10 Updates

Supreme Court Debates When Employee-Stock Plans Should Dump Stock

Apr 3 2014, 3:22pm CDT | by

Justices wrestled with a difficult question at the U.S. Supreme Court today: If the executives in charge of a retirement plan that invests in company stock learn something bad about the company,...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

16 weeks ago

Supreme Court Debates When Employee-Stock Plans Should Dump Stock

Apr 3 2014, 3:22pm CDT | by

Justices wrestled with a difficult question at the U.S. Supreme Court today: If the executives in charge of a retirement plan that invests in company stock learn something bad about the company, should they sell?

That would fit the classic definition of insider trading, of course. And it could hardly be good public policy to encourage executives to help their own employees front-run the rest of the market by selling stock at an inflated price to saps who don’t know as much as they do.

Yet the Obama administration came perilously close to that position in arguments today in Fifth Third Bancorp v. Dudenhoeffer . When pressed by the justices on what a trustee of an employee stock plan should do when in possession of material, non-public information suggesting the stock is overvalued, Deputy Solicitor General Edwin S. Kneedler said “it would ordinarily be the right thing to do to sell.”

Seriously?

Justice Samuel Alito asked if Kneedler could possibly mean what he just said.

“No, he can’t — he can’t sell on the basis of inside information,” Kneedler backpedaled. “He could — I’m sorry, he could stop purchasing, which is –”

“But the market will see through that in about two seconds,” Justice Stephen Breyer snapped.

At issue in this case is whether plaintiff lawyers who pounce whenever a company’s stock price falls can make it past the initial motion for summary judgment, with claims that trustees of employee stock ownership plans should have dumped those shares because they knew they were overvalued. Congress carved out an exception for ESOPs from rules requiring retirement plans to diversify their holdings, under the theory that company stock ownership is a good thing and employees are free to put their retirement savings in other investments if they wish. (Despite silly articles like we’ve seen lately that confuse pension plans with self-directed 401(ks).)


Flash Player 9 or higher is required to view the chart
Click here to download Flash Player now

The justices struggled with how to apply centuries-old standards of fiduciary duties to the peculiar situation of trusts that invest in only one stock, overseen by company executives who may possess inside information.ESOPs hold over $1 trillion in assets and how the Supreme Court rules in this case could have broad implications for how they are run and whether companies take the risk of offering them at all.

For plaintiff lawyers, it’s simple: They should sell when the stock is “overvalued.” Or at the very least, put the fund in the hands of independent directors who don’t have inside information — and charge lots of money to oversee an investment which every employee knows is his or her own company’s stock.

Chief Justice John Roberts put the dilemma facing ESOP trustees in stark terms. Say a company executive possesses information suggesting the stock is overvalued, he asked.

Do you sell? In which case the beneficiaries’ holdings go way down and they sue you, or do you not sell? In which casse when the information comes out, the beneficiaries sue you because their value goes down. What are you supposed to do?

Alito added a wrinkle to that. What if the inside information is an unproven allegation that a company executive had engaged in illegal behavior? That would definitely make the stock go down if news got out. Should the ESOP release the news to the public, serving as a second conduit for company information even when that information is unconfirmed?

Kneedler didn’t have an answer for that. “Stop buying might be the right approach,” he said.

Robert A. Long of Covington & Burling, arguing for Fifth Third, urged the court to follow every appeals court that has considered the question so far and give the “ESOP fiduciary some leeway.” Because, as he noted, plaintiff lawyers could have sued Fifth Third’s ESOP if they had dumped all the bank’s stock after it plunged to $2 on concerns about its subprime lending practices. The price has since surged past $23.

“In this case, if the fiduciaries had shut down the ESOP, they would certainly have been sued because they would have violated the plan terms, and the — the plan has done very well,” he said. Ah, well, logic has never been the hallmark of securities class-action litigation.

 
Update
10

6 weeks ago

RM47mil KWSG contributions still unclaimed

Jun 9 2014 7:54am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Cambodia's Famous Battambang Circus
KUALA LUMPUR: About RM47 million of contributions in the Teachers Provident Fund (KWSG) still remain unclaimed, the Dewan Rakyat was told to ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
9

6 weeks ago

Gold shop lost almost RM1mil

Jun 9 2014 3:50am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Splendour In the Grass 2014 - Byron Bay
KANGAR: A gold shop owner lost almost RM1 million after after the safe on in his shop was broken into by r ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
8

6 weeks ago

Motion to debate MAS losses in Dewan Rakyat rejected

Jun 9 2014 3:39am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Federal Aviation Administration Bans All US Flights To Israel
KUALA LUMPUR: AN emergency motion to debate the losses incurred by Malaysia Airlines last year, amounting to RM1.2 billion was rejected by the Dewan Rakyat t ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
7

6 weeks ago

MH370 Tragedy: Hisham: RM27.6 mil spent on 1st phase of SAR

Jun 9 2014 2:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia spent some RM27.6 million in its first phase of the search operations for missing Malaysia Airline flight MH370, said Acting Transport Minister ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
6

7 weeks ago

9.1m litres of diesel seized in a month

Jun 8 2014 1:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

INDIA-CHINA-DIPLOMACY-TRADE
PUTRAJAYA: The Domestic Trade, Cooperatives, and Consumerism ministry has seized some 9.1 million litres of diesel and property worth RM58 million since mounting ‘Operasi Diesel Selatan’ in the southern states last month ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
5

7 weeks ago

Girl, 9, awarded RM2.78m compensation for medical negligence

Jun 6 2014 4:56am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Government Weekly Cabinet Meeting
KUALA LUMPUR: A nine-year-old girl who suffered brain damage during her birth at a government hospital was awarded over RM2.78 million in compensation ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
4

7 weeks ago

Malaysia's total trade in April up 12pc

Jun 5 2014 11:52pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's total trade in April 2014 rose by 12 per cent from a year ago to RM123.86 billion due to growing trading activities, International Trade and Industry Minister Datuk Seri Mustapa Mohamed sai ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
3

7 weeks ago

Works Ministry to spend RM20m for upgrading works at 50 accident black spots

Jun 4 2014 11:35pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Iskandar Johor Open - Previews
JOHOR BARU: The Works Ministry will implement upgrading works at 50 accident prone locations in the country that have been identified this year involving an allocation of RM ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
2

7 weeks ago

Najib launches loan scheme for Ramadan traders

Jun 4 2014 10:24pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

EurAsia Cup presented by DRB-HICOM - Day One
PUTRAJAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak today launches RM45 million Ramadan Baza ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
1

7 weeks ago

Residents bring up objection against Kidex to Suhakam

Jun 4 2014 4:49am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PETALING JAYA: A group of 20 Petaling Jaya residents held a meeting with the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) over their objection against the proposed RM2.2 billion Kinra ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

2014 Luxury Watches Have Final US Preview Before Their Release
2014 Luxury Watches Have Final US Preview Before Their Release
2014 Watch Releases From Swatch Group Brands The Breguet Madison Avenue boutique was busy June 26 with press and VIP clientele as the luxury watch brand used this date to celebrate “Tourbillon Day.” The event included...
 
 
China to produce its own 'Avatar'
Beijing, July 28 (IANS) China is preparing to produce its own 3D fantasy movie, based on romantic folklore, to make it an epic on par with the US blockbuster science-fiction movie "Avatar".
 
 
Sushma meets UML leaders, ends Nepal visit
Kathmandu, July 27 (IANS) External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj Sunday averted a diplomatic disaster by meeting leaders of the ruling CPN-UML just before returning to India after a three-day visit which she said was "productive" and "successful".
 
 
Nepal parliament panel okays energy deal with India
Kathmandu, July 27 (IANS) A parliamentary panel in Nepal Sunday asked the government to sign as soon as possible a "Power Trade Agreement" (PTA) with India under which New Delhi has proposed 100 percent Indian investment or joint ventures with Indian entities in the Himalayan country's power sector.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Twin blasts in Nigeria kill five
Abuja, July 28 (IANS) At least five people were killed in two bomb blasts in Nigeria's Kano city, a mainly Christian area, Sunday afternoon, police said. The first blast occurred under a bridge in the Sabon Gari...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Australia gives $5 mn for Gaza relief
Sydney, July 28 (IANS) The Australian government is providing five million Australian dollars (4.7 million US dollars) in urgent humanitarian assistance to Gaza, Foreign Minister Julie Bishop announced Monday. The...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
France wants expatriates to leave Libya
Paris, July 28 (IANS) French government Sunday called on all its nationals to quit Libya, "given the deteriorating security situation" prevailing in the African country. "All our nationals are invited to get in touch...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Israel denies responsibility for UN school attack deaths
Jerusalem, July 28 (IANS) The Israeli army Sunday denied responsibility for the deaths of 16 Palestinians during Thursday's attack on a UN school in northern Gaza. "The inquiry as well as documented footage conclude...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
India lose badminton semi-final to England 3-0
Glasgow, July 28 (IANS) India lost to England 3-0 in the semi-finals of the badminton competition at the Commonwealth Games here late Sunday night. India's men's and mixed doubles teams fought well over three games,...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Danielle O'Hara's husband accused of cheating
London, July 28 (IANS) Model Danielle O'Hara's footballer husband Jamie accused of cheating on her with a nightclub blonde. The news has surfaced just days after she unveiled a tattoo dedicated to her husband. Mirror....
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
CWG: India knocked out by England in badminton
Glasgow, July 28 (IANS) India were knocked out of badminton semi-finals 0-3 by England, who will now play for gold against Malaysia, who struggled their way past Singapore 3-2 at the Commonwealth Games here. England...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Real Madrid coach rules out another striker
Madrid, July 28 (IANS) Real Madrid coach Carlo Ancelotti has for the moment ruled out adding another striker to his star-packed squad. Speaking after his side's 1-1 draw against Inter Milan in California, which ended...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Ricciardo wins F1 Hungarian Grand Prix
Budapest, July 28 (IANS) Red Bull driver Daniel Ricciardo of Australia, in his rookie year on the F-1 circuit, won the Hungarian Grand Prix Sunday. He managed to slide by Ferrari's Fernando Alonso (Spain) who finished...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
UN chief appeals Israelis, Palestinians to extend truce
United Nations, July 28 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki- moon Sunday urged "in the strongest terms" both the Israelis and Palestinians to extend, for an additional 24 hours, the humanitarian ceasefire that was in...
Read more on Politics Balla