The Problem With Outcome-Based Jurisprudence

May 9 2014, 2:08pm CDT | by

State court systems are created by state governments to enforce state law. It’s a relatively simple concept. Like the federal court system, state judicial branches are separate entities from the executive and legislative branches. Judges are charged with the difficult task of interpreting and implementing state laws and state constitutions and resolving disputes. Under the doctrine of the separation of powers, however, the judiciary does not make the law and it does not enforce the law.

Yet in practice, and particularly for cases in which revenue is involved, judges may feel tempted to take on the concerns of the executive and legislative branches and engage in outcome-based jurisprudence. This happens when a court decides what the outcome of the case should be and then works backward to determine the reasoning that will reach the desired conclusion.

Take, for example, a recent case from the Oklahoma Supreme Court. The case, CDR Systems Corp. v. Oklahoma Tax Commission, addressed a statutory capital gains deduction for taxpayers headquartered in Oklahoma. The statute was challenged by a company headquartered in Florida because it did not provide the same deduction for taxpayers headquartered outside Oklahoma. The company alleged the statute was unconstitutional because it taxes companies differently based on whether they are headquartered in Oklahoma.

Although an Oklahoma appeals court determined the statute was facially discriminatory in violation of the commerce clause, the Oklahoma Supreme Court, in what can only be described as a case of outcome-based jurisprudence, concluded the commerce clause did not apply. What’s troubling, though, is that the disparate treatment of in-state versus out-of-state taxpayers is exactly the type of situation in which the commerce clause should apply.

The opinion from Oklahoma’s highest court is questionable at best. The court went so far as to suggest the statute should be held constitutional because the “Legislature could have imposed a more burdensome means of promoting significant business investment in Oklahoma’s economy.” In other words, the Legislature could have created a more unconstitutional statute, so let’s just leave the current statute alone.

The real question, though, is why? Why did the court go out of its way to dismiss existing commerce clause precedent and produce an opinion that is rife with illogical conclusions?

The answer is likely in the remedy that would have been provided if the taxpayer had prevailed. Oklahoma Tax Commission spokeswoman Paula Ross reportedly conceded that if the statute were struck down, the state would have been liable for up to $400 million in refunds. Practitioners in the state aren’t surprised. Some suspected the court would find a way to protect the treasury while also protecting in-state businesses.

The CRD Systems opinion may have accomplished the goal of protecting the treasury, but its success ends there. Outcome-based opinions should be avoided. It is not for the court to worry about how the state will fashion a remedy. Its task is to interpret and enforce the state’s laws and strike down those that are unconstitutional. In that respect, the court in Oklahoma failed.


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Amazon Black Friday 2015 Sale is Live: The Best Deals
Amazon Black Friday 2015 Sale is Live: The Best Deals
The Black Friday 2015 sale on Amazon is an 8 Day event.
Amazon Black Friday 2015 Deals Unveiled
Amazon Black Friday 2015 Deals Unveiled
The Black Friday 2015 Deals offered in the Amazon Black Friday 2015 Sale are here.
Sam&#039;s Club Holiday Savings Celebration Sale 2015 Kicked Off Online
Sam's Club Holiday Savings Celebration Sale 2015 Kicked Off Online
The Sam's Club sale on Saturday November 14 is the first big Black Friday 2015 sale of the year and the Black Friday deals are online now ahead of the stores opening.
Find Hot Black Friday 2015 Deals
Find Hot Black Friday 2015 Deals
The Black Friday 2015 Ads are rolling advertising the Black Friday 2015 deals.