New Medicare Data Reveal Startling $496 Million Wasted On Chiropractors

Apr 20 2014, 10:54am CDT | by

Ten days ago, the federal government released a huge data set detailing how it spent $77 billion in Medicare funds in 2012 to over 880,000 health care providers. The release of this data is part of a new transparency effort by the government, which many of us applaud.

The data reveal some troubling things.

Most news organizations focused on who the biggest beneficiaries are: the New York Times described how just 100 doctors received $610 million. A Washington Post story focused on the top 10 Medicare billers, including one ophthalmologist in Florida who was paid $20 million by Medicare, mostly to cover Lucentis, a drug for macular degeneration. The Post pointed out that Medicare would have saved over $10 million less if that doctor used Avastin, which is equally effective. “Medicare pays a doctor more for injecting the more expensive drug,” the Post pointed out.

But until now, no one has pointed out another, far more egregious waste revealed by the Medicare data: we are spending a huge amount of money on the highly dubious practice known as chiropractic.

To be precise, the 2012 Medicare data reveals that in 2012, Medicare paid $496 million for chiropractic treatments in all 50 states.

This is a stunning amount. It dwarfs the funding that NIH wastes on alternative medicine through NCCAM, which is itself an egregious waste of money.

Chiropractors are not medical doctors. They primarily treat back pain, but they claim to treat a wide range of other conditions, which some of them believe are related to mis-alignments of the spine, called subluxations. This belief has no scientific basis. Nevertheless, chiropractors have succeeded in convincing the government to cover their treatments through Medicare.

Now we know how successful they have been: half a billion dollars a year spent “adjusting” the spines of patients, all funded by Medicare.

(And they have recently been lobbying furiously, as I wrote last summer, to force private health care providers to cover chiropractic and other alternative practices under Obamacare.)

But wait, you might ask, don’t chiropractors provide pain relief? And don’t they have medical degrees? Well, on the second question, the answer is that they have special Doctor of Chiropractic (D.C.) degrees, which are given out by just 15 special chiropractic colleges in the U.S. The entire field was invented out of thin air by D.D. Palmer in 1895, and later popularized by his son. In his book-length expose Chiropractic Abuse: An Insider’s Lament, chiropractor Preston Long lists “20 things most chiropractors won’t tell you,” including

  1. “Chiropractic theory and practice are not based on … knowledge related to health, disease, and health care.
  2. Many chiropractors promise too much.
  3. Our education is vastly inferior to that of medical doctors.”

These are just the first three: you can see the full list in a review of Long’s book by physician Harriet Hall, or read the book itself.

Sam Homola, a retired chiropractor, summarizing his concerns about chiropractic in a recent article at Science-Based Medicine, wrote that

“There is no credible evidence to support the use of spinal manipulation for anything other than uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain and … no evidence at all to support chiropractic subluxation theory.”

Perhaps most alarming, especially given that Medicare is paying for millions of treatments per year, is that chiropractic manipulation can cause a stroke, by causing a tear in the major artery running through the neck. As reported recently in the Journal of Neurosurgery:

“Chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine can produce dissections … of the vertebral and carotid arteries. These injuries can be severe, requiring endovascular stenting and cranial surgery. In this patient series, a significant percentage (31%, 4/13) of patients were left permanently disabled or died as a result of their arterial injuries.” [Albuquerque et al.J. Neurosurg 2011 115(6):1197-1205]

If this weren’t enough to cause concern, many chiropractors are also anti-vaccine, a problem that is apparently serious enough that some chiropractors themselves have spoken out against the anti-vaxxers in their own ranks.

Over a century ago, D.D. Palmer believed, mistakenly, that he cured a man’s deafness by manipulating his neck. His son built Palmer’s beliefs into a profitable business, but neither of them would have dreamed that the U.S. government would one day spend half a billion dollars per year on chiropractic manipulations.

If we want to start controlling the cost of Medicare, here’s an easy first step: stop covering chiropractic. We will save $496 million a year, and people’s health will improve.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Japanese government concerned by yen's rapid fall against dollar
Tokyo, Nov 21 (IANS/EFE) Japanese Finance Minister Taro Aso Friday expressed concern over the sharp depreciation of the yen against the dollar this week, and said abrupt movements in the foreign exchange market were not beneficial to the Japanese economy.
 
 
WHO declares DRC Ebola-free
Geneva, Nov 21 (IANS) The World Health Organisation (WHO) Friday declared the end of the Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).
 
 
Ultra rich population getting richer: Study
Washington, Nov 21 (IANS) Only 0.004 percent of the world's high networth adult population controls almost 13 percent of the world's total wealth, according to a new study.
 
 
Morocco, US organisation sign MoU on 'Enterprise City' project
Marrakech, Nov 21 (IANS) The Moroccan government and US institution Babson Global have signed a memorandum of understanding to conduct a feasibility study for the establishment of an "Enterprise City", a city dedicated to business, in the North African country.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

South African president calls for end to racism in sports
Johannesburg, Nov 21 (IANS) South African President Jacob Zuma Friday called for global efforts to end racism in sports. South Africa adds its voice to the billions of others throughout the world who are determined to...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Sheamus wants reality show for WWE Superstars
Sheamus wants to appear in a reality TV show about the WWE Superstars. The 36-year-old star believes the success of E! series 'Total Divas', which follows the lives of the female competitors in the company, has shown...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Bill Murray: Actors are heroes
Bill Murray thinks actors are heroes. The 'Ghostbusters' star - who recently had an entire day dedicated to him at Toronto Film Festival - claims people admire actors so much because they get to escape reality by...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Robin Williams' son: We're doing OK
Robin Williams' son says the late star's family are still adapting ''to the new normal'' following his father's death. The Hollywood actor died from asphyxia due to hanging at his home in August aged 63 and his eldest...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Jennifer Lopez exfoliates with diamonds
Jennifer Lopez exfoliates her legs with diamonds. The 'On the Floor' hitmaker reportedly swears by a $250 Australian-made body scrub that is made with ''diamond powder'' to keep cellulite at bay. A source close to the...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Indian golfers Atwal, Rashid tied 15th in Manila Masters
Manila, Nov 21 (IANS) Indian golfers Arjun Atwal and Rashid Khan shared the 15th position after the second round of the $1 million Manila Masters at the par-72 Manila Southwoods Golf and Country Club here Friday....
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Sarjubala, Saweety enter women's World boxing semis
Jeju (South Korea), Nov 21 (IANS) Indian boxers Shamjetsabam Sarjubala and Saweety reached the semi-finals of the Women's World Championships here Friday. Sarjubala started the proceedings with a dominating 3:0 win...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Japanese government concerned by yen's rapid fall against dollar
Tokyo, Nov 21 (IANS/EFE) Japanese Finance Minister Taro Aso Friday expressed concern over the sharp depreciation of the yen against the dollar this week, and said abrupt movements in the foreign exchange market were...
Read more on Business Balla
 
IS launches major offensive against Iraqi city
Baghdad, Nov 21 (IANS/EFE) The Islamic State (IS) Sunni radical group launched a large-scale offensive Friday on the Iraqi city of Ramadi, the capital of strife-torn Anbar province, a security source told Efe news...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Sri Lanka presidential election Jan 8
Colombo, Nov 21 (IANS) The Sri Lankan elections department Friday announced that the presidential election will be held Jan 8 next year. Elections Commissioner Mahinda Deshapriya said nominations will be called for...
Read more on Politics Balla