It's Not Just Banks That Are Too Big To Fail

Apr 30 2014, 9:17pm CDT | by

Following the financial crisis, worries about failures in over-the-counter (OTC) derivatives trading causing destabilizing runs and market crashes have led regulators to force most OTC trades to be cleared through central counterparties (CCPs). CCPs act like clearing banks, taking on their own books the risk of the seller defaulting. Sellers clearing OTC trades through a CCP can (in theory) default on payment without risking the entire system unravelling.

But this creates a problem. What happens if a CCP fails? Of course, the way CCP-cleared OTC trades are structured should minimize this risk. CCPs require sellers to post initial margin in the form of cash or government bonds to cover expected volatility during the lifetime of the trade, and they also require posting of variation margin in cash to cover daily price movements. As everything is fully margined in liquid safe assets, there should in theory be no shortfalls and no defaults.

But…..cash margin requirements don’t necessarily make the system safer. Firms with largely illiquid balance sheets, such as large insurance companies, can have difficulty raising the cash to meet large increases in variation margin. The principal cause of the failure of AIG in 2008 was cash margin calls on OTC credit default swaps that it was unable to meet. And this brings me back to the question – what happens if a CCP fails? Yes, a large insurance company unable to meet cash margin calls could perhaps be allowed to fail safely. But that doesn’t solve the CCP’s problem. If margin isn’t posted and the seller defaults, the CCP itself is at risk of failure – and that could have disastrous effects across wide swathes of the market. Far from making the system safer, clearing all OTC trades through CCPs could actually make it riskier.

When a CCP is placed at risk by a large seller defaulting on a trade for which it has failed to post margin – a scenario which is not as unlikely as it sounds – the CCP may call in resources from other CCP member firms of the CCP. This is called a “default waterfall” model and is not unlike the system whereby claims on deposit insurance when a bank fails are met from levies on the surviving banks. In the case of CCPs (and increasingly for bank deposit insurance, too) the levy is charged in advance and goes to create a “default fund”.

Regulators have also insisted that CCPs must have their own capital buffers to absorb losses due to member firm default.

But even this may not be enough. The scale of AIG’s losses, for example, would quickly have drained any default fund and wiped out most CCPs’ capital. In 2013, therefore, the Bank of England produced a paper discussing alternatives for resolving failed CCPs. In this paper, for the first time, the possibility of the buy-side sharing in the losses of a failed CCP was raised.

On the face of it, this seems wholly unreasonable. If a sell-side firm defaults, why should buy-side firms not involved in the trade take losses? The whole point of a CCP is to avoid generalised losses across the whole industry. This seems like a dilution of the purpose of CCPs.

And yet Risk magazine reports (paywall) that two asset management firms, Blackrock and Citadel, have endorsed the idea that the buy-side should share CCP losses, perhaps by taking a haircut on margin payments to them from the CCP – which was one of the suggestions in the Bank of England paper. The firms say that it is unreasonable for clients in CCP-cleared OTC trades to expect to bear no counterparty risk:

Taking the risk away completely could itself be dangerous, argued Athanassios Diplas, senior advisor to the board of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association and principal of Diplas Advisors. He said a government backstop for CCPs would present a moral hazard, allowing people to behave improperly with the guarantee that they will be bailed out in the case of a default. For this reason, Citadel’s Mazzella emphasised any backstop should come after all other market participants had taken some share of the losses.

“I do think we should have some skin in the game and that should come before any government backstop,” he said.

So CCP clearing with cash margin creates a form of moral hazard similar to that created by deposit insurance and implicit government guarantees in banking.

Mazilla’s suggestion that buy-side firms should accept haircuts to prevent a CCP failing, and that government bailout should be absolutely the last resort, is not unlike the EU’s European Bank Resolution Directive, which will formally endorse large depositor haircuts ahead of government bailout of banks. But this raises an interesting point.

Not all counterparties to OTC trades are too big to fail – indeed it is probably true to say that the majority are not. But CCPs are unquestionably too big to fail. In seeking to end “too big to fail” in OTC derivatives trading, we may actually have made the problem worse.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Nigerian opposition criticise government for currency devaluation
Abuja, Nov 27 (IANS) The All Progressives Congress(APC), Nigeria's main opposition party, Wednesday criticised the government for its move to devalue the country's currency naira.
 
 
Britain deploys military helicopters to aid for Ebola-hit Sierra Leone
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Britain has deployed Royal Navy helicopters to deliver materials to northern Sierra Leone as the part of its ongoing efforts to tackle Ebola, the British Department for International Development (DFID) said Wednesday.
 
 
Pakistan blocks three Saarc connectivity pacts; Modi, Sharif avoid meeting (Intro Roundup)
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Pakistan Wednesday played spoilsport by blocking three major Saarc connectivity projects initiated by India, even as Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi conspicuously avoided meeting his Pakistani counterpart Nawaz Sharif while he met five other South Asian leaders here.
 
 
Way out of debt crisis far from easy: Angela Merkel
Berlin, Nov 26 (IANS) German Chancellor Angela Merkel Wednesday said the way out of the European debt crisis is long and far from easy.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Nigerian opposition criticise government for currency devaluation
Abuja, Nov 27 (IANS) The All Progressives Congress(APC), Nigeria's main opposition party, Wednesday criticised the government for its move to devalue the country's currency naira. ]The party objected that the policy...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Nick Cannon and Mariah Carey to spend Christmas together
Nick Cannon and Mariah Carey will spend Christmas together. The couple, who married in 2008, announced their separation earlier this year, but Nick has confirmed that won't stop him spending the festive season with his...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Yasmany Tomas Agrees to 6-Year, $68.5M Deal With Arizona Diamondbacks
Yasmany Tomas has agreed to a mega-deal with the Arizona Diamondbacks.The Cuban outfielder came to terms with the D-backs on a six-year, $68.5 million contract, per MLB.com's Jesse Sanchez:"Cuban outfielder Yasmany...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Johnny Depp feels 'like a fugitive'
Johnny Depp lives ''like a fugitive''. The Hollywood icon is among the most photographed people in the world, but insists he craves a more quiet life. Johnny, 51, said: ''I'm f*****g shy man. ''I'm living, in a sense,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Scott Disick says he hasn't slept with Kourtney Kardashian 'in five years'
Scott Disick has claimed he and Kourtney Kardashian ''haven't slept together in five years''. The 31-year-old reality TV star made the strange statement during a new episode of 'Kourtney And Khloe Take The Hamptons',...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Kendra Wilkinson cries over Hank Baskett's 'severe depression'
Kendra Wilkinson was reduced to tears because of her husband Hank Baskett's ''severe depression''. The 29-year-old beauty, who married Hank in 2009 and has two children with the former American football star - Hank,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Jolie spotted smoking post fight with Pitt
Sydney, Nov 27 (IANS) Actress Angelina Jolie was spotted smoking a cigarette on a hotel balcony here reportedly after she and her husband Brad Pitt engaged in a heated argument. According to weekly magazine In Touch,...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Kate Moss plans Christmas 'glow'
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Supermodel Kate Moss is planning to spice up her look by adding more colourful metallics and shimmer to her beauty regime to give her skin a festive glow. The 40-year-old has decided to undergo...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Britain deploys military helicopters to aid for Ebola-hit Sierra Leone
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Britain has deployed Royal Navy helicopters to deliver materials to northern Sierra Leone as the part of its ongoing efforts to tackle Ebola, the British Department for International Development (...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Katie Holmes craves 'inspirational' romance
Katie Holmes can't imagine living in a world without romance. The 35-year-old actress - who was married to Hollywood superstar Tom Cruise from 2006 to 2012 - gave an interestingly cryptic answer when she was questioned...
Read more on Celebrity Balla