Employers' Huge Tax Refund Hopes Dashed by Supreme Court Severance Pay Ruling

Apr 4 2014, 4:59pm CDT | by

The Supreme Court’s unanimous reversal of the pro-employer, 2013 Sixth Court decision in U.S. v. Quality Stores Inc., has quashed any prospect of big tax refunds to employers for their past severance payouts to laid-off workers.

As we reported here in October, the Sixth Circuit ruled that severance payments to involuntarily severed employees were not taxable under FICA. Had the Supreme Court agreed, teams of employers would be due refunds for their FICA contributions in connection with severance payouts made during layoffs in the Great Recession. Unfortunately, the High Court reversed.

The Court ruled that severance payments employers made to involuntarily laid-off employees are “wages” and are taxable under FICA. The Court based its decision on an analysis of (1) the definition of “wages” in FICA—a statute that taxes “wages” paid by an employer or received by an employee “with respect to employment,” to fund Social Security and Medicare benefits—and (2) Internal Revenue Code (IRC) § 3402(o)—which governs income-tax withholding.

  1. As to the FICA definition—that “wages” means “all remuneration for employment, including the cash value of all remuneration (including benefits) paid in any medium other than cash,” FICA § 3121(b)—the Court held that severance payments are, “of course, ‘remuneration,’” and that “common sense dictates that employees receive the payments ‘for employment.’”
  2. As to IRC § 3402(o)—which provides that “any supplemental unemployment compensation benefit paid to an individual shall be treated as if it were a payment of wages by an employer to an employee” (emphasis added)—the Court rejected the Sixth Circuit’s ruling that the “as if” language meant severance payments were not covered by FICA’s “wages” definition.

But there is a silver lining. Employers will no longer face different tax requirements depending on where their severed employees worked. The High Court’s ruling resolves the inconsistency between lower courts that the Sixth Circuit’s Quality Stores decision created—as it was in direct odds with a Federal Circuit’s 2008 decision that severance payments are taxable under FICA (in a case titled CSX Corp. v. U.S.). In addition, the Supreme Court’s Quality Stores decision is consistent with the IRS’ long-held position on the taxability of severance payments, as well as with most employers’ current and long-term practices in compliance with that IRS position.

The Takeaway: No tax refunds on the horizon, but clear guidance and certainty for the future.

Copies of U.S. v. Quality Stores Inc., et al., No. 12-1408, 2014 WL 1168968 (March 25, 2014), and the two Circuit Court decisions the Supreme Court has reconciled—CSX Corp., et al. v. U.S., 518 F.3d 1328 (Fed. Cir. 2008), and U.S. v. Quality Stores Inc., et al., 693 F.3d 605 (6th Cir. 2013)—are available here, here and here, respectively.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Seals may have spread tuberculosis to humans: Study
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) In a bizarre turn of events, research shows that tuberculosis likely spread from humans in Africa to seals and sea lions that brought the disease to South America.
 
 
Banned substance still depleting ozone layer: NASA
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) In a significant revelation, NASA researchers have shown that the earth's atmosphere contains an unexpectedly large amount of an ozone-depleting compound from an unknown source, decades after the compound was banned worldwide.
 
 
Ebola spread in Nigeria under control: Minister
Abuja, Aug 21 (IANS) Nigeria has been successful in its efforts to control the spread of Ebola disease, a minister said.
 
 
Sports meet in Kenya cancelled over Ebola fears
Nairobi, Aug 21 (IANS) The International Netball Federation (INF) cancelled an international meeting in Nairobi owing to deadly Ebola virus attack that has visited parts of Africa, Xinhua reported Wednesday.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Chris Brown and Karrueche Tran trying for a baby
Chris Brown and Karrueche Tran are trying for a baby. The 25-year-old star confirmed the pair are back together after taking to his Instagram account to post a picture of the 26-year-old beauty and as well as thanking...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Seals may have spread tuberculosis to humans: Study
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) In a bizarre turn of events, research shows that tuberculosis likely spread from humans in Africa to seals and sea lions that brought the disease to South America. The sea animals then...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Fletcher has not been sidelined: Shastri
London, Aug 21 (IANS) Former India captain Ravi Shastri, who has been appointed the team director for the ODI series against England, said his role would be to oversee the team but added that chief coach Duncan...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
US offers bounty for Haqqani Network leaders
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) The US government has offered $30 million as bounty for information to locate leaders of the Haqqani Network that is blamed for attacks on American and NATO forces in Afghanistan. The US...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Thai military chief selected as interim PM
Bangkok, Aug 21 (IANS) Thailand's National Legislative Assembly (NLA) Thursday selected military junta chief Prayuth Chan-ocha as the interim prime minister. A total of 194 NLA members were present, with 191 of them...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Banned substance still depleting ozone layer: NASA
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) In a significant revelation, NASA researchers have shown that the earth's atmosphere contains an unexpectedly large amount of an ozone-depleting compound from an unknown source, decades after...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
Bush takes ice bucket challenge, nominates Clinton
Washington, Aug 21 (IANS) Former US president George W. Bush has joined celebrities across the world to take the ice bucket challenge to help raise money for Lou Gehrig's disease and has nominated his predecessor Bill...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Tom Hanks' typewriter app No 1 on Apple iTunes
New York, Aug 21 (IANS) Actor Tom Hank's recently-launched typewriter app for iPad has become the leading app at the Apple iTunes App Store. Called "Hanx Writer", it is now ranked No 1 in both the productivity as well...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Dougie Poynter and Ellie Goulding getting ready to wed?
Dougie Poynter and Ellie Goulding have been talking about marriage. The McBusted bassist - the only unmarried member of the band - and the 'Starry Eyed' singer are completely smitten with one another and friends are...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Jessica Alba had 'super' imagination
Jessica Alba used to imagine she was ''super-human''. The 'Fantastic Four' actress spent hours as a child dreaming of having special powers that would elevate her ahead of her peers. She said: ''When I was little, I...
Read more on Celebrity Balla