FDA Action Should Take The Juice Out Of Some Food Labeling Class Actions

Mar 4 2014, 1:41pm CST | by

FDA Action Should Take The Juice Out Of Some Food Labeling Class Actions
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

We admit that before scrutinizing the related wave of food labeling class action litigation, we had never seen the term “evaporated cane juice” (ECJ).  It might be fair to wonder whether many of the plaintiffs in these suits had ever noticed it on food labels either. But claims alleging that using ECJ on a food label violate federal rules (and thus also California law) have become ubiquitous. As of January 22, there were over 50 suits pending in federal courts with an ECJ claim. Thanks to an action yesterday by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), those claims may not survive beyond March.

FDA formally reopened the comment period for draft guidance first published on October 7, 2009. That draft guidance informed industry that “dried cane syrup,” not evaporated cane juice, is the common or usual name under federal rules for “the solid or dried form of sugar cane syrup.” FDA never finalized that guidance, but true to FDA form, the agency still invoked it in warning letters sent to companies using the term evaporated cane juice.

Plaintiffs in class-action suits with ECJ claims have routinely argued that the draft guidance and the warning letters established an FDA standard, and that use of the term “evaporated cane juice” violated California law. Even though FDA stated plainly in the documents themselves that neither the 2009 draft guidance nor warning letters invoking it represented the agency’s enforceable view on ECJ, some federal judges have ignored those statements and ruled that FDA has spoken on ECJ.

Defendants in ECJ cases have argued that because establishing the correct terminology for dried sugar cane was within the “special competence” of FDA, and because exercise of that authority is ongoing, courts should defer to FDA under the prudential “primary jurisdiction” doctrine. While that argument was initially successful in cases involving the use of “natural,” courts with one exception (Judge Rogers’s Hood v. Wholesoy decision), have uniformly rejected the primary jurisdiction defense in ECJ cases. We wrote about the most recent case to do so, Gitson v. Clover Stornetta Farms, in January.

The Gitson court, as well as the courts overseeing the other 50+ cases with ECJ claims, will soon be receiving new motions to dismiss based on FDA’s reopening of the ECJ draft guidance comment period. Courts in food labeling cases have applied the primary jurisdiction doctrine consistently to dismiss cases involving labeling where FDA has an ongoing administrative proceeding. For instance, in last year’s Ivie v. Kraft Foods Global et. al decision, Judge Whyte of The Food Court (aka the Northern District of California) threw out a claim because FDA had a rulemaking underway to redefine what constitutes one serving of a breath mint.

We’ve regularly criticized FDA in our Food Court-related commentaries for ceding its enforcement authority to unaccountable plaintiffs’ lawyers and docket-overloaded judges. Such a surrender, we have argued, contradicts what Congress intended when it passed the Nutritional Labeling and Education Act—food labeling uniformity for products sold in a national market. While the Federal Register notice does not mention the 50+ suits with ECJ claims, the timing of it can’t be a coincidence. We applaud FDA’s action and hope that it is but the first agency reminder that regulation of food labeling resides primarily with the executive, not the judicial, branch of government.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Breastfeeding linked to lower risk of postnatal depression
London, Aug 22 (IANS) A new study involving 10,000 mothers has shown that women who breastfed their babies were at significantly lower risk of postnatal depression than those who did not.
 
 
Pakistan media flays India for axing talks
Islamabad, Aug 22 (IANS) Two Pakistani newspapers Friday denounced India's decision to call off talks between their foreign secretaries, saying it had dealt "a serious blow" to the bilateral peace process.
 
 
Novel way to monitor drone's parametres
New York, Aug 22 (IANS) Drones are the future of home delivery and surveillance but to achieve this consistently, they will have to tackle high winds and other uncertainties like depletion of fuel.
 
 
Moon soil charged by electric spark?
Washington, Aug 22 (IANS) High-energy particles from solar storms may have electrically charged the soil in the moon's frigid polar regions, altering its properties, a study suggests.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

David Walliams has naked picture of Lara Stone at home
David Walliams keeps a saucy picture of Lara Stone on the wall of their mansion. The couple - who married in 2010 - don't have many photographs on the walls of their London home apart from a black and white print of the...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Daniel Radcliffe learning Japanese
London, Aug 22 (IANS) Actor Daniel Radcliffe says he is learning to speak Japanese but is finding it tough. "I just started learning Japanese. It's super hard, but fascinating," femalefirst.co.uk quoted the British...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Rihanna obtains restraining order
Los Angeles, Aug 22 (IANS) Singer Rihanna has obtained a restraining order against a man who was caught eyeing her Hollywood Hills property here last week. The unidentified man was caught hanging around her house for...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Britney Spears 'fed up' of father's control
Los Angeles, Aug 22 (IANS) Singer Britney Spears is allegedly "fed up" of her father Jamie Spears controlling her finances. The 32-year-old's personal and professional affairs have been controlled by Jamie and Andrew...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Taylor Swift 'horrified' to see John Mayer
Los Angeles, Aug 22 (IANS) Country musicianTaylor Swift was shocked to see her former boyfriend John Mayer at the same restaurant. The duo split in 2010 following a brief romance and the 24-year-old apparently didn't...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Breastfeeding linked to lower risk of postnatal depression
London, Aug 22 (IANS) A new study involving 10,000 mothers has shown that women who breastfed their babies were at significantly lower risk of postnatal depression than those who did not. The study, by researchers in...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Pakistan media flays India for axing talks
Islamabad, Aug 22 (IANS) Two Pakistani newspapers Friday denounced India's decision to call off talks between their foreign secretaries, saying it had dealt "a serious blow" to the bilateral peace process. "The...
Read more on Ad Balla
 
Amy Winehouse sculpture to be unveiled in London
London, Aug 22 (IANS) A sculpture to commemorate Amy Winehouse is to be unveiled at Camden market in north London, near the singer's last home. The memorial, which has been designed by Scott Eaton, will be a life-...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Mariah Carey 'heartbroken' by split from husband?
Los Angeles, Aug 22 (IANS) Singer Mariah Carey is said to be "heartbroken" by her split from husband Nick Cannon. Cannon, the host of "America's Got Talent" has confirmed he and Carey have been living apart "for a few...
Read more on Celebrity Balla