360° Coverage : Cellphone operator wades into surveillance debate

Cellphone operator wades into surveillance debate

Jun 7 2014, 2:54am CDT | by

NEW YORK (AP) — Wireless carrier Vodafone Group PLC is performing a tricky balancing maneuver by publishing a report on government surveillance of its subscribers in 29 countries — a release that reveals more than first meets the eye.

In the report published Friday, Vodafone, which has unparalleled global reach for a cellphone company, said six countries have demanded direct access to its network. That cuts Vodafone's employees out of the surveillance process, removing one of the hurdles that can curb government overreach.

Vodafone would not say which countries have established these direct links. But in an exhaustively researched appendix to the report, the U.K.-based company sheds light on the legal frameworks that surround government interception in the 29 countries. The appendix reveals that six countries — Albania, Egypt, Hungary, Ireland, Qatar and Turkey — have provisions that allow authorities to request unfettered access.

In two other countries, India and the U.K., legal provisions are unclear as to whether government officials are allowed to have direct access, according to the report.

The report is remarkable not so much for what it reveals about the extent of law enforcement and intelligence agency surveillance, but for the comparisons it enables across countries. The report also highlights six countries for which Vodafone was unable to disclose any statistics on warrants from the government or other requests: Romania, Qatar, Egypt, India, South Africa and Turkey.

By contrast, Vodafone's report is almost superfluous for some Western European countries, like Germany, where the government already publishes statistics on how many requests it sends phone companies.

Wiretapping of phones and accessing of call records for law-enforcement purposes is a decades-old and accepted practice even in the most open democracies. With backing from courts, police can request cooperation from phone companies to access communications.

But in developing countries like Congo, Ghana and Lesotho, Vodafone doesn't have the capability to support wiretapping, since governments haven't requested it.

By making its report public, together with a disclosure of requests for information, Vodafone is entering the international debate about balancing the rights of privacy against security. Rather than being stuck with responsibility and backlash when citizens realize their data has been scooped up without their knowledge, Vodafone decided it was time to push for a debate.

Vodafone's report comes one year after former NSA systems analyst Edward Snowden revealed that U.S. and other countries' intelligence agencies indiscriminately gather and store huge amounts of data from phone calls and Internet communications.

"Companies are recognizing they have a responsibility to disclose government access," Daniel Castro, senior analyst for the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation in Washington. "This is new."

Vodafone's report is also seen by some as an effort to turn the page on the company's embarrassing role in the protests that toppled Egyptian strongman Hosni Mubarak in 2011. As the protests raged, the government forced Vodafone to bombard its Egyptian subscribers with propaganda text messages. The company said it had no choice but to comply, but was severely criticized for its actions.

"They took a hard lesson there," said Cynthia Wong, a senior internet researcher at Human Rights Watch. "Even if the government is the ultimate problem, they realized they needed to take steps to mitigate harm to their users."

Civil liberties advocates applauded Vodafone for releasing the report and cracking open the debate, even as they expressed alarm at the infringements into civil liberties.

"For governments to access phone calls at the flick of a switch is unprecedented and terrifying," said Shami Chakrabarti, director of the human rights group Liberty, adding that the Snowden revelations showed the Internet was already being treated as "fair game."

"Bluster that all is well is wearing pretty thin —our analog laws need a digital overhaul," she said.

Civil liberties advocates weren't the only ones applauding Vodafone's actions. Norway's Telenor Group, which also has operations across Eastern Europe and Asia, offered support, noting governments have the ultimate responsibility to act.

In the U.S., Snowden's revelations focused particular attention on the role of Western technology and telecommunications firms, which stand accused of facilitating the mass surveillance by giving spies unrestricted access to their networks. Several Silicon Valley companies have since attempted to restore consumers' trust by publishing data on government surveillance.

The study comes at a time when other businesses are calling for a revamp of laws too outdated to stand up to the quickly changing telecommunications universe.

Executives in Silicon Valley, for example, have stepped up pressure on President Barack Obama to curb the U.S. government surveillance programs that collect information off the Internet.

Twitter Inc., LinkedIn Corp., AOL Inc., Google Inc., Apple Inc., Yahoo Inc., Facebook Inc. and Microsoft Corp. are pushing for tighter controls over electronic espionage — fearing that eavesdropping threatens the technology industry's financial livelihood.

"They want their customers to be able to trust them to store their data in a private and secure manner," Castro said.

The countries included in the report are: Albania, Australia, Belgium, the Czech Republic, Congo, Egypt, Fiji, France, Germany, Ghana, Greece, Hungary, India, Ireland, Italy, Kenya, Lesotho, Malta, Mozambique, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Portugal, Qatar, Romania, South Africa, Spain, Tanzania, Turkey and the U.K.

___

Associated Press Writers Danica Kirka and Raphael Satter in London and Jan M. Olsen in Copenhagen contributed to this report.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/31" rel="author">Associated Press</a>
The Associated Press (AP) is one of the largest and most trusted sources of independent newsgathering, supplying a steady stream of news to its members, international subscribers and commercial customers.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Money transactions via Bitcoin not safe
London, Nov 26 (IANS) Researchers have shown that money transactions via Bitcoin network do not protect user's IP address and it can be linked to the user's transactions in real-time.
 
 
Life-saving bacteria found in turkeys
New York, Nov 26 (IANS) The biological machinery needed to produce a potentially life-saving antibiotic is found in turkeys, researchers have found.
 
 
India to give business visa for 3-5 years for Saarc: Modi
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Wednesday said India will give business visa for three to five years for Saarc countries and called for making procedures simple and facilities better.
 
 
Save money on 'Twitter Offers'
New York, Nov 26 (IANS) Micro-blogging site Twitter has launched a new feature where retailers will tweet special offers that can be used to get money back on certain purchases.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Collective efforts more important in Saarc region: Modi
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Nowhere in the world are collective efforts more important than in south Asia, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said at the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (Saarc) Summit here...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Modi speaks of Mumbai attack anniversary at Saarc
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Wednesday recalled the horror of the 2008 Mumbai terror attack at the Saarc Summit and stressed on the need to combat "terrorism and trans-national crimes". "Today...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Money transactions via Bitcoin not safe
London, Nov 26 (IANS) Researchers have shown that money transactions via Bitcoin network do not protect user's IP address and it can be linked to the user's transactions in real-time. The team demonstrated that only a...
Read more on Business Balla
 
India can connect Saarc students through e-libraries: Modi
Kathmandu, Nov 26 (IANS) Prime Minister Narendra Modi Wednesday said India is prepared to connect students in the south Asian region through e-libraries. "IT has removed all barriers to quality education. India is...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Court orders Maradona to pay for slander victim's legal fees
Buenos Aires, Nov 26 (IANS) Famed Argentine ex-footballer Diego Maradona must pay the legal expenses of Shanghai Shenhua team coach Sergio Batista for alleging he took bribes from national players, an Argentine court...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Life-saving bacteria found in turkeys
New York, Nov 26 (IANS) The biological machinery needed to produce a potentially life-saving antibiotic is found in turkeys, researchers have found. "Our research group is certainly thankful for turkeys. The 'good...
Read more on Business Balla
 
Taylor Swift values Lorde friendship
Taylor Swift says Lorde and Lena Dunham as the ''most important'' people in her life at the moment. The 24-year-old musician really appreciates the friendship of the pair and insists it's great to have peers you like...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Susan Boyle: Catholic upbringing has made me single
Susan Boyle blames her single status on her Catholic parents' ''coded behaviour''. The 'Wild Horses' singer has revealed her mother and father's strong Christian beliefs have affected the way she approaches romantic...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Black Friday looks good for Kohl’s
Kohl’s has released their Black Friday 2014 advertisement flier. The big draw to Kohl’s for this year’s version of Black Friday is that the company will have over 500 deals in store. Kohl’s will start their Black...
Read more on Black Friday Countdown
 
Jennifer Aniston felt 'uncomfortable' filming Horrible Bosses 2
Jennifer Aniston felt ''uncomfortable'' filming scenes for 'Horrible Bosses 2'. The 45-year-old actress has admitted to feeling a little uncomfortable as she filmed some sexually provocative scenes with some extras for...
Read more on Movie Balla