10 Updates

The Limits of Sex-Segregated Marketing

Apr 23 2014, 10:57am CDT | by

In a recent Slate article , my daughter describes how in 2009 she and I unsuccessfully sued McDonald’s before the Connecticut Human Rights Commission for discriminating on the basis of sex in its...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

13 weeks ago

The Limits of Sex-Segregated Marketing

Apr 23 2014, 10:57am CDT | by

In a recent Slate article , my daughter describes how in 2009 she and I unsuccessfully sued McDonald’s before the Connecticut Human Rights Commission for discriminating on the basis of sex in its sale of Happy Meal toys.  When 11-year-old Antonia bought a Happy Meal at the counter, she wasn’t asked a question but was just given the “girl’s toy.”  When I ordered a Happy Meal at the drive-thru, an employee would ask me “Is it for a boy or girl?” and gave me a different toy depending on how I answered the question.  We alleged that both these behaviors violated Connecticut’s civil right statute, because the Happy Meal toy that McDonald’s provided was contingent on the customer’s sex.

The Commission’s response to our allegations was dismissive in more than just the legal sense:

It is not the business of the Commission to engage its resources for the purposes of titilation [sic] or sociological experiment. Complainants’ assertion that respondent violated complainants’ civil rights or denied complainants public accommodation or services on the basis of sex is absurd.

Putting aside the Commission’s misspelled suggestion that the civil rights allegations of an 11-year-old girl were made for the purposes of stimulating interest “especially in a sexual way ,” the Commission’s dismissal raises important questions about the limits of civil rights law.  Neither statute nor the case law give defendants a discrimination defense for only causing de minimus harm.  But should merely default discrimination should be actionable?  Giving Antonia a girl’s toy without asking her preference might not be a concern as long as Antonia can easily get the so-called boy’s toy just by asking.  Indeed, the Commission’s opinion went on to emphasize that:

Respondent did not require complainant to accept the Happy Meal it offered complainant. All complainants had to do was exchange the Happy Meal toy that respondent gave to Anna Ayres-Brown for the one Anna wanted.

But the ability of companies to adopt gendered frames depends on context.  Back in 2008 Antonia, in a letter to McDonald’s CEO , questioned whether it would be legal for an employer “to ask at a job interview whether someone wanted a man’s job or a woman’s job?”

The Connecticut Supreme Court in 1975 found that “sex-classification” in help-wanted advertising constitutes a per se violation of Connecticut law.  The same Human Rights Commission that dismissed our claims concerning “boy’s toy’s and girl’s toy” had, over thirty years earlier, found that segregating help-wanted advertisements categories (Help Wanted Male, Help Wanted Female, and Help Wanted Male/Female) was discriminatory even though job-seekers remained free to apply to jobs listed in any category.  In upholding the Commission’s order, the Connecticut Supreme Court reasoned:

It is part of a policy to eliminate sex-discrimination in its subtle as well as overt forms. The very act of classifying individuals by means of criteria irrelevant to the ultimate end sought to be accomplished operates in a discriminatory manner. . . . Symbolic discrimination as in the instant case is every bit as restrictive as naked exclusions. The distinction between ‘help wanted men’ and ‘help wanted men only, no women’ is nugatory. . . . The [Connecticut Fair Employment Practices Act] operates to eliminate not only the unjustified exclusion of people from occupations, but also the practices leading to and facilitating such discrimination.

Thus, notwithstanding the freedom of jobseekers to apply for either type of job, and the independent duty of employers to consider all jobseekers on a non-discriminatory basis, the mere framing of some jobs as “male” or “female” was held to be a restriction that offended the notion of fair employment. Default discrimination in employment is almost certainly illegal.

In other contexts, however, gendered-descriptions of products is ubiquitous and, as a matter of positive law, almost certainly legal.  The Position Statement that McDonald’s submitted to the Human Rights Commission pointed out that that department stores, cosmetic companies and clothing retailers frequently segregate their offerings into “men’s” and “women’s” categories.  Antonia and I take it as beyond argument that many of these practices fall outside the prohibition of public accommodation law.

But what principles should distinguish between contexts where sex-segregated marketing is illegal (e.g., employment advertisements) and contexts where sex-segregated marketing is legal (e.g., adult clothing advertisements).  In a law review article , that Antonia and I have written (and is forthcoming at the William & Mary Journal of Women and the Law), we propose three context-distinguishing factors concerning:

(a) the strength and legitimacy of customer preferences for sex-segregated categories;

(b) the existence of less restrictive alternatives; and,

(c) the likelihood of cognizable harms.

We argue that these preference, alternative, and harm factors militate toward finding that sex-segregated Happy Meal marketing to be actionable discrimination.  But we also acknowledge that reasonable people can differ, inter alia, about the degree to which gendered framing of toy choice produces a cognizable harm.

Thwarting Customer Choice

In follow-up testing conducted this past summer, we learned that at many stores employees’ behavior went far beyond gendered questions and default discrimination.  As Antonia described on Slate :

In a series of 30 visits, we sent boys and girls, ages 7-11, into 15 McDonald’s stores to independently order a Happy Meal at the counter. We found that 92.9 percent of the time, the storewithout asking, simply gave each child the toy that McDonald’s had designated for that child’s gender—a Justice fashion toy for girls and a Power Rangers toy for boys. What’s worse was the trouble the children encountered when they immediately returned to the counter and asked to exchange their unopened toy: 42.8 percent of stores refused to exchange for an opposite-sex toy.

In the most egregious instance, a McDonald’s employee asked a girl, “Would you like the girl’s toy?” The girl responded, “No, could I have the boy’s toy?” When the girl opened the container a moment later, she learned that notwithstanding her explicit request, a McDonald’s employee had given her the girl’s toy. This girl went back to the counter with the unopened toy and requested, “May I have a boy’s toy, please?” The same McDonald’s employee replied, “There are only girl’s toys.” We then sent an adult male into the store who immediately was given a boy’s toy.

It’s probable that this employee lied to the girl because of her sex.  To my mind, this is pretty clearly an example of actionable discrimination.  The heartening news is that McDonald’s has taken our empiricism very seriously and in December sent Antonia a letter committing to real change .

Stepping back, I can still empathize with those who react to our efforts as trying to make a mountain at of a molehill.  It might seem unlikely that a small-scale study of toy choice could illuminate an important civil rights issue.  Then again, at least in one instance a small-scale social science study about toy choice did just that.  In Brown vs. Board of Education , the Supreme Court cited to a doll study conducted by Kenneth and Mamie Clark which found that many black children preferred playing with white dolls to black dolls.  While the focus of our toy study is markedly different, the Clark study reminds us that children’s choices of playthings can reflect and reproduce the residue of discrimination in society more generally.

 
Update
10

6 weeks ago

RM47mil KWSG contributions still unclaimed

Jun 9 2014 7:54am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Cambodia's Famous Battambang Circus
KUALA LUMPUR: About RM47 million of contributions in the Teachers Provident Fund (KWSG) still remain unclaimed, the Dewa ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
9

6 weeks ago

Gold shop lost almost RM1mil

Jun 9 2014 3:50am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Sydney FC v West Ham United - Football United New Zealand Tour 2014
KANGAR: A gold shop owner lost almost RM1 million after after the safe on in his shop was broken ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
8

6 weeks ago

Motion to debate MAS losses in Dewan Rakyat rejected

Jun 9 2014 3:39am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Federal Aviation Administration Bans All US Flights To Israel
KUALA LUMPUR: AN emergency motion to debate the losses incurred by Malaysia Airlines last year, amounting to RM1.2 billion was rejected b ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
7

6 weeks ago

MH370 Tragedy: Hisham: RM27.6 mil spent on 1st phase of SAR

Jun 9 2014 2:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia spent some RM27.6 million in its first phase of the search operations for missing Malaysia Airline flight MH370, said Acting Transport Minister, Datuk Seri Hish ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
6

6 weeks ago

9.1m litres of diesel seized in a month

Jun 8 2014 1:11am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

INDIA-CHINA-DIPLOMACY-TRADE
PUTRAJAYA: The Domestic Trade, Cooperatives, and Consumerism ministry has seized some 9.1 million litres of diesel and property worth RM58 million since mounting ‘Operasi Diesel Selatan’ in the southern ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
5

7 weeks ago

Girl, 9, awarded RM2.78m compensation for medical negligence

Jun 6 2014 4:56am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Government Weekly Cabinet Meeting
KUALA LUMPUR: A nine-year-old girl who suffered brain damage during her birth at a government hospital was awarded over RM2.78 ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
4

7 weeks ago

Malaysia's total trade in April up 12pc

Jun 5 2014 11:52pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's total trade in April 2014 rose by 12 per cent from a year ago to RM123.86 billion due to growing trading activities, International Trade and Industry Minister Datuk Seri Mustapa ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
3

7 weeks ago

Works Ministry to spend RM20m for upgrading works at 50 accident black spots

Jun 4 2014 11:35pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

Iskandar Johor Open - Previews
JOHOR BARU: The Works Ministry will implement upgrading works at 50 accident prone locations in the country that have been identified this year involving an allocation of ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
2

7 weeks ago

Najib launches loan scheme for Ramadan traders

Jun 4 2014 10:24pm CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

EurAsia Cup presented by DRB-HICOM - Day One
PUTRAJAYA: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak today launches RM45 million Ramadan Bazaa ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 
Update
1

7 weeks ago

Residents bring up objection against Kidex to Suhakam

Jun 4 2014 4:49am CDT | Source: Business Times Malaysia

PETALING JAYA: A group of 20 Petaling Jaya residents held a meeting with the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia (Suhakam) over their objection against the proposed RM2.2 billion Kinrara Damansara Skyway (Kidex) toda ...
Source: Business Times Malaysia   Full article at: Business Times Malaysia
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

China to boost infrastructure in Tibet
Beijing, July 26 (IANS) China has vowed to upgrade the transport infrastructure in Tibet and expand the existing network of rail, road and air routes within the next six years.
 
 
Global film industry gender-biased: Study
London, July 26 (IANS) A study has revealed that only 22 percent of the crew involved in making 2,000 of the biggest grossing films worldwide over the past 20 years were women.
 
 
Nigeria fourth country in West Africa to report Ebola death
Accra, July 26 (IANS) Nigeria has become the fourth country in the West African region to record a death from the deadly Ebola disease, the country's Health Minister Onyebuchi Chukwu has confirmed.
 
 
Erotic thoughts key to female orgasm: Study
London, July 26 (IANS) Women who miss on orgasm should focus more on their their bodily sensations during intercourse and try to have more erotic thoughts during the act, a fascinating study reveals.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

India beat Scotland 6-2 in hockey
Glasgow, July 26 (IANS) The Indian men's hockey team defeated Scotland 6-2 in their second Pool A match of the Commonwealth Games at the Glasgow National Hockey Centre here Saturday. After drubbing Wales 3-1 in the...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Charlize Theron gets seal of approval from Sean Penn's daughter
Charlize Theron has gotten the seal of approval from Sean Penn's daughter. The 38-year-old actress has been dating Sean, 53, for the past eight months and his daughter Dylan, 23, from his marriage to Robin Wright, is...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Liberty Ross and Rupert Sanders finalize divorce
Liberty Ross and Rupert Sanders have finalized their divorce. The former couple formally ended their marriage on Friday (25.07.14), two years after he was caught cheating with Kristen Stewart, according to TMZ which...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Susan Sarandon reveals Bowie affair
Susan Sarandon says she had a love affair with David Bowie in the 1980s. The 67-year-old actress fell for the singer when they worked on the movie 'The Hunger' together in 1983 but split up because she didn't want...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Sexual abuse lawsuit against Bryan Singer dropped
A sexual abuse lawsuit against Bryan Singer has been dropped. The 'X-Men: Days of Future Past' director was accused by an anonymous British actor - identified only as John Doe No. 117 - of abusing him as a teenager but...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Shooters Rahi, Anisa ensure India two more medals
Glasgow, July 26 (IANS) Shooters Rahi Sarnobat and Anisa Sayyed ensured India another gold and silver after topping the women's 25-metre pistol semifinal at the Barry Buddon Shooting Centre to qualify for the gold...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Lifter Meena 5th in women's 58 kg bronze
Glasgow, July 26 (IANS) Indian weightlifter Meena Kumari missed the bronze in the women's 58 kg category to finish fifth in the Commonwealth Games here Saturday. England's Zoe Smith, who won the bronze four years ago...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
India need Shami to fire at Rose Bowl
Hampshire, July 26 (IANS/RAY) If pacer Mohammed Shami fires in the third India-England Test match for the Pataudi Trophy starting at the Rose Bowl here Sunday, the tourists could be well placed to hold their own. The...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Boxers Vijender, Manoj in last 16
Glasgow, July 26 (IANS) Indian boxers Vijender Singh and Manoj Kumar won their respective bouts to advance to the Round of 16 at the Commonwealth Games at the Scottish Exhibition and Conference Centre here Saturday....
Read more on Sport Balla
 
China to boost infrastructure in Tibet
Beijing, July 26 (IANS) China has vowed to upgrade the transport infrastructure in Tibet and expand the existing network of rail, road and air routes within the next six years. China's ministry of transport (MOT), in...
Read more on Politics Balla