Keep Questioning Why College Athletes Cannot Command More Money

Apr 26 2014, 9:17am CDT | by

The NCAA and businesses organized as “conferences,” including The Big Ten Conference, Southeastern Conference and Atlantic Coast Conference bring in billions of dollars on the backs of college athletes.  Spectators are enthralled by the skill of the athletes who take part in games organized and promoted by the NCAA and said conferences.  While the NCAA and the conferences can command compensation from massive television deals, ticket offerings and apparel sales based on what the marketplace will provide, athletes are capped in their earnings per what the NCAA and the conferences deem is an acceptable amount of remuneration.

The aforesaid is nothing new.  Today’s environment is one in which an effort by some Northwestern football players to unionize receives top billing and people are becoming very aware of players’ sincere concerns regarding safety, medical care and due process.  There is also a question left unanswered by any informed, non-interested party: Why does anyone believe (other than for self-interest, primarily based on direct or indirect monetary benefit) that amateurism exists?

Twitter has become a great tool for polling the masses and oftentimes receiving thoughtful responses, albeit limited to 140 characters (which refreshing more often than not).  I posed a question to my Followers with the preface that I understand college athletes benefit from scholarships, but why should there be a limitation on remuneration for those athletes who can command more money?

College athletes benefit from scholarships, but why the limitation on those who can command more?

— Darren Heitner (@DarrenHeitner) April 25, 2014

The overwhelming response was fascinating, because not a single reply provided a real justification.  The “they can demand more once they go pro” rationale is stale.  Everyone has seen the NCAA commercials that state, “ There are more than 400,000 NCAA student-athletes, and most of them go pro in something other than sports.”  The NCAA is not lying (other than the fact that they are really not student-athletes), the vast majority of college athletes do not make it in the professional ranks.  That includes some blue-chip prospects who would likely be able to command an amount of money greater than a full scholarship on the open market.  Why prevent them from receiving what they are worth while in school?

Then there is the paternal response.  The NCAA and conferences are charged with a responsibility to prevent college athletes from the distractions that come along with being able to enjoy money in their hands.  Employers must salivate when they read this line of justification for depressing wages.  It simply makes no sense.  College athletes are told that they cannot negotiate their worth, while their classmates are entitled to create new companies, be entrepreneurs and potentially make millions of dollars.  These are adults who have the right to vote in elections for individuals who will serve as public officers.  They do not need, desire or demand that the NCAA and conferences protect them from perceived and assumed distractions that follow the flow of money.

Numerous fallacious and unfounded responses are included on the thread; however, the people behind the replies should not be scolded — they spread theories the NCAA and conferences have been forcing down fans’ throats for decades.  Athletes should be content with receiving scholarships; they are in a better spot in life if they leave school debt-free?  If there are two options: perform for a team and receive absolutely nothing, or perform the same services and receive a scholarship, then receipt of a scholarship is easily the better choice.  However, once again, it does not answer why there should be an arbitrary restriction on remuneration to a college athlete.  Receipt of money in excess of cost of living is more desirable than the status quo.  Leaving school wealthy is being in a better spot than simply leaving school debt-free.

Throughout the Twitter discussion, I was most impressed by the fact that a compliance office was brave enough to chime in.  Winthrop’s Compliance Office should be praised for at least having the courage to engage in a debate on capping college athletes’ receipt of compensation.

@DarrenHeitner 99.99% of SAs in revenue prod. sports are receiving far more than their “free market value”. Not saying that justifies either

— Winthrop Compliance (@WUCompliance) April 25, 2014

The vast majority of college athletes would not receive more than what they are offered under the current system.  As acknowledged by Winthrop’s Compliance Officer, that still does not justify placing a limit on players who actually can command more money in an open market.

By the 2017-18 academic year, 12 of the 14 schools that comprise The Big Ten Conference (unless schools are added or eliminated by then) are projected to receive $44.5 million each from the league’s distribution plan.  There is no denying that college sports is big business.  Meanwhile, on April 25, former college athletes, including Minnesota Vikings and former Florida Gators defensive tackle Sharrif Floyd filed a lawsuit against the NCAA and many college conferences, claiming that they have jointly agreed and conspired with member institutions to deny college athletes the compensation they would otherwise receive for their services in a competitive market.  They have asked for trebled damages under the antitrust laws and that the NCAA, conferences and their “co-conspirators” be enjoined from applying their anti-competitive rules.

Lawsuits have been and will continued to be filed against the NCAA and major college conferences.  The filings contained therein may effectuate change.  Meanwhile, keep questioning why college athletes cannot command more money.  Keep the discourse alive.  Demand real answers.  Demand change.

Want to learn more about the business of sports? Order my book How to Play the Game and follow me on Twitter.

Follow @DarrenHeitner

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Mali confirms two new Ebola cases
United Nations, Nov 26 (IANS) Mali has confirmed two new cases of Ebola, bringing to total number of cases in the West African nation to eight, days ahead of the opening of a new UN Ebola response office.
 
 
Merkel warns of recession in Europe
Berlin, Nov 26 (IANS) German Chancellor Angela Merkel Tuesday warned that Europe could slide back into recession, media reported.
 
 
India, Nepal ink nine deals; Modi inaugurates trauma centre, bus service (Roundup)
Kathmandu, Nov 25 (IANS) Nepal's happiness "gives us joy", Prime Minister Narendra Modi said here Tuesday on his second visit to the Himalayan country in 100 days as both sides inked nine agreements, further cementing their close ties.
 
 
India, Nepal ink 10 deals; Modi inaugurates trauma centre, bus service (Intro Roundup)
Kathmandu, Nov 25 (IANS) Nepal's happiness "gives us joy", Prime Minister Narendra Modi said here Tuesday on his second visit to the Himalayan country in 100 days as both sides inked 10 agreements, including on $1 billion assistance to Nepal.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

US urges eradication of armed rebels in Congo
Washington, Nov 26 (IANS) The US Tuesday called for efforts to wipe out illegal armed groups in eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), as the number of civilians killed there has risen to some 200 in less than...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Eating healthy tough for Cumberbatch
Los Angeles, Nov 26 (IANS) Actor Benedict Cumberbatch says he struggles to eat health food. The "Sherlock" star says that despite trying his best to maintain his nutritious diet, he often struggles to keep it up while...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
24 killed in coal mine fire in China
Beijing, Nov 26 (IANS) At least 24 workers were killed and 52 others injured in coal mine fire in northeast China's Liaoning Province early Wednesday, the state-owned Liaoning Fuxin Coal Corporation said. The fire...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Jordin Sparks hits out at Jason Derulo
Jordin Sparks has taken a swipe at her ex-boyfriend Jason Derulo in a song. The 24-year-old beauty appears to take aim at her former lover, with whom she had a three-year relationship that ended in September, in her...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Eva Mendes reveals motherhood has brought 'wild nights'
Eva Mendes has had some of the ''wildest nights'' of her life since giving birth to her first child, Esmeralda Amada. The 40-year-old actress, who has been dating Ryan Gosling since 2011, gave birth six weeks ago and...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Cate Blanchett feels judged by other mothers
Cate Blanchett feels her parenting skills are being judged by other mothers. The Oscar-winning actress has three children - Dashielle, 12, Roman, 10 and Ignatuis, six - and says she's held to a different set of...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Jimmy Page reveals his admiration of Leona Lewis
Jimmy Page says performing with Leona Lewis was one of the highlights of his career. The Led Zepplin guitarist was asked to name the greatest moment of his professional life outside of the band and he cited performing...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
UN chief 'deeply concerned' over escalating violence in Libya
United Nations, Nov 26 (IANS) UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon Tuesday said he was "deeply concerned" over the recent escalating violence in Libya, calling on all parties to "end these attacks and prevent further...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Kate Hudson's fitness secrets
Los Angeles, Nov 26 (IANS) If you desire to have an incredibly toned physique a la Kate Hudson, you've got to work your "a** off", says the actress. The 35-year-old, who is a mother of two, says that her svelte figure...
Read more on Celebrity Balla