Your Home Is Not A Retirement Piggy Bank

Apr 21 2014, 3:38pm CDT | by

The investment bank J.P. Morgan recently released an interesting, very lengthy report on the state of the markets. Compelling reading, but the really arresting chart was all the way out on slide No. 65.

On that page, you learn the long-term performance statistics of a number of different asset classes. Here’s a simple list version of the chart:

  • Real estate (REITs): 11.2%
  • Gold: 8.4%
  • S&P 500: 8.2%
  • Foreign stocks (EAFE): 6.5%
  • Bonds: 6.3%
  • Homes: 2.7%
  • Inflation: 2.5%
  • Average investor: 2.3%

That’s what happened from 1993 through 2012, according to data gathered by market research firm Dalbar and cited by J.P. Morgan in its report. People tend to focus on the last item, the relative performance of the average mutual fund investor.

That’s a terrible result, I know, but I want to point out instead the two entries just above, inflation and home prices.

All investing at its root has the same goal, to beat inflation by a wide enough margin to allow your savings to grow by compounding in a reasonable period of time. Given that most people save for 20 to 30 years in order to retire, that is what we have to consider “reasonable.”

So, your target is double, double again and maybe double one more time. One becomes two, two becomes four, then becomes eight.

Zero growth

What many people do instead is focus on the single biggest asset in their lives, their home. That’s not a bad thing. Owning a home can be a great deal, since you get to live in it while you pay it off and the taxes and interest are deductible.

But you shouldn’t confuse owning a home with real retirement savings. Even if you plan to downsize, the amount cash you might realize in a sale and repurchase will not be significant.

Meanwhile, your home “investment” is only growing at about the rate of inflation, which is to say, by nearly zero.

Your return goal should be to safely double your savings every decade. That would require you to earn at least 7.2%. Add in normal inflation, and your goal becomes something closer to 10%.

Can you do that these days? The short answer is yes. An all-stock portfolio in the years from 1950 through 2013, a period which included every major market crash and hiccup in modern times, nevertheless gained 11% annualized.

A bond portfolio did 6.1%, and a 50-50 stock and bond mix returned 9%, according to J.P. Morgan’s analysis.

Lower costs

The real trick is owning enough stocks early, when those market declines are opportunities to buy rather than a headache to endure, then slowly move over to a less-volatile mix of income investments as you age.

That type of portfolio management is getting easier and easier to do at greatly reduced cost, thanks to ETFs and simple online software. So, yes, buy a home and keep it repaired and enjoy those tax breaks year after year.

Just don’t bet your retirement on it.

 
 
 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Best Buy kills its Future Shop Brand in Canada
Best Buy kills its Future Shop Brand in Canada
Best Buy announced today to shut down its Future Shop stores.
 
 
Ikea Foundation's Better Shelter has partnered with UNHCR for safer refugee hous
Ikea Foundation's Better Shelter has partnered with UNHCR for safer refugee housing
Better Shelter and the UNHCR recently joined together in providing refugees and displaced people with long-term housing units as global crises mount. But what is a Better Shelter and how does it help?
 
 
Ikea Foundation's Better Shelter has partnered with UNHCR for safer refugee hous
Ikea Foundation's Better Shelter has partnered with UNHCR for safer refugee housing
Better Shelter and the UNHCR recently joined together in providing refugees and displaced people with long-term housing units as global crises mount. But what is a Better Shelter and how does it help?
 
 
Facebook Announces Messenger Platform and Businesses on Messenger
Facebook Announces Messenger Platform and Businesses on Messenger
Facebook launches two initiatives to bolster its Messenger app.