agency reported.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

US eager to engage Modi government: Congressional report
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) The US, which had shunned Narendra Modi for nearly 10 years, is eager to engage India's new government led by him and re-energize what some see as a flagging relationship, according to a new...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Barcelona agree deal for Sao Paulo defender
Rio de Janeiro, Aug 21 (IANS) Spanish football giant Barcelona have agreed to sign defender Douglas from Sao Paulo for six million euros, the Brazilian club said. But the 24-year-old will not join the Catalan outfit...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Barcelona to appeal to CAS against FIFA ban
Madrid, Aug 21 (IANS) Spanish football giant Barcelona confirmed that they will appeal to the Court of Arbitration in Sport (CAS) after FIFA upheld its decision to ban the club from signing for the next two transfer...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Rihanna and Drake are just friends
Rihanna and Drake are reportedly working on their friendship. The on-again, off-again couple, who were spotted partying together in New York City twice this week, ''seemed happy to see one another'' as they sat side-by-...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Rita Ora doesn't understand love
Rita Ora admits she doesn't understand love. The British singer, who split from Scottish DJ Calvin Harris in June after a year of dating, says she is still ''fascinated'' with the feeling, despite finding it confusing....
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Learning from Meghalaya village to keep India clean (Environment Feature)
Mawlynnong (Meghalaya), Aug 21 (IANS) If Indians want to make their country a clean and healthy place, then they should learn from the Khasi tribesmen of Meghalaya's Mawlynnong village, says tourist Michael Dough. "I...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Health conscious Crawford pulls children out of school
Los Angeles, Aug 21 (IANS) Model Cindy Crawford and her husband Rande Gerber recently pulled their two children out of school over health concerns. Crawford and other parents made the decision after testing found high...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
US admits failure to rescue journalist in Syria
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) The US had recently attempted to rescue a number of American hostages, including slain journalist James Foley held in Syria by the Islamic State, but the mission failed, Pentagon Press...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Zoe Saldana finally admits pregnancy
Los Angeles, Aug 21 (IANS) "Avatar" actress Zoe Saldana has for the first time acknowledged that she is pregnant via a video of her ALS Ice Bucket Challenge, an activity where people dump a bucket of ice water on one's...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Robin Williams to be honored by Billy Crystal
Billy Crystal will honor the late Robin Williams at the upcoming Emmy Awards. The 66-year-old comedian will lead tributes to his longtime friend, who was found dead at his home in Tiburon, California on August 11 after...
Read more on Celebrity Balla