Busting The Stock Picker's Market Myth

Apr 21 2014, 9:32am CDT | by

The dispersion among individual stock returns varies over time. Low dispersion occurs when all stocks tend to move in the same direction, and high dispersion occurs when stocks tend to go their separate ways. It’s during a period of high dispersion we hear Wall Street gurus proclaim: “It’s a stock picker’s market.” The inference is that it’s easier to beat the market during these periods. That’s not true.

There is no evidence to support the notion that active stock selection is easier when there is wide dispersion among individual stock returns. A new study, titled Dispersion: Measuring Market Opportunity, by S&P Dow Jones debunks this myth. The data suggest that the probability actively managed mutual funds will outperform the market are no higher during periods of high dispersion than low dispersion.

According to the S&P Dow Jones study, dispersion gives us a way to measure the “potential value of stock selection ability.” If stocks are all heading largely in the same direction, (i.e., have relatively low dispersion), in theory, an active stock picker should find it particularly difficult to construct a portfolio that beats a benchmark index. On the other hand, during a period when individual stocks are acting more like independent assets, there should be a greater opportunity for skillful (or lucky) investors to outperform. Of course, there is simultaneously a greater opportunity for the less skillful (or unlucky) investor to underperform also.

Evidence from the S&P Dow Jones Indices Dispersion: Measuring Market Opportunity in Figure 1 shows little relationship between large-cap US actively managed fund success and dispersion of stocks in the S&P 500. Although there is higher dispersion among active fund returns during periods of high stock market dispersion (not shown), this fund dispersion does not increase the likelihood of outperformance by active managers within the large-cap US market segment.

Figure 1: Percentage of outperforming large-cap US equity funds and dispersion of the S&P 500

It’s often helpful to step back from the data and think about things logically. Why should there be a greater percentage of active fund managers who outperform during periods of high dispersion? Does skill increase during these periods? Are there more opportunities to outperform? I find these arguments suspect.

All the active fund managers buy from the same universe of stocks. Some may buy high-performing stocks during periods of high dispersion, but others are buying low-performing stocks. Thus, the only thing that changes is the amount in which the winners win by and the short-fall in which the losers lose by.  There should be no difference in the percentage of winning funds and losing funds, and that’s exactly what the S&P Dow Jones data infers.

Money managers have a number of clichés when trying to promote their services, and “It’s a stock pickers market” is among the top choices. But this is a hollow argument. There’s no extra benefit to using active management during periods of high stock market dispersion. If you’re lucky, you might pick a winning fund that hits the ball out of the park, but if you’re unlucky, you could dig a deep hole for your portfolio.

My advice is to buy the index where you’re assured to receive your fair share of return. I’d rather be certain of a good return with index funds than hopeful of a great one by betting on active management.

See blog disclosure here.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

US reporter requests privacy after release
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The US journalist, who was freed this week by the miltants in Syria after two years in captivity, Wednesday thanked everyone for their efforts to secure his release and asked for privacy to be with his family.
 
 
Congo confirms six Ebola cases
Brazzaville, Aug 28 (IANS) Six cases of the Ebola virus have been confirmed in Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Health Minister Felix Kabange Numbi said Wednesday.
 
 
IMF chief faces investigation in corruption case
Paris, Aug 27 (IANS/EFE) International Monetary Fund (IMF) chief Christine Lagarde has been put under investigation in France for "negligence" after being questioned for hours in a corruption case, judicial sources said Wednesday. She denied wrongdoing.
 
 
Whale tourism affecting marine animals' behaviour
London, Aug 27 (IANS) Boat trips to watch whales and dolphins may increasingly put the survival of marine mammals at risk, conservationists have warned.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Most people take my clothes too seriously: Rick Owens
Los Angeles, Aug 28 (IANS) American fashion designer Rick Owens believes his fans takes his designs too seriously. The California-born designer, known for his statement drop-crotch shorts and leather jackets, believes...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
US reporter requests privacy after release
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The US journalist, who was freed this week by the miltants in Syria after two years in captivity, Wednesday thanked everyone for their efforts to secure his release and asked for privacy...
Read more on Ad Balla
 
Chris Martin writes love songs about Jennifer Lawrence
Chris Martin is ''sweeping'' Jennifer Lawrence ''off her feet.'' The Coldplay frontman, who split from Gwyneth Paltrow in March after 10 years of marriage, has reportedly been pulling out all the stops to romance 'The...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Neil Young will continue to support ailing son
Neil Young and Pegi Young will continue to co-parent their ailing adult son. The 68-year-old 'Heart of Gold' hitmaker, who filed for divorce from the 61-year-old singer last month after 36-years of marriage, stated in...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Dating actresses best for Daniel Radcliffe
London, Aug 28 (IANS) Actor Daniel Radcliffe says dating actresses works well for him as they understand the demands of the industry. The "Harry Potter" actor is currently in a relationship with his "Kill Your...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Egypt accuses Morsi of leaking documents to Qatar
Cairo, Aug 28 (IANS) The Egyptian prosecution ordered Wednesday to temporarily detain former Islamist president Mohamed Morsi for 15 days on charges of leaking "national security documents" to Qatar, media reported....
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Poland sends humanitarian aid for Ukrainian soldiers
Warsaw, Aug 28 (IANS) The Polish National Defence Ministry said Wednesday humanitarian aid for Ukrainian troops is already on its way. Poland will provide around 320 tonnes of relief supplies, including food, blankets...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Child abuse: British police commissioner's resignation demanded
London, Aug 28 (IANS) Police commissioner of the British metropolitan county of South Yorkshire has come under fire from various quarters after an inquiry exposed shockingly child sexual abuses. Leaders from different...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
UN Security Council urges for immediate ceasefire in Libya
United Nations, Aug 28 (IANS) The UN Security Council Wednesday adopted a resolution on Libya, calling for an immediate ceasefire while expanding sanctions on those who involved in the violence there. The 15-member...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Cara Delevingne to star in 'Zoolander' sequel?
Los Angeles, Aug 28 (IANS) Model Cara Delevingne may star in the upcoming "Zoolander" follow-up alongside Ben Stiller. The 22-year-old model is said to be negotiating with the movies' star, Stiller, over the female...
Read more on Celebrity Balla