Taxing Coca-Cola While Exempting Broccoli Is Bad Policy

Mar 7 2014, 8:48am CST | by

The Navajo Nation is trying to use its tax code (I didn’t know the Navajos had a tax code) to promote healthier living. The Navajos recently voted to impose higher taxes on “junk food” and reduce taxes on healthier alternatives. I abhor government attempts to get people to do things for their own benefit. It isn’t the government’s job to make sure I will live to 100 or that I’ll go to heaven. Of course, the Navajo Nation has one of the highest unemployment rates in the country, hovering near 50 percent. Nothing says we care about you like imposing excise taxes on poor people. I know that raising taxes on poor people to get them to follow orders plays well in Knob Hill, and Brookline, and the Upper East Side. But I’m not sure how well it plays in rural Arizona or New Mexico.

Basically, under the proposal soda and fatty snacks would be taxed at 7 percent (up from the current 5 percent), But “fresh” fruits, vegetables, and nuts wouldn’t be taxed at all. I would remind proponents that most people won’t eat Brussels sprouts no matter what the tax rate is. I don’t know how the Navajos will define fatty snacks. Some are obvious — deep-fried Snickers bars would probably qualify. How about snacks that have no fat, like my personal favorite, cherry Twizzlers? Would they be taxed at 7 percent? I hope not. Would a Big Mac be a taxable snack? What happens if someone eats Twinkies for dinner? Would they still be taxed as a snack? The one upside is that this law may give Rick Pomp a lot of fun anecdotes for the next edition of his casebook.

Apparently, the tribe’s leaders are trying to combat an obesity problem. And the reservations in the Southwest have a problem. I’ve seen reports saying that up to 50 percent of the population is obese. Maybe little Navajo kids are spending too much time in front of the PlayStation instead of running around outside. Maybe Navajos have a fondness for bread and pasta, neither of which will be subject to the higher tax. Yet bread and pasta (as all low-carb dieters know) will mysteriously make you fat.

But whether I’m obese or not, why do you get to decide whether I should be punished for drinking a Coke? What gives you that right? Democracy? In any event, several newspapers reported that a sponsor of the proposal was himself obese before deciding to change his life and losing 100 pounds. And he did it without any tax increases or help from the government.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

WhatsApp behind half of Italian divorce cases: Attorney group
Rome, Nov 20 (IANS) Almost half of the divorce cases in Italy rely at least in part on information gathered through the instant messaging service WhatsApp, according to the Italian Association of Matrimonial Lawyers.
 
 
Modi among contenders for Time's Person of the Year
New York, Nov 20 (IANS) Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is in the list of 50 contenders for Time magazine's Person of the Year.
 
 
Atomic clock that fits in your pocket
Washington, Nov 20 (IANS) Researchers, including an Indian-origin scientist, are working on a highly accurate atomic clock the size of a Rubik's cube, measuring about 2 inches in each dimension.
 
 
New insight into cells may lead to better drugs
London, Nov 20 (IANS) In a significant revelation that may help scientists create better drugs, a team of British researchers have found how different types of immune cells communicate with each other and how they kill cancerous or infected cells.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Chevrolet Black Friday 2014 Car Sale announced
Black Friday car sales events are again hosted at car dealerships across the Nation. The Chevrolet Black Friday 2014 Sale has offers on select models 0% APR, $1,000 purchase bonus cash and no monthly payments until next...
Read more on Black Friday Countdown
 
Lily Allen's record label closed?
Los Angeles, Nov 21 (IANS) Singer Lily Allen's record label ITNO has reportedly been closed after three years. Allen set up the label ITNO, which stands for "In The Name Of", in 2011 with Sony, but has since been...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Drone attack in Pakistan kills five suspected militants
Islamabad, Nov 21 (IANS) At least five suspected militants, including what sources claim to be a high value target, were killed in a US drone attack in Pakistan's North Waziristan region Thursday, media reported....
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Mike Nichols, director of 'The Graduate', dies at 83
Washington, Nov 20 (IANS/EFE) Mike Nichols, whose 1967 film "The Graduate" earned him an Oscar as best director, has died, media reported Thursday. He was 83. "He was a true visionary, winning the highest honors in...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Myanmar military launches counter-attack against armed group
Yangon, Nov 20 (IANS) The Myanmar government said Thursday that its troops had launched a counter-attack on the ethnic Kachin Independence Army (KIA) after the armed group disrupted their normal movement. The...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Iraqi forces retake town from IS
Baghdad, Nov 20 (IANS) Iraqi security forces Thursday retook control of a town from Islamic State (IS) militant group in eastern Iraq, and are fighting to seize another in the west, security sources said. In Iraq's...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Turkey to cooperate with Iraq in fighting IS: Iraqi PM
Baghdad, Nov 20 (IANS) Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi said Thursday that Turkey has offered military cooperation to fight the Islamic State(IS) militant group. "There is an agreement on information exchange and...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Hostilities, human rights violations continue in Ukraine: OHCHR
Geneva, Nov 20 (IANS) Hostilities, human rights violations and abuses continued in eastern Ukraine despite the announcement of the Sep 5 ceasefire, a report released by the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Carrie Underwood learned baby news at dinner
Carrie Underwood learned she was expecting a baby boy while having dinner with her husband. The 'Something In the Water' singer and spouse Mike Fisher are expecting their first child together but felt the sonographer's...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Keira Knightley's fan fear
Keira Knightley finds Benedict Cumberbatch's fans terrifying. The 29-year-old actress insists her 'Imitation Game' co-star's devoted female followers - who are dubbed 'The Cumberbitches' - are ''lovely'' but she finds...
Read more on Celebrity Balla