Throwback Thursday: Forbes Discovered Alibaba When It Had Less Than $1 Million In Sales

May 8 2014, 6:02pm CDT | by

Back during the last dotcom bubble, my team created a magazine and Web site for Forbes called Best Of The Web. It focused mostly on demystifying the Internet and finding useful Web sites for our readers, but it also covered then sizzling hot world of B2B ecommerce. We wrote about many flame-outs, companies  like Ariba, Internet Capital Group and VerticalNet, but we also covered some big winners and to my knowledge we were the first to shed light on a fledgling web trading site called Alibaba. At the time the tiny company was mostly just a series of informational web pages with links connecting buyers and sellers who had to strike their deals either offline or via email.  Alibaba grossed less than$1 million when former Forbes writer Justin Doebele wrote the piece in July 2000. Its sales for the most recent nine months were reported to be $6.5 billion. Why did Alibaba flourish while once exciting B2B competitors like disappear? For the answer read Paul McWilliam’s story on why Alibaba’s Long Tail Makes Amazon’s Look Like A Bobcat’s. 

by Justin Doebele  (July 17, 2000)

We are in a dance hall of a lakeside resort a two-hour drive from Shanghai. It is 11: 00 p.m. The room, done in red velvet drapes and blinking disco lights, is packed with 120 men and women, mostly under 30, all employees of They’ve been waiting an hour to hear their leader, Jack Ma. Suddenly the room erupts in applause. A tiny figure with sunken cheekbones, tussled hair and a mischievous grin grabs the microphone. He’s five feet tall and weighs just over 100 pounds.

This imp of a man brought the commercial use of the Internet to China. Although is legally based in Hong Kong, its roots and most of its operations are in China, and Ma is a Mainland citizen. In March 1995, the same year that Jeff Bezos started, Ma registered China’s first Internet company:  Hangzhou Hope Networks Consulting. It offered to host Web pages for Chinese companies. Today Alibaba links together importers and exporters from around the world and grosses under $1 million a year.

For Ma that’s just a start. Now he has global ambitions. He aims at nothing less than Webifying the  $6.8 trillion worth of world trade (retail value). Click on to the site. It lets buyers and sellers find each other, matching, say, a supplier in Tibet with a buyer in Patagonia.

An American looking to buy 1,000 tennis rackets searches among dozens of potential suppliers and learns their terms of trade. Alibaba claims more than 200,000 registered members from 194 countries, though 70% are Chinese right now. You can buy fishmeal from Ghana or wiper blades from Italy; there are more than 700 different products broken down by category and country. The site is published in Chinese and English, and it recently launched a separate Korean version of Alibaba.

Listing is free, but you can’t actually make trades through the site. Alibaba helps you make a connection and deals are struck offline or via e-mail. Alibaba hopes to derive its revenue and ultimately its profits from add-on features. Shipping, trade financing, on-site inspections, quality control services and insurance are a few of the services that could earn money for the site. Ma also hopes to make money by offering a premium service to members and through advertising and promotions.

Except for some advertising, doesn’t yet offer any of these services, but Ma says he expects to have them on the site soon.

Alibaba already has satisfied customers. One is Robert Guo, of tiny textile and light industrial trading company Wuhu Wanlong Trading in Wuhu, China. “I have gotten three contracts worth  $100,000 over the past three months from the site. These are just the big buyers. We also have gotten many smaller deals off the site,” says Guo.

Nelson Dy of Van Gils Garments in the Philippines makes T shirts and other garments in Del Monte Quezon City. He gets an average of ten queries a day or more on Alibaba. “Two potential buyers [from] are coming soon to meet me in the Philippines,” says Dy.

“Alibaba has made a big step forward in how business is done in Asia,” says Hong Kong-based IDC Internet analyst Matthew McGarvey. “Sites like Alibaba are injecting transparency into the trading process.”

Elsewhere, however, it faces lots of competition. Ma isn’t the only one targeting this stupendous market. Some are trying to aggregate big buyers across industries, mostly in the U.S. and Europe, as Commerce One and Ariba are doing. Others are verticals for a single industry, such as E-Steel for the metals industry and Covisint for autos.

Alibaba has grander ambitions. Ma wants the site to be both global and horizontal across all products. But he may well have picked the best starting point:  Asia, by some estimates, is home to about 70% of all the world’s exporting companies. There are about 400,000 exporters in China alone and more on the way.

Not surprisingly, two of Ma’s three biggest rivals are Asian outfits, the Hong Kong-based Global Sources and the San Francisco-based Though MeetChina is based in the U.S., it is focused on building an electronic marketplace for Chinese exporters. China Resources, a public company backed by the Chinese government, holds a minority stake in the Web site. says it plans to compete more directly with by expanding to other Asian markets within a year. “We want to make buying 1,000 bicycles from China as easy as buying a book from,” says American Thomas Rosenthal, cofounder of the site.

The third rival, Boston, Mass.-based Industry to Industry, Inc., is backed by a private investment arm of a foundation headed by Klaus Schwab, the founder of the World Economic Forum. It started in late 1998 and has focused on four industries:  chemical, energy, retail goods, and engineering and construction./>/>

Ma compares’s free-for-all approach to a Middle Eastern bazaar, where anyone can lay out their wares and haggle with potential buyers.’s rivals claim this difference is a disadvantage since, like a Mideast bazaar, Ma doesn’t do any screening of either his buyers or sellers. Though also has a free-for-all approach, all three rival sites offer some kind of screening of its member companies.

Ma shrugs. “Let the others go after the whales,” says Ma. “We want to catch the shrimp.” Since most of’s staff are Chinese and living in China, Ma’s personnel and operating costs are relatively low. His biggest office space, in Hangzhou, is 200,000 square feet in size and rents for just  $80,000 a year. A Chinese computer engineer with three years of experience can be hired for just $18,000 a year, versus $100,000 in Silicon Valley.

Though the business is chiefly in China, most of Ma’s backing is international. His first round of  $5 million in funding came from Goldman Sachs, Fidelity Investments, Sweden’s Investor AB, Singapore’s TDF fund and Hong Kong’s Transpac. His second round of financing, at $20 million, came in January 2000 from a group of investors lead by Japan’s Softbank. “This company has the potential to be big, as big as Yahoo,” says chief technology officer John Wu. He should know. Before joining Alibaba in May, Wu was the chief architect of Yahoo’s widely used search engine.

Certainly the potential market is enormous. FORBES figures that about $470 billion a year is spent just servicing world trade–phone bills, invoicing, sales calls, overseas travel. If Web sites like Alibaba can cut that bill by even 20% –and that may be conservative–there is a potential savings pool of nearly  $100 billion from which it can draw revenues as profits.

Say this for Ma:  He understands his business is one where the future is seemingly unlimited, but the present is a period of red ink and teeming competition. “One must run as fast as a rabbit,” he says, “but be as patient as a turtle.”


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Europe's Galileo satellites launched into wrong orbit
Paris, Aug 23 (IANS) European satellite launch company Arianespace announced Saturday that the two satellites of Europe's Galileo satellite navigation system launched Friday from the European spaceport in French Guiana were delivered into the wrong orbit.
UN to radically scale up fight against Ebola
Monrovia, Aug 23 (IANS/WAM) The UN has vowed to radically scale up support to fight the Ebola virus outbreak in West Africa and said more health workers will be brought to Liberia to deal with the disease.
White dwarf stars formed mysterious supernova
London, Aug 23 (IANS) Supernova 2014J is 11 million light years away from earth and was only seen by chance at the University of London Observatory this year.
Universe's earliest stars were monstrous: Study
Tokyo, Aug 23 (IANS) Little is known about the universe's earliest stars but if we believe astronomers, they might have been hundreds of times more massive than the sun.

Latest from the Network

Force India struggle in wet Belgian GP qualifying
Spa-Francorchamps (Belgium), Aug 23 (IANS) Force India drivers Sergio Perez and Nico Hulkenberg had a difficult outing in the Belgian Grand Prix qualifying Saturday and will start Sunday's race 13th and 18th....
Read more on Sport Balla
Simon Pegg finds watching himself hard
Simon Pegg sometimes finds it ''hard'' to watch his own movies. The 44-year-old actor - who has five-year-old daughter Matilda with wife Maureen - is very ''proud'' of his work but doesn't enjoying viewing them back as...
Read more on Movie Balla
Indian cueists bag Asian title
Karachi, Aug 23 (IANS) India A, consisting of Kamal Chawla, Faisal Khan and Dharmender Lilly, won the Gold medal in the Asian Snooker Team championship here Saturday, defeating Pakistan A 3-1 in the final. The Indian...
Read more on Sport Balla
Sri Lanka, Pakistan 2nd ODI shifted to Hambantota
Colombo, Aug 23 (IANS) The second One-Day International (ODI) between Sri Lanka and Pakistan was Saturday moved up to Aug 26 and the venue shifted to Hambantota after heavy rainfall here left the Premadasa Stadium...
Read more on Sport Balla
Stacy Keibler gives birth to daughter
Los Angeles, Aug 23 (IANS) Former wrestler-turned-actress Stacy Keibler has welcomed a girl child. The 34-year-old and her husband, Jared Pobre, welcomed their daughter, Ava Grace Pobre, into the world Wednesday, she...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Britain mulls steps to combat extremism
London, Aug 23 (IANS) To discourage extremist elements originating from Britain, Home Secretary Theresa May has plans to bring in new laws that may strip Britons fighting in Syria and Iraq of their citizenship. May is...
Read more on Politics Balla
Europe's Galileo satellites launched into wrong orbit
Paris, Aug 23 (IANS) European satellite launch company Arianespace announced Saturday that the two satellites of Europe's Galileo satellite navigation system launched Friday from the European spaceport in French Guiana...
Read more on Apple Balla
Indian man commits suicide in UAE
Dubai, Aug 23 (IANS) A 24-year-old Indian man was found dead Saturday at his home in the United Arab Emirates (UAE), a media report said. The man, identified by his initials R.M., committed suicide by hanging himself...
Read more on Politics Balla
Boy killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza
Gaza, Aug 23 (IANS) An eight-year-old boy was killed and three others wounded in a fresh Israeli airstrike Saturday afternoon on a house in the central Gaza Strip, medics said. Ashraf al-Qedra, the health ministry...
Read more on Politics Balla
Toll in Japan mudslides hits 49
Tokyo, Aug 23 (IANS) The toll in deadly landslides in the Japanese city of Hiroshima rose to 49 Saturday, while 41 people remained missing. About 2,800 rescuers continued their efforts in searching for survivors three...
Read more on Politics Balla