Donald Rumsfeld Goes Tax Protester On IRS, But Should Aim At Congress

Apr 17 2014, 3:23am CDT | by

Donald Rumsfeld Goes Tax Protester On IRS, But Should Aim At Congress
Photo Credit: Forbes Business

Donald Rumsfeld was always direct. Now his signature bluntness is aimed at the IRS, although Congress arguably deserves his ire even more. In a letter to the IRS, he complains bitterly about our tax code. Its complexity is a “sad commentary on governance in our nation’s capital,” the former Defense Secretary says.

Although he and his wife both signed the returns as required under penalties of perjury, he gives a harsh confession:

The tax code is so complex and the forms so complicated,  that I know that I cannot have any confidence that I know what is being requested and therefore I cannot and do not know, and I suspect a great many Americans cannot know, whether or not their tax returns are accurate.”

Is Mr. Rumsfeld a tax protester? Not really, but even if you can call it that, he’s clearly right. Cleverly, he didn’t alter the penalties of perjury line on his Form 1040. He also didn’t write something under this signature like “without recourse” or “unlawful.” His who’s on first letter to the IRS was separate, just complaining that the tax code is so complex that neither he nor his wife know if it is right.

A line of case law considers whether altered tax returns are actually “returns” for purposes of filing deadlines, the statute of limitations, and more. In that sense, Mr. Rumsfeld remains cagey. He stopped short of saying he didn’t even look through the return after the accountants prepared it. Of course, he’s right that most people cannot hope to understand a complex return, or often even a simple one.

The last decade gave us the Timothy Geithner defense to tax return mistakes (“TurboTax made me do it!”). Then in the aftermath of the mortgage and foreclosure meltdown, officials at big financial institutions popularized robo-signing of loan or foreclosure documents. The parallel with tax returns is the robo-signer defense: “I didn’t read my tax return—I just signed it.”

Besides, most tax returns are not self-prepared. A majority of people have someone do their taxes. Most members of Congress don’t do their own. With over half our returns prepared by someone else, it is no wonder that many taxpayers assume their returns are written in an unintelligible runic script. Even lawmakers can’t do their own.

We are supposed to read and understand the return, and we must sign under penalties of perjury. We should review it before signing and alert the return preparer to any mistakes we discover. But how often does this happen?

The situation seems worse today than ever before, because of the vast and unending complexity of our moribund tax system. Electronic filing doesn’t help. Consider the simple mechanics. There is a marked contrast between the mechanics of paper vs. electronic filing. With a traditional paper filing, at least the taxpayer signed the return before mailing. That imports a certain amount of due diligence.

Sure, they could sign without reading. But with e-filing, the client may not even see the return. The client should review the return, and the return preparer should ask the client to verify that all figures are correct, the correct boxes are checked, and so on.

But even a signature  in the traditional sense may be lacking. Instead of physically signing the return, electronic filing is, well, electronic. The taxpayer and the preparer enter numbers. Before filing, the taxpayer signs a signature authorization form (Form 8879) saying the taxpayer has reviewed the electronic return, it is accurate, etc. In the old days, at least the return had to be printed out and the taxpayer had to sign.

Is the IRS responsible for part of the complexity? Sure. But the tax code is Congress’ baby. Perhaps it deserves to be thrown out to make room for a brand new one.

You can reach me at This discussion is not intended as legal advice, and cannot be relied upon for any purpose without the services of a qualified professional.


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Chinese unmanned lunar orbiter returns home
Beijing, Nov 1 (IANS) China succeeded Saturday in the world's first mission to the Moon and back, becoming the third nation to do so after the former Soviet Union and the US.
China pledges $81 mn financial assistance for Afghanistan
Beijing, Oct 31 (IANS) China Friday pledged to provide non-reimbursable assistance of 500 million yuan (about 81 million dollars) to Afghanistan this year at an international meeting on Afghanistan held here.
EU seeks talks with Russia over goods duties: WTO
Geneva, Oct 31 (IANS) The European Union (EU) has sought a consultation with Russia over the tariffs the latter imposed on certain agricultural and manufactured goods, the World Trade Organisation (WTO) said Friday.
Virgin Galactic's spaceship crashes during test flight
Los Angeles, Nov 1 (IANS) A passenger rocket plane developed by Virgin Galactic's crashed Friday after suffering an "in-flight anomaly" during a powered test flight over the US state of California, the company said.

Latest from the Network

Scott Disick is battling severe anxiety
Scott Disick admits his anxiety makes him ''literally want to jump out of my skin.'' The 31-year-old reality TV star - whose longtime girlfriend Kourtney Kardashian is set to give birth to their third child in December...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Demi Lovato wants to be 'sexier' this Halloween
Demi Lovato says working out has boosted her confidence. The 22-year-old singer, who sought treatment for a number of issues, including an eating disorder, in rehab in late 2010, is planning to wear a ''sexier''...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Usher's son is his toughest critic
Usher's son doesn't think he's a great singer. The 'She Came To Give It To You' hitmaker admits his youngest child, Nayvid, five, is very critical of his performances. The 36-year-old star said: ''He doesn't care about...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Rogen may star in Steve Jobs biopic
Los Angeles, Nov 1 (IANS) Actor Seth Rogen is reportedly in talks with Sony studio to star as Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak in their upcoming Steve Jobs biopic. "Zero Dark Thirty" star Jessica Chastain is also being...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Lindsay Lohan denies dating Tom Cruise
London, Nov 1 (IANS) Actress Lindsay Lohan has denied she's secretly dating actor Tom Cruise. The duo reportedly swapped numbers here recently, and have been meeting up since. But now Lohan's representative said the...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Three Iraqis arrested on terror charges in Switzerland
Geneva, Nov 1 (IANS) Swiss authorities Friday said they arrested three Iraqi nationals suspected of planning a terrorist attack in Europe. The office of the attorney general of Switzerland said in a statement that the...
Read more on Politics Balla
Pakistan repatriates 29 Afghans
Islamabad, Oct 31 (IANS) Pakistan handed over 29 Afghans arrested during a military operation in its northwestern tribal region to Afghan authorities, the army said Friday. The Pakistani security forces had launched a...
Read more on Politics Balla
Less than half of Americans support stricter gun laws: Poll
Washington, Oct 31 (IANS) Less than half of Americans said they back tougher gun laws, which is significantly lower than the 58 percent recorded just after the 2012 school shooting in Newtown, Connecticut, that left 20...
Read more on Politics Balla
Zimbabwe's main opposition calls for fresh polls again
Harare, Oct 31 (IANS) Zimbabwe's opposition MDC-T party said Friday economic challenges confronting the country could only be resolved if the country holds free and fair polls. MDC-T president Morgan Tsvangirai told...
Read more on Politics Balla
Trapped miners confirmed dead: Colombia
Bogota, Oct 31 (IANS/EFE) Twelve workers trapped by a flood inside a coal mine in the northwestern province of Antioquia are dead, Colombian authorities said Friday. "With an inspection we made in the night hours, we...
Read more on Politics Balla