Prosecutor: Beanie Babies Billionaire Tax Cheat Didn't Deserve `Get-Out-Of-Jail' Card

May 9 2014, 10:36pm CDT | by

Federal prosecutors argued in a court filing today that the no-jail sentence given to  billionaire tax-cheat H. Ty Warner was “substantively unreasonable,’’ in part because the sentencing judge was unduly impressed by his “not so extraordinary” charity and by 70 letters attesting to his generosity written primarily by employees, business associates and those he had donated to after learning the government was investigating him.

Last September, in a deal with the U.S. Attorney for Northern Illinois, Beanie Babies inventor Warner pleaded guilty  to one felony count of tax evasion and agreed to pay a $53 million fine for hiding as much as $106 million in secret Swiss accounts and evading at least $5.5 million in tax on the accounts’ earnings over 12 years. According to the U.S. Sentencing Commission Guidelines, which ratchet up sentences with the dollar value of a white collar crime, the 69-year-old Warner should have been sentenced to between 46 and 57 months of jail time.

But in January, Chicago Federal District Court Judge Charles F. Kocoras let him off  with probation and community service,  after reading aloud from nine letters and declaring:  “Mr. Warner’s private acts of kindness, generosity and benevolence are overwhelming. Never have I had a defendant in any case —white collar crime or otherwise—demonstrate the level of humanity and concern for the welfare of others as has Mr. Warner.’’  Warner’s charity, the judge added,  “Trumps all of the ill-will and  misconduct he engaged in.”

The downward departure from guidelines in Warner’s case was particularly dramatic and the U.S. Attorney for Northern Illinois, who had asked Kocoras to give Warner jail time, is now appealing  the sentence to the 7th Circuit Court of appeals.  The rare appeal, which had to be approved by the U.S. Solicitor General, is hardly a slam dunk; the government hasn’t  won an appeal of a below-guidelines sentence for a tax crime since the Supreme Court ruled that the guidelines are not binding on sentencing judges.

In their opening appeals brief filed late Friday, prosecutors painted Warner as distinctly ungenerous when compared with either ordinary Americans or with the billionaires who have pledged to give at least half their net worth to charity. (Since Warren Buffett and Melinda and Bill Gates started The Giving Pledge  four years ago, 127 of the 1,650 or so billionaires that have been confirmed by Forbes, have signed the pledge, with a new crop, including Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg, announced just this morning.)

At his sentencing, Warner’s net worth was pegged at $1.8 billion and his lawyers said he had donated $140 million to charity over the past decade. But prosecutors argued before the sentencing and again in their appeals brief, that that number was inflated because it reflected the retail value of the Beanie Babies Warner had donated and not his cost for producing the stuffed animals. They pegged the value of Warner’s contributions from 1998 to 2011 at just $35.7 million. Moreover, prosecutors pointed out, many of the donated toys “helped spur a Beanie Babies craze,’’  including, for example, a Beanie created for the benefit of the memorial fund for Princess Diana. Warner’s cash donations for an aquarium and bike path in Santa Barbara, Cal., they added, helped attract tourists to the nearby Four Seasons Resort he owned.

That $35.7 million Warner gave over 14 years, prosecutors calculated, amounted to  just 2% of his net worth at sentencing.  Translating that to common man equivalence, prosecutors noted that the median net worth of households in the U.S. in 2011 was  $68,828 and  that 2% of that is $1,377,  which would amount to  $100 a year of donations over 14 years.

“Warner is no `Robin hood.’ His past charitable contributions were not so  extraordinary, in light of his wealth, that they qualified as a `get-out-of-jail-card,’’’ the prosecutors wrote.

The prosecutors also pointed out, as they have before, that Warner has never said where the money he deposited in UBS AG in Switzerland in 1996 came from.  “The books and records of defendant’s company show the funds were not transferred from the company, nor did they come from defendant’s personal domestic bank accounts,’’ they wrote, raising the possibility that the money he stashed in UBS was  income he skimmed from his business and never reported to the IRS.  If that is the case, then Warner evaded a lot more than $5.5 million in tax.  (In 1999 alone, Warner, as the sole owner of Ty Inc., had an adjusted gross income of  $662 million.)

Before sentencing, Warner’s lawyers made much of the fact that he had tried to “rectify his mistake” by applying to the Internal Revenue Service’s Offshore Voluntary Disclosure Program in September 2009. More than 40,000 individuals with previously secret offshore accounts have entered that program, which gives miscreants  amnesty from criminal prosecution if they tell all and pay stiff penalties and back taxes. Warner was turned down for the program, however, because the government was already investigating him, making him ineligible.

In their brief, prosecutors noted for the first time that, as Forbes first reported in February, Warner resisted complying with a federal grand jury subpoena for his foreign bank records. (He turned over the records after an appeals court ordered him to, but nevertheless appealed anonymously to the Supreme Court, which declined to hear his case.)

Billionaires Who Spent Time Behind Bars


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

SJVNL signs pact with Nepal for hydro-power plant
Kathmandu, Nov 27 (IANS) Indian public sector company Satluj Jal Vidyut Nigam Ltd. (SJVNL) has signed a project development agreement with the Nepal government for executing the 900 MW Arun-III Hydro Electric Project in eastern Nepal, officials said Thursday.
'I saw humans on Mars in 1979': Ex-NASA employee
New York, Nov 27 (IANS) A woman claiming to be a former NASA employee has stated that while watching some footage, she saw two humans walking on the Red Planet towards the Viking Mars lander in 1979.
Mammoth cloning reality soon?
New York, Nov 27 (IANS) With the discovery of the best-preserved specimen of a mammoth found so far, cloning of the woolly animal is closer to becoming a reality, scientists report.
Saarc energy accord signed
Kathmandu, Nov 27 (IANS) The foreign ministers of Saarc member states have signed the Saarc Framework Agreement for Energy Cooperation (Electricity).

Latest from the Network

Modi, Sharif bonhomie gives fresh boost to Saarc (Roundup)
Kathmandu, Nov 27 (IANS) In a final ice-breaking moment, that gave a huge boost to Saarc and floundering regional cooperation, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi shook hands with his Pakistani counterpart Nawaz Sharif...
Read more on Politics Balla
Now, flying robots to serve as waiters in Singapore
Singapore, Nov 27 (IANS) If you are planning to visit Singapore next year, don't be surprised if you were greeted and served a sumptuous meal by flying robots as waiters in some restaurants. Infinium-Serve, the...
Read more on Politics Balla
Four Afghans, one Briton killed in Kabul suicide attack
Kabul, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) A British national and four Afghans were killed Thursday in a suicide attack on a British embassy vehicle in Kabul which left 34 others injured, officials said. The attack occurred at 10.30 a....
Read more on Politics Balla
Badminton to continue testing of five-game scoring system
Kuala Lumpur, Nov 27 (IANS) The Badminton World Federation (BWF) Thursday decided to continue with the testing variations of the best of five games. "Following the recent BWF Council meeting in Lima, Peru, members...
Read more on Sport Balla
Two arrested in France for jihadi propaganda
Paris, Nov 27 (IANS) French police arrested a couple in Ain, central east France on charges of belonging to an alleged jihadi propaganda network, media reported on Thursday. A French man in his thirties, who converted...
Read more on Politics Balla
Japanese court rejects lawsuit against reopening two n-plants
Tokyo, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) A Japanese court Thursday rejected a class action lawsuit filed by residents of the western prefecture of Shiga against reactivating offline nuclear power plants in Takahama and Oi. The ruling...
Read more on Politics Balla
SJVNL signs pact with Nepal for hydro-power plant
Kathmandu, Nov 27 (IANS) Indian public sector company Satluj Jal Vidyut Nigam Ltd. (SJVNL) has signed a project development agreement with the Nepal government for executing the 900 MW Arun-III Hydro Electric Project...
Read more on Business Balla
13 civilians killed by Ukrainian forces: Separatists
Moscow, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) At least 13 civilians were killed in recent shelling by Ukrainian artillery in the eastern city of Donetsk controlled by pro-Russian separatists, the rebel command announced Thursday. A...
Read more on Politics Balla
Zambian police gear up for presidential election
Lusaka, Nov 27 (IANS) Police in Zambia have stepped up measures to ensure peace ahead of a presidential election scheduled for Jan 20, a top official said Thursday. Stella Libongani, the inspector general of Zambia...
Read more on Politics Balla
Hong Kong students threaten to occupy government buildings
Hong Kong, Nov 27 (IANS/EFE) Students participating in the pro-democracy demonstrations in Hong Kong threatened Thursday to attack government buildings following a night of clashes that occurred just hours after the...
Read more on Politics Balla