"Disgusting!," Cry Legal Experts: Is This The Lowest A Top U.S. Law Firm Has Ever Stooped?

Apr 13 2014, 11:57am CDT | by

"Disgusting!," Cry Legal Experts: Is This The Lowest A Top U.S. Law Firm Has Ever Stooped?
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

Would any self-respecting U.S. law firm represent a client who suggested the Jews deserved the Holocaust? Probably not. As a matter of honor, most law firms would run a mile, and even the least honorable would conclude that the damage to their reputation wasn’t worth it.

Where imperial Japan’s atrocities are concerned, however, at least one top U.S. law firm hasn’t been so choosy. In what is surely one of the most controversial civil suits ever filed in the United States, the Los Angeles office of Mayer Brown is trying to prove that the so-called comfort women – the sex slaves used by the Imperial Japanese Army in World War II – were no more than common prostitutes.

The suit has been filed on behalf of two Japanese-Americans, Michiko Shiota Gingery and Koichi Mera, plus a corporation called GAHT-US (a bizarre entity whose involvement must be a particular embarrassment to any decent person at Mayer Brown – more about this in a moment). At the center of the controversy is a memorial to the comfort women which was recently established in a park in Glendale, California. The suit suggests that the above named Japanese-Americans will suffer “irreparable injury” from “feelings of exclusion, discomfort, and anger” if the memorial is not removed.

This characterization is, of course, the functional equivalent of a suggestion that German-Americans suffer “irreparable injury” from memorials to the Jewish Holocaust. Basically it is preposterous.

Although the suit has so far been largely overlooked by the mainstream press, it has provoked outrage among legal bloggers. Here, for instance, is a comment from Ken White, a prominent Los Angeles-based criminal attorney: “I cannot remember a lawsuit that so immediately repulsed and enraged…..This lawsuit is thoroughly contemptible. It should fail, and everyone involved should face severe social consequences.”

Strong words but White’s assessment is hard to fault. The indisputable historical record, after all, shows that countless women who served in the Imperial Army’s brothels were innocents seized at gunpoint in the empire’s erstwhile colonies and forced into sexual servitude.

Even the Japanese government has admitted as much. Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Yohei Kono issued a widely publicized statement in 1993 acknowledging that there were “many cases” of agents acting on behalf of the Imperial Army “intimidating these women to be recruited against their will.”

The statement went on tacitly to acknowledge the comfort women’s enslaved status: “In the war areas, these women were forced to move with the military under constant military control and that they were deprived of their freedom and had to endure misery.”

The Kono statement was treated as front-page news by the American press at the time, but was hardly new news. To be sure it had been preceded by a long series of denials in Tokyo, a record taken at face value by an ever naïve American press; but the main allegations had been proved in a Dutch court under rigorous Western rules of evidence as far back as 1948. That court, which had been convened in what was then the Dutch East Indies (now Indonesia), had considered allegations that the Japanese army officers had forced many Dutch women seized in the Dutch East Indies into sexual slavery. One Japanese military official was executed and several others were sentenced to jail terms. The Dutch went on in 1956 successfully to press the Japanese government to pay compensation to the women, an almost unheard-of achievement in Western diplomacy (the Japanese establishment has otherwise proved highly successful in stonewalling countless compensation claims from other victims of war atrocities). In 1985 details of the comfort women story of were published in an official Dutch government history of the war.

As for GAHT-US, its full name is the Global Alliance for Historical Truth-US. If that sounds impressive, its genesis is less so. It was incorporated as recently as February 6 and uses a UPS office as its official address. The really controversial part is that its name has evidently been chosen so it would be confused with a very different entity, the Global Alliance for Preserving the History of WWII in Asia. This latter is a long-established, entirely respectable scholarly group founded by Chinese-American professors that is on the other side of the comfort women argument.  The first two responses to a Google search today  for  “Global Alliance for Historical Truth” brought up the Chinese-American entity, thus suggesting that respectable Chinese-American opinion endorses the effort to brand the comfort women as prostitutes.

For the record I emailed the four Mayer Brown attorneys involved in this case – Neil Soltman, Matthew Marmolejo, Ruth Zadikany, and Rebecca Johns – for a comment. I also emailed the firm’s chief executive Paul Theiss. I received no responses. Reached by phone, Soltman referred me to the firm’s public relations officer Bob Harris but Harris also failed to respond.

Should Mayer Brown have taken on this suit? Here is the opinion of the prominent First Amendment attorney Marc Randazza: “Every law firm gets confronted (on a pretty regular basis) with the question: ‘should I put my name on this?’ That soul searching comes into play when you wonder, ‘is this honorable?’ You know when it is, and when it isn’t. I’m not talking about representing a client that you know is guilty — they deserve a defense. I’m not talking about representing a really evil client — because there might be an important legal issue in play. I’m talking about when you do something truly disgusting.”

Why therefore would Mayer Brown, which ranks among America’s top 20 corporate law firms, take on such a case? Beats me but one answer suggested by a commenter at Ken White’s website is probably worth passing on: “Mayer Brown has a heavy practice in Asia…. They are probably either doing this as a favor to a large client, or trying to expand their Asia presence to Japan.”

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Trim down your 'side fat'
Los Angeles, Aug 28 (IANS) Eliminate that extra padding on the sides of your waist by doing the right moves, eating well and moving around.
 
 
Girl-gang members at greater risk of unprotected sex
New York, Aug 28 (IANS) Young girls who join gangs to find their lost freedom are at a greater risk of unprotected sex with multiple partners and substance abuse, says a new study.
 
 
Diaspora meet to focus on Bahrain-India trade
Dubai, Aug 28 (IANS) A key meeting of the Indian diaspora in Bahrain next week will set the stage for partnership agreements and investment announcements initiated during and after King Hamad's visit to India in February this year, a Bahrain daily reported Thursday.
 
 
US banks victims of 'sophisticated' cyber attack: Report
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) JP Morgan Chase and at least four other US banks have been victims of a "sophisticated" series of cyber attacks this month, sources close to the investigation told The New York Times.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Trim down your 'side fat'
Los Angeles, Aug 28 (IANS) Eliminate that extra padding on the sides of your waist by doing the right moves, eating well and moving around. Celebrity trainer and nutrition expert Harley Pasternak suggests how to do...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Girl-gang members at greater risk of unprotected sex
New York, Aug 28 (IANS) Young girls who join gangs to find their lost freedom are at a greater risk of unprotected sex with multiple partners and substance abuse, says a new study. Adolescents who have strained...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Father of South Korean ferry accident victim ends fast
Seoul, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The father of one of the victims of the South Korean ferry tragedy Thursday ended a 46-day hunger strike against the government that inspired tens of thousands of people to join his cause...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Murder case registered against Pakistani PM, 20 others
Islamabad, Aug 28 (IANS) Pakistani police Thursday afternoon registered a murder case against Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and 20 others for their alleged involvement in the police shootout June 17 that killed 14...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Diaspora meet to focus on Bahrain-India trade
Dubai, Aug 28 (IANS) A key meeting of the Indian diaspora in Bahrain next week will set the stage for partnership agreements and investment announcements initiated during and after King Hamad's visit to India in...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
US banks victims of 'sophisticated' cyber attack: Report
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) JP Morgan Chase and at least four other US banks have been victims of a "sophisticated" series of cyber attacks this month, sources close to the investigation told The New York Times....
Read more on Business Balla
 
Pakistan government ready to file FIR against Sharif
Islamabad, Aug 28 (IANS) The Pakistan government Thursday said it was ready to lodge a first information report (FIR) against Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, among others, in Lahore's Model Town tragedy case that resulted...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Rooney named England captain
London, Aug 28 (IANS) Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney was Thursday named captain of the England national football team. Rooney takes over from Liverpool's Steven Gerrard, who retired after England's World Cup...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Lily Allen launches range of fake nails
London, Aug 28 (IANS) Singer Lily Allen has collaborated with beauty accessories company Elegant Touch for her new collection Lily Loves Nails. The collection features a series of fun and bright fake nail sets,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Yawning contagious in wolves too
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS) A new study has suggested that wolves tend to yawn when they see one of their brethren indulging in the act -- just like the humans. This kind of contagious behaviour could be a sign that...
Read more on Apple Balla