Building Repair Deductions - Thirty Per Cent Of What?

Mar 14 2014, 11:02am CDT | by

null ” is the best line that I could find in the ninety odd pages of Regulation 1.263(a)-3 Amounts paid to improve tangible property” commonly known as the “ repair regs”.  Oh well. null  I’ve been studying the repair regs for practical utility.  I have some observations that may be useful to people working on returns and doing planning for ordinary mortals who own a couple of buildings, but lack their own accounting staff.  Also for owners who are wondering if their tax advisers ar on the ball.

Why Just Buildings?

The regulations are about “tangible property” which includes both “personal” property, which means stuff that you can move around and “real property” which is more or less stuck in one place.  The range of businesses that I am familiar with, which after thirty five years is pretty broad, mostly don’t have to worry about capitalizing personal property, because of Section 179, which allows immediate expensing.  Even when Section 179 does not apply for some reason, you are still able to write most things off over five or seven years making the stakes pretty low, particularly in the current low interest environment.  Finally, I don’t really see people spending much money fixing personal property.  So if you or your client has a fleet of jets or a conglomeration of heavy construction equipment or a few tugboats, you are going to have to look elsewhere for guidance.  I have just been worried about buildings.

null  - 39 years if commercial or 27.5 years if residential.  Also, in real estate, null or conservatively, from a tax viewpoint, capitalizing things that might be expensed.  That is why it is really important to have somebody looking at these regulations for you.

How An Owner Can Tell If This Is Being Addressed

Has your accountant asked you if you have a written long term maintenance plan?  Alternatively has your accountant, knowing that you are kind of seat of the pants, told you that you will need one?  There are two “safe harbors’ for taxpayers that don’t have audited financial statements.  One is a dollar threshold that tops out at $10,000.  That strikes me as pretty laughable.  The other safe-harbor is a rule that indicates that null .  Most of the teaching in the regulation is done by example.  The example illustrating the ten year rule is a taxpayer who plans on replacing the hand rails on the escalators every four years.  The handrails are actually replaced in years four and eleven. The taxpayer is still allowed to expense both rounds of handrail replacement, since the plan to do both within ten years was reasonable.  In order for that to stand up on audit, though, there should have been a written plan in year 1 and somebody,(Who else but the accountant?), should have made that part of the permanent file.

In the past null and carry forward as part of the permanent file.  When the question comes up six or seven years from now, people may win or lose the issue on audit, based on whether they have something like that.  It reminds me a bit of the constantly revised business plan that people who win hobby loss cases have.

The other way you can tell whether the regulations are being addressed is whether the accounting people are asking operational people more questions.  It has probably always been true to some extent, but the regulations make it crystal clear, that you cannot tell whether an expenditure needs to be capitalized just from looking at invoices and associated contracts.

Out Of The Safe Harbor

The expenditures that have to be capitalized are those for “betterment”.  A betterment makes the overall unit of property better, different or like new.  It also needs to be a big deal within that unit of property. In the context of buildings, there are as many as eight separate units to consider besides the basic structure:

 (1) Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (“HVAC”) systems (including motors, compressors, boilers, furnace, chillers, pipes, ducts, radiators);

(2) Plumbing systems (including pipes, drains, valves, sinks, bathtubs, toilets, water and sanitary sewer collection equipment, and site utility equipment used to distribute water and waste to and from the property line and between buildings and other permanent structures);

(3) Electrical systems (including wiring, outlets, junction boxes, lighting fixtures and associated connectors, and site utility equipment used to distribute electricity from the property line to and between buildings and other permanent structures);

(4) All escalators;

(5) All elevators;

(6) Fire-protection and alarm systems (including sensing devices, computer controls, sprinkler heads, sprinkler mains, associated piping or plumbing, pumps, visual and audible alarms, alarm control panels, heat and smoke detection devices, fire escapes, fire doors, emergency exit lighting and signage, and fire fighting equipment, such as extinguishers, and hoses);

(7) Security systems for the protection of the building and its occupants (including window and door locks, security cameras, recorders, monitors, motion detectors, security lighting, alarm systems, entry and access systems, related junction boxes, associated wiring and conduit);

(8) Gas distribution system (including associated pipes and equipment used to distribute gas to and from the property line and between buildings or permanent structures);/>/>

There may be more categories in the future.  You need to determine whether a particular expenditure is a “big deal” within each of those categories.  What is interesting is that the assessment is not made based on dollars, but rather on physical reality.  null .  Most of the teaching is done by example.  Here are the ones that struck me.

Roofs 

Nothing new here really.  Roofs have long been a matter of contention.  The examples allow that applying a new rubber “membrane” could be expensed.  Replacing the entire roof, including decking, insulation, asphalt and various coatings has to be capitalized.  Of course the regulations allow you to extract the cost of the original roof from the building and write-off the remaining undepreciated cost.  I’m not going to try to explain how I would come up with that number, other than to say, that, in the event, I will come up with something and will end up comforting myself with the thought of “How wrong could it be?”.  It would be nice to have something in the permanent file to support that.

Is There A Thirty Per Cent Rule?

So the tenants are complaining about it being too hot or too cold or too just right.  You bring in a contractor and she tells you to replace three of your ten roof mounted units.  Three out of ten units is not a “significant portion” of the roof mounted units which are a major component of the HVAC system.  On the other hand if there is a single “chiller” and you replace that you have to capitalize it.

If you replace all the wiring in the building, that being a major component of the electrical system you have to capitalize it. null  of that major component and would not have to be capitalized.

If you decide to replace all the toilets and sinks you are going to have to capitalize that expenditure.  As noted at the outset, “All the toilets together perform a discrete and critical function in the operation of the plumbing system”.  On the other hand, if you replace 8 out of 20 sinks in the building, that is not “a significant portion” of the 20 sinks, which are a major component of the plumbing system, even though perhaps not as critical as “all the toilets together”.  Interestingly, that brings us to 40% not being a “significant portion”.

So we don’t have a bright line test with the thirty per cent, more of a theme.  Most important though, it is not a percentage of dollars.  It is a percentage of some physical attribute such as feet of wiring.

Accounting People Can Be Too Abstract

Many accountants prefer numbers to words.  null You will not be able to make reasonable determinations under these rules without getting an understanding of the physicality of the building.  You see an invoice for a substantial amount to entirely replace an elevator.  Should you capitalize that?  Well, does this building that may be a thousand miles from where you are sitting have one elevator or four?  You probably cannot tell that from your depreciation schedule.  Even the accounting staff of the management company might not know.  So if you are involved in owning a few buildings and your tax accountants are asking seemingly odd questions, that is a sign that they are on the ball.

There are already teams formed in large firms to “go to market” with specially trained staff to make a real production out of this stuff.  In many cases, it may not be necessary, if regular accountants just widen their horizons a bit.

You can follow me on twitter @peterreillycpa.

Note

This is hardly a comprehensive treatment of the repair regulations.  It more the distillation that a tax geek would give to his less reading inclined brethren and his less than patient entrepreneurial clients.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Europe's Galileo satellites launched into wrong orbit
Paris, Aug 23 (IANS) European satellite launch company Arianespace announced Saturday that the two satellites of Europe's Galileo satellite navigation system launched Friday from the European spaceport in French Guiana were delivered into the wrong orbit.
 
 
UN to radically scale up fight against Ebola
Monrovia, Aug 23 (IANS/WAM) The UN has vowed to radically scale up support to fight the Ebola virus outbreak in West Africa and said more health workers will be brought to Liberia to deal with the disease.
 
 
White dwarf stars formed mysterious supernova
London, Aug 23 (IANS) Supernova 2014J is 11 million light years away from earth and was only seen by chance at the University of London Observatory this year.
 
 
Universe's earliest stars were monstrous: Study
Tokyo, Aug 23 (IANS) Little is known about the universe's earliest stars but if we believe astronomers, they might have been hundreds of times more massive than the sun.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Political stalemate continues, as opposition wants Sharif's head (Roundup)
Lahore/Islamabad, Aug 23 (IANS) Pakistan's political stalemate continued Saturday amid political discussions by the government to find a solution and protest leaders Imran Khan and Tahir-ul-Qadri refusing to give up...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Two British Indians charged with murder
London, Aug 23 (IANS) Two British Indian men were Saturday charged with stabbing and murdering a man on a London street, a media report said. Gaurav Sharma, 33, and Jaswinder Singh, 27, have been accused of attacking...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
11 militants killed in Libyan air strikes
Tripoli, Aug 23 (IANS) At least 11 Islamist militants were killed and 20 injured in air strikes in Libya Saturday, Xinhua reported citing military sources. Mohammed Ghiryany, spokesman for the Islamist armed group,...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
31 held in Hong Kong drug bust
Beijing, Aug 23 (IANS) At least 31 people were arrested for possessing drugs in two unlicensed bars in Hong Kong, police said Saturday. Hong Kong police seized drugs worth over 640,000 HK dollars (about 82,580...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Ten killed in attacks across Iraq
Baghdad, Aug 23 (IANS) Ten people were killed and 50 wounded in a wave of attacks across Iraq Saturday, security sources said. The deadliest attack occurred around mid-day when a suicide bomber blew an explosive-laden...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Egyptian court postpones trial of Morsi, 130 others
Cairo, Aug 23 (IANS) A criminal court in Egypt Saturday postponed the trial of ousted president Mohamad Morsi and 130 other defendants in a jailbreak case till Sep 15. The case was postponed to listen to the...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Yemeni army commander killed in bomb blast
Sana'a, Aug 23 (IANS) A high-ranking commander of the Yemeni armed forces was killed Saturday in a bomb attack in the port city of Aden, a government official said. Brigadier Ahmed Saleh Omari was killed in Aden's...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Poroshenko, Merkel call for peaceful settlement of Ukraine crisis
Kiev, Aug 23 (IANS) Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko and visiting German Chancellor Angela Merkel Saturday called for a peaceful resolution of the Ukraine crisis, the presidential press service said. At a joint...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
India women go down to England by 13 runs
Scarborough (England), Aug 23 (IANS) India women suffered a dramatic batting collapse losing five wickets for 30 runs and went down by 13 runs to England women in the second ODI for their second consecutive loss in the...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Five killed as Kenyan bus fall into river
Nairobi, Aug 23 (IANS) At least five people were killed and eight critically injured in a road accident in Kenya, police said Saturday. The accident occurred Friday night when a minibus plunged into Athi river, 35 km...
Read more on Politics Balla