Did Obama's New FERC Nominee 'Criminalize' Energy Regulation?

May 6 2014, 6:07pm CDT | by

Later this month, the U.S. Senate will hold confirmation hearings on President Obama’s nominee, Norman Bay, for the head of the U.S. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.

The outcome of the confirmation hearing may matter far more than most people appreciate.

Before teaching criminal law at the University of New Mexico School of Law, Bay served as a federal prosecutor for more than a decade in the District of Columbia and New Mexico. Bay is a borne and bred “federal prosecutor.” By contrast, prior to joining FERC as the head of enforcement in 2009, Bay had virtually no experience in energy regulation or markets.

Bay’s prosecutorial instincts have shaped the core policies and procedures FERC has developed to implement the expanded enforcement authority Congress granted it in EPAct 2005 to address manipulative conduct and deceptive practices in the wholesale electricity and natural gas markets.

In particular, Bay has been instrumental in shifting FERC’s institutional practices away from more traditional energy regulation and toward a kind of shock-and-awe paradigm for policing markets.

During tenure at FERC, Bay has expanded the scope of his office’s powers to “prosecute” allegedly fraudulent activity by bureaucratic fiat with few if any meaningful mechanisms for ensuring public accountability.

In 2010, FERC adopted the so-called “Policy Statement on Penalty Guidelines” to calculate civil fines and assess penalties for fraud and market manipulation. The Penalty Guidelines were modeled on the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines, which establish the formulas for calculating fines and prison sentences for criminals convicted of a federal crime.

Congress enacted the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines during the Reagan administration to provide certainty, fairness, and transparency for criminal sentences. The objective was to avoid conflicting sentences for the same offense in different jurisdictions. One judge fines a driver $5 for driving five miles over the speed limit while another judge fines a driver charged with the same offense $2 million.

After FERC adopted the Guidelines, it received considerable pushback from the industry, which argued that the Sentencing Guidelines were not intended to apply to violations of regulatory regimes of the sort enforced by FERC.

Per FERC’s summary: “Specifically, these commenters suggest that modeling the Penalty Guidelines on a criminal framework is wrong because, unlike in the civil and regulatory context, criminal cases require the government to prove, and an independent jury or judge to find, a defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt before imposing penalties on organizations,” said the Edison Electric Institute in comments.

Like the Sentencing Guidelines, the Penalty Guidelines implicitly grant enormous discretion to the attorneys representing FERC’s office of enforcement. This is dangerous.

“It has been a virtual mantra for observers of federal sentencing . . . that the Guidelines produced a great ‘transfer of power’ to prosecutors,” Robert Weisberg, a professor of criminal law at Stanford Law School wrote in 2005.

Supreme Court Justice Robert Jackson explained the significance of granting prosecutors’ discretion to charge individuals with crimes given the number of laws on the books.

“If the prosecutor is obliged to choose his cases, it follows he can choose his defendants,” said Jackson. This results in “[t]he most dangerous power of the prosecutor: that he will pick people he thinks he should get, rather than pick cases that need to be prosecuted.”

A series of recent decisions by the U.S. Supreme Court has begun to reign in this prosecutorial discretion.

Notably, in 2006, Bay published a law review article arguing that these recent decisions would not appreciably curtail the prosecutorial discretion in federal courts.

“Power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely,” said Lord Acton. This is a basic idea behind the U.S. Constitution. So is due process./>/>

For better or worse, FERC‘s recent flurry of aggressive enforcement actions charging financial institutions with alleged fraud is symptomatic of the regulatory overreach that inevitably results when too much discretion is combined with too little accountability.

Exhibit A: the alleged fraudsters targeted in FERC’s most aggressive actions have uniformly refused to admit any actual wrongdoing.

FERC’s growing culpability gap has not been entirely overlooked by decision makers.

In July, Senators Elizabeth Warren and Edward Markey asked FERC’s Commissioner Jon Wellinghoff why JP Morgan was “permitted to avoid an admission of guilt . . . [as] a precondition for settlement?”

Rather than explaining why FERC didn’t demand an admission of wrongdoing from JP Morgan, Wellinghoff’s response merely begged the question, stating that, “in certain circumstances, it is appropriate to insist on an admission of liability.”

FERC’s recent enforcement actions are so cloaked in non-public proceedings that only bits and pieces of the evidence and supporting legal analysis are available.

There is the one exception to this general lack of transparency. Powhatan Energy has put ALL of its response to FERC’s allegations of market manipulation a part of the public record.

If Powhatan’s experience is any indication of FERC’s anti-manipulation enforcement policies, the political risks of participating in wholesale power markets are approaching Hugo Chavez-scale proportions.

But more about than later . . .

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Twitter to track apps on your smartphone
New York, Nov 27 (IANS) The micro-blogging site Twitter has launched a new move to track which apps are installed on your cellphone.
 
 
Copper essential for resting brain too
New York, Nov 27 (IANS) A new study has found that proper copper levels are essential to the health of the brain at rest.
 
 
Dogs clearly listen to what we say
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Dogs pay attention not only to who we are and how we say things, but also to what we say, shows a study.
 
 
Eye's 'glassy' proteins behind sight deterioration
London, Nov 27 (IANS) The age-related long-sightedness could be due to proteins in eye-lens that are converted from a fluid solution to a solid glassy state, making the lens more rigid, says a study.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Modi, Sharif shake hands, chat at reception
Kathmandu, Nov 27 (IANS) After a day when they apparently ignored each other in front of cameras, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Pakistani Premier Nawaz Sharif shook hands and met briefly during the retreat at...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Arsenal's target is to top Group D: Cazorla
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Arsenal mid-fielder Santi Cazorla said that after securing the last 16 spot in Champions League, the club's next target will be the top place of the group. The English club reached the knockout...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Five killed in Kabul suicide car bombing
Kabul, Nov 27 (IANS) At least five Afghan civilians were killed and 34 others wounded Thursday morning when a suicide car bombing targeted a British embassy armoured vehicle in eastern Kabul, sources said. The British...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Twitter to track apps on your smartphone
New York, Nov 27 (IANS) The micro-blogging site Twitter has launched a new move to track which apps are installed on your cellphone. "To help build a more personal Twitter experience for you, we are collecting and...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Galatasaray going through very difficult moment: Prandelli
Brussels, Nov 27 (IANS) Galatasaray coach Cesare Prandelli said that the club are going through "very difficult moment" following the 0-2 away defeat to RSC Anderlecht in the Champions League. "We will continue on our...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Pele remains in hospital in stable condition
Rio de Janeiro, Nov 27 (IANS) Brazil football legend Pele remains in hospital as he receives ongoing treatment for a urinary tract infection. The 74-year-old is being treated with intravenous antibiotics and is in a...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Simeone salutes his players for 4-0 win over Olympiakos
Madrid, Nov 27 (IANS) Atletico Madrid coach Diego Simeone praised his players after they defeated Olympiakos of Greece 4-0 in the Champions league at the Vicente Calderon Stadium here Wednesday. "We have produced some...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Basel made life difficult for us: Gareth Bale
Geneva, Nov 27 (IANS) Real Madrid winger Gareth Bale said Basel posed enough threats after Real won over the Swiss club 1-0 in the Champions League Wednesday night. "Basel are still battling to qualify, still fighting...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Tennis star Murray to marry
London, Nov 27 (IANS) Two-time Grand Slam champion Andy Murray is set to marry long-time girlfriend Kim Sears, Murray's management team has announced. Murray, 27, and Sears, 26, have been a couple since meeting at the...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Natalie Portman up for Jobs biopic
Natalie Portman is in talks for a role in the Steve Jobs biopic. The 'Black Swan' actress is negotiating a deal to play a ''major role'' in the movie about the Apple co-founder - who died from pancreatic cancer in 2011...
Read more on Movie Balla