Push For Progressive Income Taxes Picks Up In The Blue States

Apr 29 2014, 1:51pm CDT | by

As opposed to Capitol Hill, where there is gridlock amid a divided federal government, most states around the country are under unified political control, with Republicans running the governor’s mansion and both chambers of the legislature in 24 states, while the Democrats do likewise in 13 states. As the halfway point of 2014 approaches, the two parties continue to take the states where they have unified partisan control in diametrically opposite directions from a policy standpoint.

In Democrat-run Illinois, whose state legislature is the place where President Obama learned the political ropes, liberal fiscal policy and its effects are on full display. Gov. Pat Quinn (D) signed into law massive “temporary” tax increases – a 66 percent individual income tax hike and 23 percent hike in the corporate rate – upon taking office in 2011. Gov. Quinn is now determined to prevent those tax increases from expiring later this year. However, in just the last few months, there have been a procession of additional tax increases proposed in the Land of Lincoln.

First there was the “millionaire’s tax” proposed by Speaker Mike Madigan (D-Chicago), the most powerful guy in Springfield, which would have actually increased taxes on the majority of small business profits in the state. Speaker Madigan recently withdrew the bill due to insufficient support from his own party.

Then there was the bill to impose a statewide soda tax, which would just punish lower and middle income households (the blue collar family on Chicago’s South Side is going to feel the pinch from an extra levy on a bottle of Coca-Cola a whole lot more than will the corporate lawyer in Winnetka), while doing nothing to improve health.

Now progressive activists, Democrat legislators, and the government employee unions who fund them both have their sights set on a graduated income tax, that way they can divide taxpayers into groups and mug them one at a time. Constitutional amendments that would move the Illinois income tax from a flat five percent to a progressive structure have been introduced by Rep. Naomi Jakobsson (D-Champaign) and Senator Don Harmon (D-Oak Park). Rep. Jakobsson’s proposal would result in seven income tax brackets, with the top rate nearly doubled to nine percent.

The Center for Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP), a liberal think tank, is a vocal proponent of the Illinois progressive income tax proposals. CBPP claims a graduated income tax will reduce income inequality. However, in a report issued this week, the non-partisan Tax Foundation points out how CBPP’s claim in completely false. As the Tax Foundation rebuttal of CBPP notes, while there is little variability in income inequality between progressive and flat tax states, income inequality is actually greater on average in states with a progressive income tax.

In fact, Illinois’ tax competitiveness would take a major hit if it were to adopt a progressive income tax. The Tax Foundation’s State Business Tax Climate measures and ranks the business tax climates of all 50 states in terms of economic competitiveness. The think tank has determined that should Rep. Jakobsson’s progressive income tax bill be approved, Illinois would drop from having the 32 nd to 44 th worst state business tax climate in the nation.

Of the 41 states with an income tax, eight of them have a flat tax. North Carolina was the most recent to join the flat tax state ranks with the passage of its historic tax reform bill in 2013, which reduced and flattened the state’s income tax, taking the top rate from 7.75 percent (previously the highest in the Southeast), to a flat 5.8 percent. With the bottom rate previously at six percent, all North Carolina taxpayers saw a rate reduction this year.

Flat Income Tax States

Colorado 4.63%
Illinois 5.0%
Indiana 3.4%
Massachusetts 5.25%
Michigan 4.33%
North Carolina 5.8%
Pennsylvania 3.07%
Utah 5.0%

Illinois lawmakers aren’t the only ones considering making their state revenues more volatile by instituting a progressive income tax. 2014 has seen renewed interest in a graduated income tax in Massachusetts, where Senate Majority Leader Stanley Rosenburg (D-Amherst) and others have introduced a constitutional amendment that would give the state legislature the authority to impose a tiered income tax.

Though lawmakers on Beacon Hill covet a progressive income tax, even the residents of deep blue Massachusetts, a state that went for Obama 61-38 percent in the 2012 presidential election, recognize the benefits that come with a flat tax, such as equal treatment from the tax man and greater budget stability. Since 1962, Bay State voters have rejected progressive income tax proposals at the ballot on five separate occasions, most recently in 1994.

Democratic state lawmakers, liberal advocacy groups, and other supporters of progressive income taxes claim that those who have higher incomes should pay more in taxes. Well, that is precisely what happens under a flat tax. Under a 5.25% flat tax like the one in Massachusetts, an individual with taxable income of $40,000 a year would owe the state $2,100, whereas someone with taxable income of $100,000 in a year would pay $5,250 in state income tax.

Tax Foundation economist Scott Drenkard made a strong case for moving to a flat state income tax in testimony before the North Carolina Senate Finance Committee last year, noting that “economic literature on progressive income taxes is especially unkind.” Drenkard pointed to an OECD study that found reductions in the top marginal income tax rate are beneficial to long term growth, as well as host of academic studies finding higher marginal tax rates reduce economic growth.

Lawmakers in Illinois, Massachusetts, and elsewhere would be wise to reject progressive income tax proposals. Fortunately, many states – such as Arizona, Louisiana, Nebraska, Wisconsin, Missouri, Georgia, and others – are considering proposals to move in the opposite direction, toward lower, flatter, more equitable and competitive state tax codes.

As has been mentioned in this space before, there is a great public policy experiment taking place in the U.S., and it is happening in state capitals across the country. States continue to move in different directions on fiscal policy and will, in time, demonstrate which approach works best.

 />/>

Patrick Gleason is Director of State Affairs at Americans for Tax Reform. Follow him on Twitter @PatrickMGleason 

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Nigerian opposition criticise government for currency devaluation
Abuja, Nov 27 (IANS) The All Progressives Congress(APC), Nigeria's main opposition party, Wednesday criticised the government for its move to devalue the country's currency naira.
 
 
Britain deploys military helicopters to aid for Ebola-hit Sierra Leone
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Britain has deployed Royal Navy helicopters to deliver materials to northern Sierra Leone as the part of its ongoing efforts to tackle Ebola, the British Department for International Development (DFID) said Wednesday.
 
 
Pakistan blocks three Saarc connectivity pacts; Modi, Sharif avoid meeting (Intro Roundup)
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Pakistan Wednesday played spoilsport by blocking three major Saarc connectivity projects initiated by India, even as Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi conspicuously avoided meeting his Pakistani counterpart Nawaz Sharif while he met five other South Asian leaders here.
 
 
Way out of debt crisis far from easy: Angela Merkel
Berlin, Nov 26 (IANS) German Chancellor Angela Merkel Wednesday said the way out of the European debt crisis is long and far from easy.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Japanese man sues women-only university for rejecting him
Tokyo, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) A young Japanese man is suing an all-female public university for gender discrimination after being denied admission, according to a media reports. The man, aspiring to enroll in Fukuoka...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Brown case highlights alarming pattern: Rights panel
Miami, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) The grand jury decision not to indict the white police officer who fatally shot unarmed black teenager Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri, spotlights "an alarming pattern of law enforcement...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
15 wins in a row great achievement: Ancelotti
Geneva, Nov 27 (IANS) Real Madrid coach Carlo Ancelotti has called Real Madrid's 15th straight victory "a great achievement" and said he expected Basel to advance in the Champions League. Real defeated Basel 1-0...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
41 prisoners flee Venezuela jail
Caracas, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) A total of 41 alleged criminals fled Wednesday morning from a jail in the central Venezuelan city of Los Teques in Miranda state. "According to preliminary information, around 2 a.m....
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Taxes may keep Jolie from buying British property
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Actress Angelina Jolie, who has been considering buying property in Britain, says the proposed 'mansion tax' could prevent her from doing so. The actress is a regular visitor to Britain due to...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Nigerian opposition criticise government for currency devaluation
Abuja, Nov 27 (IANS) The All Progressives Congress(APC), Nigeria's main opposition party, Wednesday criticised the government for its move to devalue the country's currency naira. ]The party objected that the policy...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Nick Cannon and Mariah Carey to spend Christmas together
Nick Cannon and Mariah Carey will spend Christmas together. The couple, who married in 2008, announced their separation earlier this year, but Nick has confirmed that won't stop him spending the festive season with his...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Yasmany Tomas Agrees to 6-Year, $68.5M Deal With Arizona Diamondbacks
Yasmany Tomas has agreed to a mega-deal with the Arizona Diamondbacks.The Cuban outfielder came to terms with the D-backs on a six-year, $68.5 million contract, per MLB.com's Jesse Sanchez:"Cuban outfielder Yasmany...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Johnny Depp feels 'like a fugitive'
Johnny Depp lives ''like a fugitive''. The Hollywood icon is among the most photographed people in the world, but insists he craves a more quiet life. Johnny, 51, said: ''I'm f*****g shy man. ''I'm living, in a sense,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Scott Disick says he hasn't slept with Kourtney Kardashian 'in five years'
Scott Disick has claimed he and Kourtney Kardashian ''haven't slept together in five years''. The 31-year-old reality TV star made the strange statement during a new episode of 'Kourtney And Khloe Take The Hamptons',...
Read more on Celebrity Balla