Anthony Weiner Even Worse As A Pundit Than He Was As A Politician

Mar 29 2014, 12:56pm CDT | by

Anthony Weiner Even Worse As A Pundit Than He Was As A Politician
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

Remarkably, the man who was driven out of politics not once but twice for embarrassing personal scandals is proving to be even worse as a pundit than he was as a politician. In his first post as newly hired writer for Business Insider, Weiner has penned a terrible article on Tesla’s fight against political protectionism from car dealerships. In his post, Weiner ironically complains about Tesla’s defenders  ”simplistic” arguments and then goes on to provide analysis that is as simplistic and poorly reasoned as the dealership lobbyists and PR people we’ve been hearing from.

He starts by providing the reasons he thinks these laws might be good ideas:

Why would you want to have laws that require a car be purchased through a local dealer? Perhaps to protect a purchaser’s rights to easily enforce the warranty. To ensure the state’s ability to enforce the reams of unique state legal requirements that govern automobile sales, service and even disposal maybe. Or, it might just be a run-of-the-mill instinct for local rather than federal regulations to govern what, for many Americans, is the biggest purchase of their lives.

I guess his point here is that when a manufacturer opens up a store and sells directly to customers they are de facto above the law and unable to be regulated? That Tesla, whose cars can cost over $100,000, might find it profitable to not abide by warranties, or break laws, while local dealers won’t? There’s simply no argument here.  It’s a baseless assumption, and in fact it’s disproven by a variety of manufacturer direct sales by expensive and important products like Apple computers.

He continues, appealing to the wisdom and reasonableness of politicians:

Another issue with Tesla’s push to establish direct sales is that there isn’t an element of the current structure that regulators and lawmakers didn’t contemplate when these restrictions were implemented…

….Reasonable people may think regulations that get in the way of tech companies are all just bad laws. In Tesla’s case, some might consider bans on direct auto sales to be part of a protectionist regime set up by a powerful lobby — neighborhood car dealers — and unchallenged by a lazy industry that didn’t want to antagonize its sales force. Still, dismissing all existing regulations out of hand without recognizing them as the product of reasoning and careful consideration isn’t the answer.

The point here seems to be entirely that “trust me, politicians thought hard about this”. He hasn’t even come close to establishing these laws are in fact a good idea. And almost every reasonable person who is not either a politician or paid by the industry that has actually considered the economics of this issue has concluded that the arguments for the protectionists laws are wrong.  In contrast, those making the case for these laws are hardly demonstrating “reasoning and careful consideration” but are either as badly argued as Weiner’s piece or, like this from the President of the Greater New York Automobile Dealers Association, even worse:

“You go from dealer to dealer, working out the best price,” he said. “If you’re dealing with a monopoly, the way Tesla is… they can raise the price to whatever they want to raise it.”

This is completely at odds with basic economics. Making downstream businesses competitive doesn’t do anything to alleviate an upstream monopoly. In fact, these laws risk the problem of double marginalization where you have market power for manufacturers and retailers. But then again, politicians have been saying this for a long time so by Weiner’s reasoning I guess it must be true.

The piece, in short, is terrible. The entire content consists of 1) bad reasoning about these laws, and 2) assurances that we should trust politicians ability to reason carefully about these laws. The only value of the piece is that his first argument entirely disproves the second. Next time a politician wants to defend the wisdom of politicians he should choose an example where he can actually argue that a law they’ve passed is not a terrible idea.

Source: Forbes Business

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Sports meet in Kenya cancelled over Ebola fears
Nairobi, Aug 21 (IANS) The International Netball Federation (INF) cancelled an international meeting in Nairobi owing to deadly Ebola virus attack that has visited parts of Africa, Xinhua reported Wednesday.
 
 
UN chief condemns American journalist's killing
United Nations, Aug 21 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon Wednesday strongly condemned the killing of American journalist James Foley by extremist Islamist militants, calling it "an abominable crime".
 
 
Russia suspends four McDonald restaurants
Moscow, Aug 21 (IANS) Russia's consumer rights watchdog said Wednesday it has temporarily shut down four McDonald's restaurants here, including the first ever outlet in the country, citing sanitary violations.
 
 
Egypt mufti's adviser slams killing of US journalist
Cairo, Aug 20 (IANS) Ibrahim Negm, advisor to the mufti of Egypt, Wednesday denounced the beheading of US journalist James Foley by the Islamic State (IS) Sunni extremist group in Iraq, state-run MENA news agency reported.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

US admits failure to rescue journalist in Syria
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) The US had recently attempted to rescue a number of American hostages, including slain journalist James Foley held in Syria by the Islamic State, but the mission failed, Pentagon Press...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Zoe Saldana finally admits pregnancy
Los Angeles, Aug 21 (IANS) "Avatar" actress Zoe Saldana has for the first time acknowledged that she is pregnant via a video of her ALS Ice Bucket Challenge, an activity where people dump a bucket of ice water on one's...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Robin Williams to be honored by Billy Crystal
Billy Crystal will honor the late Robin Williams at the upcoming Emmy Awards. The 66-year-old comedian will lead tributes to his longtime friend, who was found dead at his home in Tiburon, California on August 11 after...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Kourtney Kardashian thinks cravings are 'fun'
Kourtney Kardashian thinks cravings are a ''fun'' part of pregnancy. The 35-year-old beauty, who is expecting her third child with boyfriend Scott Disick, admits she can't get enough of cheese and pickle sandwiches at...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Gwyneth Paltrow approves of Jennifer Lawrence
Gwyneth Paltrow reportedly approves of Chris Martin's new romance with Jennifer Lawrence. The 'Iron Man 3' star, who recently started dating 'Glee' co-creator Brad Falchuk, has reportedly given her estranged husband,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Israel to step up Gaza offensive: Netanyahu
Jerusalem, Aug 21 (IANS) Israel will step up the offensive in the Gaza Strip until rocket firing from there into Israel stops, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Wednesday in response to renewed Gaza rocket attacks...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
UN chief hails destruction of Syrian chemicals
United Nations, Aug 21 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon Wednesday welcomed the destruction of Syria's declared chemical weapons material on board the US Maritime Vessel Cape Ray. "This marks a significant...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
UAE president issues anti-terror law
Abu Dhabi, Aug 21 (IANS) UAE President Khalifa bin Zayed Al-Nahyan issued the country's anti-terrorism law Wednesday, state media reported. Though the media report did not specify the details of the law, but so far no...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Sports meet in Kenya cancelled over Ebola fears
Nairobi, Aug 21 (IANS) The International Netball Federation (INF) cancelled an international meeting in Nairobi owing to deadly Ebola virus attack that has visited parts of Africa, Xinhua reported Wednesday. Kenya...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Egypt to have three new provinces
Cairo, Aug 21 (IANS) Egypt is to establish three new provinces and demarcate others including Cairo, Giza and Suez, a government official said Wednesday. The new three provinces will be Middle Sinai, Alamin and Wahat...
Read more on Politics Balla