360° Coverage : The Problem With Outcome-Based Jurisprudence

2 Updates

The Problem With Outcome-Based Jurisprudence

May 9 2014, 2:08pm CDT | by

State court systems are created by state governments to enforce state law. It’s a relatively simple concept. Like the federal court system, state judicial branches are separate entities from the...

Filed under: news

 
 
 

16 weeks ago

The Problem With Outcome-Based Jurisprudence

May 9 2014, 2:08pm CDT | by

State court systems are created by state governments to enforce state law. It’s a relatively simple concept. Like the federal court system, state judicial branches are separate entities from the executive and legislative branches. Judges are charged with the difficult task of interpreting and implementing state laws and state constitutions and resolving disputes. Under the doctrine of the separation of powers, however, the judiciary does not make the law and it does not enforce the law.

Yet in practice, and particularly for cases in which revenue is involved, judges may feel tempted to take on the concerns of the executive and legislative branches and engage in outcome-based jurisprudence. This happens when a court decides what the outcome of the case should be and then works backward to determine the reasoning that will reach the desired conclusion.

Take, for example, a recent case from the Oklahoma Supreme Court. The case, CDR Systems Corp. v. Oklahoma Tax Commission, addressed a statutory capital gains deduction for taxpayers headquartered in Oklahoma. The statute was challenged by a company headquartered in Florida because it did not provide the same deduction for taxpayers headquartered outside Oklahoma. The company alleged the statute was unconstitutional because it taxes companies differently based on whether they are headquartered in Oklahoma.

Although an Oklahoma appeals court determined the statute was facially discriminatory in violation of the commerce clause, the Oklahoma Supreme Court, in what can only be described as a case of outcome-based jurisprudence, concluded the commerce clause did not apply. What’s troubling, though, is that the disparate treatment of in-state versus out-of-state taxpayers is exactly the type of situation in which the commerce clause should apply.

The opinion from Oklahoma’s highest court is questionable at best. The court went so far as to suggest the statute should be held constitutional because the “Legislature could have imposed a more burdensome means of promoting significant business investment in Oklahoma’s economy.” In other words, the Legislature could have created a more unconstitutional statute, so let’s just leave the current statute alone.

The real question, though, is why? Why did the court go out of its way to dismiss existing commerce clause precedent and produce an opinion that is rife with illogical conclusions?

The answer is likely in the remedy that would have been provided if the taxpayer had prevailed. Oklahoma Tax Commission spokeswoman Paula Ross reportedly conceded that if the statute were struck down, the state would have been liable for up to $400 million in refunds. Practitioners in the state aren’t surprised. Some suspected the court would find a way to protect the treasury while also protecting in-state businesses.

The CRD Systems opinion may have accomplished the goal of protecting the treasury, but its success ends there. Outcome-based opinions should be avoided. It is not for the court to worry about how the state will fashion a remedy. Its task is to interpret and enforce the state’s laws and strike down those that are unconstitutional. In that respect, the court in Oklahoma failed.

 
Update
2

3 days ago

Khazanah throws MAS RM6b lifeline

Aug 29 2014 5:01pm CDT | Source: Business Times Singapore

August 30, 2014 1:15 AMKHAZANAH Nasional will inject RM6 billion (SS$2.4 billion) over three years to resuscitate loss-making Malaysia Airlines (MAS) under a recovery plan that includes even an Act of Parliament. Other key moves are migrating its operations, assets and liabilities to a new company (NewCo) and slashing the workforce ...
Source: Business Times Singapore   Full article at: Business Times Singapore
 

 
Update
1

4 days ago

MAS posts loss of RM307m for Q2

Aug 28 2014 5:00pm CDT | Source: Business Times Singapore

August 29, 2014 1:13 AMMALAYSIA Airlines (MAS) registered a loss of RM307 million (S$122 million) for the second quarter to end-June, but warned of worse to come in the second half when the "full financial impact of the double tragedies of MH370 and MH17" hits ...
Source: Business Times Singapore   Full article at: Business Times Singapore
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

IS video shows beheading of second US journalist
Washington, Sep 2 (IANS) Days after the beheading of American photojournalist James Foley, Sunni militant group Islamic State (IS) has posted a video showing the beheading of another kidnapped American journalist Steven Sotloff, CNN reported.
 
 
IS beheads second US journalist
Washington, Sep 2 (IANS) The Islamic State militant organisation has posted a video titled "A second message to America", showing the beheading of American journalist Steven Sotloff, CNN reported.
 
 
India offers red carpet, not red tape, Modi hard sells India (Roundup)
Tokyo, Sep 2 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Tuesday hard sold India to Japanese investors saying that his country offers only a red carpet and not red tape while dubbing his five-day trip to Japan that ends Wednesday as "very successful".
 
 
Fear grips onlookers as Ebola victim walks through market
Monrovia, Sep 2 (IANS) A video footage has emerged from Liberia showing a person tagged positive for Ebola virus disease (EVD) walking through a busy market, sending hundreds of horrified onlookers fleeing in fear, a media report said Tuesday.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

11 killed in Pakistan building collapse
Islamabad, Sep 2 (IANS) At least 11 people, including women and children, were killed Tuesday when a roof of an old building collapsed in Pakistan, a media report said. As many as 18 people were wounded when a two-...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Imran refuses to budge as parliament supports Pakistan PM (Roundup)
Islamabad, Sep 2 (IANS) Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) chairman Imran Khan refused to budge on his demand for Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif's resignation Tuesday as a joint session of parliament came out overwhelmingly...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
IS video shows beheading of second US journalist
Washington, Sep 2 (IANS) Days after the beheading of American photojournalist James Foley, Sunni militant group Islamic State (IS) has posted a video showing the beheading of another kidnapped American journalist...
Read more on Ad Balla
 
Modi cites people's efforts for India-Japan strategic ties
Tokyo, Sep 2 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Tuesday said India and Japan were now working as "special strategic and global" partners and this was the result of efforts of not just the two governments but because...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
IS beheads second US journalist
Washington, Sep 2 (IANS) The Islamic State militant organisation has posted a video titled "A second message to America", showing the beheading of American journalist Steven Sotloff, CNN reported. The video also...
Read more on Ad Balla
 
Rahane shines as India seal series in Edgbaston
Birmingham, Sep 2 (IANS) Ajinkya Rahane's maiden century and his century-run stand with Shikhar Dhawan powered India to a comprehensive nine-wicket win over England in the fourth ODI here Tuesday and also sealed the...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
India vs England: Scoreboard, fourth ODI
Birmingham, Sep 2 (IANS) The following is the final scoreboard of the fourth ODI between India and England at Edgbaston here Tuesday. England Alastair Cook c Raina b Kumar 9 Alex Hales b Kumar 6 Gary Ballance c Rahane...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Britain asks citizens to review travel plans to Pakistan
Islamabad, Sep 2 (IANS) The British Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO) has advised its citizens to review their planned trips to Pakistan in view of the volatile security situation in the country. "There is a high...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Jaime King: Motherhood is all that matters
Jaime King says her son is the most important thing in her life now. The 'Sin City: A Dame to Kill For' star welcomed her first child James - her son with husband Kyle Newman - into the world last October and since she...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Chris Brown pleads guilty to assault
Chris Brown has pleaded guilty to assault. The 'Beautiful People' hitmaker was sentenced to time already served by a judge after accepting a plea deal at a Washington DC superior court today (02.09.14), where he was...
Read more on Celebrity Balla