Obama's First Privacy Chief Backs NSA's Right To Spy - With Reform

May 14 2014, 12:53pm CDT | by

“We are spying in a transparent world.”

So claimed Timothy Edgar, President Obama’s first-ever director of privacy and civil liberties for the White House National Security Staff, at Britain’s Parliament today. Even with the emergence of new proposed limitations on the NSA’s unprecedented data collection, the crux was that nation-states engagement in broad-based surveillance is now an intrinsic component to realpolitik, in a digital planet running on big data.

Joined by Privacy International’s director Gus Hosein, and British MPs Julian Huppert, David Davis and Chi Onwurah, and hosted by Big Brother Watch, Edgar detailed the rise and rise of the secret surveillance state and its murky legal basis beginning with the Bush administration’s introduction of and exploitation of the Patriot Act to its continued use under the Obama administration. Edgar insisted in his address that now more than ever rules and reform are necessary in securing protections for American citizens and people all over the world.

Outlining his vision in line with a Guardian Op-Ed piece earlier this year, Edgar asserted that if America is to be at ease with its allies and act diplomatically first instead of using coercion, the civil liberties and private affairs of foreign citizens must be taken into account as well as those of Americans. This notion is beginning to take root within the intelligence community, which, he says, is a leap in thinking.

Despite the tough talk on balancing security and liberty, there was the sense of a whitewash. It’s hard to swallow the idea that more oversight alone will go a long way towards solving problems in a country unique in the extent of its oversight, as Edgar emphasized. Even if the NSA was subject to legal restrictions, the scale of state spying was unconfirmed until the actions of whistleblower Edward Snowden.

The collection of vast amounts of metadata was left essentially untouched in Obama’s proposed directive in January this year, and so the problem here is that applying these limitations presumes a legitimacy of the NSA’s methods.

In Edgar’s eyes, intelligence services have a mission that’s “broader than counter-intelligence,” and he believes that this is “appropriate.”

“That doesn’t mean that collection initiatives can’t be more limited than they are for counter terrorism,” he said. “We could distinguish between the reasons we need intelligence collection, and have stricter rules for a broader collection than we do for genuine security threats. But I think it would be naive to assume we are going to limit intelligence collection to only international security threats.”

Can even the smallest victories in reform be effective, so long as agencies operating in the dark are prepared to maneuver through legal loopholes to get what they want? The wheels may be in motion for a light touch of legislation, but what’s being proposed is not much more than damage control. Edgar was asked about the potential for stricter legislation but his answer was a quasi-vigilant wait-and-see.

“I don’t think we know yet,” Edgar said. “They haven’t actually implemented the entire directive. The Director of National Intelligence is putting together proposed limits, and the General Counsel is meeting with human rights groups next week I don’t think the world should trust the American government simply because Obama made a speech. Obama’s good at making speeches – the question is whether there are limits that result in effective reforms.”

“If, in 5 or 10 years, we have scandals about why the NSA broke the rules that protect the privacy rights of foreigners, that’s going to mean that the rules are taken seriously, that’s going to mean there’s an oversight system that’s catching potential violations of those rules.  But if in 10 years nobody remembers there was supposedly a directive in January 2014 to put some reforms in place, then you should probably be suspicious that nothing really has changed,” he said.

Privacy International’s Gus Hosein aired his own ominous predictions on the short and long-term potential effects if the Five Eyes nations, the USA, Great Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, carry on as they are.

“There are dark implications of our actions,” Hosein explained. “Governments around the world are rubbing their hands with glee because this government paved the way for mass surveillance, and they are thinking we can do the same.

“The French are giggling, let alone every country in Africa, in Asia, in Latin America, who is buying British technology that does exactly the same thing.

“Not only are we inspiring, but we are providing the technologies to enable what this [Britain's] government is doing, what the US is doing. At least the US is being held to account to some extent. A lot more work needs to be done here, because if we don’t do it, it’s going to be disastrous.”

Perhaps what’s worth highlighting is that this conversation would not have seen the light of day without Snowden – who himself claimed to have exhausted all of the official channels for oversight before going public. And that suggests an altogether more radical approach may be required than slightly more oversight, even if the latter is a small step in the right direction.


Don't miss ...


<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.


blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Facebook launches new chatting application
Madrid, Nov 25 (IANS/EFE) Facebook launched Tuesday a new chatting application worldwide called "Rooms" which simulates traditional internet chatting rooms, enabling users to chat with strangers on specific topics.
Mali confirms two new Ebola cases
Bamako, Nov 25 (IANS) Mali has confirmed two new Ebola cases after the death of five people due to the virus, the country's public health ministry has said.
Toddlers remember good times for life
New York, Nov 25 (IANS) According to researchers from the Utah-based Brigham Young University, babies are more likely to remember an incident if there is a positive emotion or affect that accompanies it.
Garlic, broccoli may speed up cancer recovery
London, Nov 25 (IANS) Researchers from the University of Copenhagen have found that selenium - naturally found in garlic and broccoli - slows down immune over-response, improving treatment against cancers such as melanoma and prostate cancer.

Latest from the Network

Over a dozen killed in Nigeria twin bombings
Abuja, Nov 25 (IANS) Two blasts Tuesday rocked a busy market in Maiduguri, capital of Nigeria's northeastern state of Borno and epicentre of Boko Haram's violence in the West African country, killing more than a dozen...
Read more on Politics Balla
Ready for talks but ball in India's court: Sharif
Kathmandu, Nov 25 (IANS) Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif Tuesday said Islamabad is ready to hold talks with India but "the ball is now in India's court", the Geo News reported. Speaking in the Nepal's capital...
Read more on Politics Balla
Hope Saarc helps reduce tensions with India: Pakistan minister
Islamabad, Nov 25 (IANS) Pakistan hopes that Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif's participation in the Saarc Summit in Nepal will help reduce Islamabad-New Delhi tensions given that US policies in the region have failed,...
Read more on Politics Balla
Modi hands over Dhruv chopper to Nepal
Kathmandu, Nov 25 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Tuesday handed over the indigenous Advance Light Helicopter (ALH) Dhruv to his Nepalese counterpart Sushil Koirala here for use by the Nepal Army. Built by the...
Read more on Politics Balla
Vanessa Hudgens gets restraining order against stalker
Los Angeles, Nov 25 (IANS) Actress Vanessa Hudgens has got a restraining order against her alleged stalker Junior Kabongo. Hudgens went to court after Kabongo came here from Africa to meet her after sending her a...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
Modi flags off Kathmandu-Delhi bus service
Kathmandu, Nov 25 (IANS) Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi Tuesday flagged off a Kathmandu-Delhi bus service here. A bus bound for Kathmandu took off from the Indian capital at the same time. Modi, here to attend...
Read more on Politics Balla
Pune FC maintain hot form in King's Cup
Thimpu, Nov 25 (IANS) Pune FC finished their King's Cup group engagements in style, winning 2-0 against Bangladesh's Abahani Limited at the Changlimithang Stadium here Tuesday, to collect a maximum 12 points from four...
Read more on Sport Balla
Frame constitution early, with consensus: Modi urges Nepal
Kathmandu, Nov 25 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Tuesday urged Nepal to frame its much-awaited constitution early and on the basis of consensus. Addressing an event here to hand over to Nepal a 200-bed trauma...
Read more on Politics Balla
Saudi Arabia to issue five-year residency permits
Dubai, Nov 25 (IANS) The validity of residency permits of foreign workers in Saudi Arabia is likely to be extended to five years, a media report said Tuesday. The directorate general of passports is giving final...
Read more on Politics Balla
FC Goa aim to maintain momentum in ISL
Margao, Nov 25 (IANS) Hosts FC Goa will aim to maintain their upward swing and jump to the third spot when they take on Kerala Blasters FC in an 11th round match of the Indian Super League (ISL) at the Jawaharlal Nehru...
Read more on Sport Balla