Will Investors Regret Target's CEO Ouster? Compare to Sears, JCP

May 8 2014, 3:32pm CDT | by

There was much press this week about Target’s CEO and Chairman, Gregg Steinhafel, being forced outBlame reached the top job after the successful cyber attack on Target last year.  But null to a mounting global problem.

Cyber security is a problem for every company

Richard Clark is probably the USA’s foremost authority on cyber attacks.  He was on America’s National Security Council, and headed the counter-terrorism section.  Since leaving government he has increasingly focused on cyber attacks, and advised corporations.

In early 2013 I met Mr. Clark after hearing him speak at a National Association of Corporate Directors meeting.  He was surprisingly candid in his comments at the meeting, and after.  He pointed out that null .  He said it was impossible to do business without working on-line, and simultaneously it was impossible to think any company – of any size – could stop an attack from successfully getting into the company.  The only questions one should focus on answering were “How fast can you discover the attack?  How well can you contain it? What can you learn to at least stop that from happening again?”

Target was a crime victim, as can happen to any company

So, while the Target attack was large, and not discovered as early as anyone would like, to think that Target is in some way wildly poor at security or protecting its customers is simply naive.  Several other large retailers have also had attacks, include Nieman Marcus and Michael’s, and it was probably bad luck that Target was the first to have such a big problem happen, and at such a bad time, than anything particularly weak about Target.

We now know that all retailers are trying to learn from this, and every corporation is raising its awareness and actions to improve cyber security.  But some company will be next.  Target wasn’t the first, and won’t be the last.  Companies everywhere, working with law enforcement, are all reacting to this new form of crime.  So firing the CEO, 2 months after firing the CIO (Chief Information Officer), makes for good press, but it is more symbolic than meaningful.  It won’t stop the hackers.

Investors and customers have a lot to lose given Target’s competitive performance

Where this decision does have great importance is to shareholders and customers.  Target has been a decent company for its constituents under this CEO, and done far better than some of its competitors.  The share price has doubled in the last 5 years, and Target has proven a capable competitor to Wal-Mart while other retailers have been going out of business (Filene’s Basement, Circuit City, Linens & Things, Dots, etc.) or losing all relevancy (like Abercrombie and Fitch and Best Buy.)  And Target has been at least holding its own while some chains have been closing stores like crazy (Radio Shack 1,100 stores, Family Dollar 370 stores, Office Depot 400 stores, etc.)

Just compare Target’s performance to JCPenney, who’s CEO was fired after screwing up the business far worse than the cyber attack hurt Target.  And he was a former hero running Apple’s retail stores.

Or, look at Sears Holdings.  CEO Ed Lampert was heralded as a hero 6 years ago, but since then the company he leads has had 28 straight quarters of declining sales, and closed 305 stores since 2010.  The Kmart division has become a complete non-competitor in discounting, and Sears has lost all relevancy as a chain as it has been outflanked on all sides.  CEO Lampert has constantly whittled away at the company’s value, and just this week told shareholders that they can simply plan on more store closings in the future.

And vaunted Wal-Mart is undergoing a federal investigation for bribing government officials in Mexico to prop up its business. Wal-Mart is constantly under attack by its employees for shady business practices, and this year lost a National Labor Relations Board case regarding its hours and pay practices. And Wal-Mart remains a lightning rod for controversy as it fights with big cities like Chicago and Washington, DC about its ability to open stores, while Target has flourished in communities large and small with work practices considered acceptable.

Finding a good replacement for Steinhafel will not be easy

CEOs, and Boards of Directors, across the nation have been seriously addressing cyber security for the last couple of years.  Awareness, and protective measures, are up considerably.  But there will be future attacks, and some will succeed.  It is unclear blaming the CEO for these problems makes any sense – unless there is egregious incompetence.

Now, null .  Destroying KMart, while battling Wal-Mart, and still trying to figure out how to compete with Amazon.com is a remarkably difficult job.  Perhaps the toughest CEO job in the country.  Steinhafel had performed better than most.  Investors, and customers, may soon regret that he’s not still leading Target.

Connect with me on LinkedIn, Facebook  and Twitter/>/>

How Lampert killed Sears Holdings

Why it is better to own AMZN than SHLD or WMT

Why the bribery case is a wake up call for WMT investors

How Wal-Mart became easy prey for Target

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

US reporter requests privacy after release
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The US journalist, who was freed this week by the miltants in Syria after two years in captivity, Wednesday thanked everyone for their efforts to secure his release and asked for privacy to be with his family.
 
 
Congo confirms six Ebola cases
Brazzaville, Aug 28 (IANS) Six cases of the Ebola virus have been confirmed in Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Health Minister Felix Kabange Numbi said Wednesday.
 
 
IMF chief faces investigation in corruption case
Paris, Aug 27 (IANS/EFE) International Monetary Fund (IMF) chief Christine Lagarde has been put under investigation in France for "negligence" after being questioned for hours in a corruption case, judicial sources said Wednesday. She denied wrongdoing.
 
 
Whale tourism affecting marine animals' behaviour
London, Aug 27 (IANS) Boat trips to watch whales and dolphins may increasingly put the survival of marine mammals at risk, conservationists have warned.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Kidnapped US journalist's mother pleads IS to release son
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The mother of a US freelance journalist, who was kidnapped in Syria by the Islamic State(IS), Wednesday released a video in which she urged the jihadist group to "be merciful" and release...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Bieber compares himself to Princess Diana
Los Angeles, Aug 28 (IANS) Troubled singer Justin Bieber has compared himself to the late Princess Diana after he reportedly experienced a minor car collision when he was infuriated about being pursued by a...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Styles helping rising star Meghan Trainor?
London, Aug 28 (IANS) English singer Harry Styles has reportedly offered to help rising star Meghan Trainor as she attempts to break into the music industry. Styles met her in the US during One Direction's 'Where We...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Chris O'Dowd and Dawn O'Porter expecting first child
Chris O'Dowd and Dawn O'Porter are expecting their first child. The 'Bridesmaids' star, 34, debuted his wife's baby bump in a video clip of his ALS Ice Bucket Challenge on Wednesday (08.27.14). Upon completing the...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Maliki urges Iraqi political blocs to back Abadi
Baghdad, Aug 28 (IANS) Iraq's outgoing Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki called on the political blocs to decrease their demands and hepl form the government lead by Haider al-Abadi. "Some of the blocs' demands are...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
UN delivers food to Gaza via Egyptian crossing
United Nations, Aug 28 (IANS) For the first time in seven years, a humanitarian convoy of the United Nations World Food Programme (WFP) successfully crossed from Egypt into the Gaza Strip Wednesday, a spokesman said...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Most people take my clothes too seriously: Rick Owens
Los Angeles, Aug 28 (IANS) American fashion designer Rick Owens believes his fans takes his designs too seriously. The California-born designer, known for his statement drop-crotch shorts and leather jackets, believes...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
US reporter requests privacy after release
Washington, Aug 28 (IANS/EFE) The US journalist, who was freed this week by the miltants in Syria after two years in captivity, Wednesday thanked everyone for their efforts to secure his release and asked for privacy...
Read more on Ad Balla
 
Chris Martin writes love songs about Jennifer Lawrence
Chris Martin is ''sweeping'' Jennifer Lawrence ''off her feet.'' The Coldplay frontman, who split from Gwyneth Paltrow in March after 10 years of marriage, has reportedly been pulling out all the stops to romance 'The...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Neil Young will continue to support ailing son
Neil Young and Pegi Young will continue to co-parent their ailing adult son. The 68-year-old 'Heart of Gold' hitmaker, who filed for divorce from the 61-year-old singer last month after 36-years of marriage, stated in...
Read more on Celebrity Balla