California Teacher-Tenure Ruling Could Backfire On Conservatives

Jun 11 2014, 4:53pm CDT | by

Conservatives who cheered a California judge’s decision yesterday blocking that state’s public-school tenure rules should think twice before attempting to sue the teachers’ unions into submission elsewhere.

The history of judicial intervention in public school policy is rich with examples that have horrified and angered conservatives, including forced busing programs and long-running fights over court-overseen mandates to equalize per-pupil spending. In 1973, the U.S. Supreme Court came within one vote of establishing a constitutional right to equal funding that could have given judges the power to dictate school funding and tax policies nationwide.

So it’s worth looking at the tentative ruling by Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu in light of what it could mean for future plaintiffs, not the assault on teacher-union perks conservatives are so excited about now.

In the surpringly concise, 16-page ruling, Judge Treu – a Republican appointee – acknowledges the “intense political debate” over school policy and said it is “not this Court’s function to question the wisdom” of the state’s laws governing teacher employment. But he nevertheless struck down laws effectively granting California teachers tenure after less than two years and requiring school districts to lay off teachers in order of seniority. He also struck down dismissal statutes that granted teachers extraordinary power to challenge firings, in what the judge dubbed “uber due process.”

All these laws, passed at the behest of the powerful unions representing some 275,000 teachers  statewide had the effect of discriminating against poor and minority students, the judge wrote. He got there by applying the doctrine of strict scrutiny under the California state constitution, a method of analysis reserved for the most serious cases of discrimination that the U.S. Supreme Court refused to use in the 1973 school-funding decision mentioned above, San Antonio v. Rodriguez.

“The evidence is compelling,” he wrote. “Indeed, it shocks the conscience.”

The plaintiffs, financed by Silicon Valley entrepreneur David Welch, proved that the challenged laws “present a real and appreciable impact on students’ fundamental right of equality of education and that they impose a disproportionate burden on poor and minority students,” he said. The decision was based on California’s version of the 14th Amendment requiring equal protection under the laws, as well as a provision requiring the state to provide a “free school in every district.”

That phrase “fundamental right of equality of education” can be used in ways that will set conservative teeth on edge, however. For an example, look at the long-running case in New Jersey known as Abbott v. Burke.  The case, originally decided by the New Jersey Supreme Court in 1985, held that the New Jersey Constitution’s guarantee of “thorough and efficient” free schools meant the system of unequal funding through property taxes was discriminatory.

The final chapter heading on this web page says it all: The case is now referred to as Abbott XX. Or Abbott XXI, since the 20th iteration of Abbott ended, like all the others before it, with an impasse between the state’s legislative and judicial branches over how to equalize school funding. Each time the Supreme Court tells the  legislature to draft a law guaranteeing “substantially equivalent funding” for schools, the legislature passes a law that fails the Supreme Court’s test. The court ordered an immediate $246 million increase in funding for the 1997-98 school year, mandated early education programs, and ordered the legislature to fund a $9.8 billion building improvement program that the Abbott plaintiffs — represented by the Education Law Center backed by the state teachers union — still complained was inadequate and unconstitutional.

When Gov. Chris Christie signed a budget in June 2010 cutting school funding by $1.1 billion, the Abbott plaintiffs went back to court, where the judges ordered a $500 million increase for the 31 poor and minority school districts covered under Abbott. This year, the plaintiffs filed another motion arguing the Christie administration hasn’t followed the court-ordered formula.

Even Arne Duncan, the Obama administration’s Secretary of Education, praised the Vergara ruling as a “mandate” to fix “laws, practices and systems that fail to identify and support our best teachers and match them with our neediest students.”

But conservative activists who take up the cudgel of state constitutional guarantees of an equal public education should keep the New Jersey example in mind. If they succeed in breaking the teachers’ union, other activists might try to use the same tool to attack the tax bases of wealthy suburbs, crack zoning laws that have the de facto effect of creating segregated school districts and even dictate higher taxes to fund higher teacher salaries.

 
 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/30" rel="author">Forbes</a>
Forbes is among the most trusted resources for the world's business and investment leaders, providing them the uncompromising commentary, concise analysis, relevant tools and real-time reporting they need to succeed at work, profit from investing and have fun with the rewards of winning.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

US troops returning from Ebola mission to be quarantined
Washington, Oct 29 (IANS) US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel Wednesday approved a measure to place under a 21-day supervised isolation regimen all military service members returning from Ebola response efforts in West Africa.
 
 
Pakistan lodges protest with India over civilian death
Islamabad, Oct 29 (IANS) Pakistan Wednesday lodged a protest with India through diplomatic channels over alleged cross border firing that killed a 70-year-old man.
 
 
India ranked 142nd in ease of doing business
Washington, Oct 29 (IANS) India was ranked 142nd among 189 nations in ease of doing business in a new World Bank Group report, even as it found that the country set the pace for regulatory reform in South Asia in 2013-14.
 
 
Sierra Leone traditional leaders warned to contain Ebola disease
Freetown, Oct 29 (IANS) Residents in the northern region of Sierra Leone have welcomed a warning by President Ernest Bai Koroma calling on the traditional leaders of the north to contain the spread of the Ebola virus disease in their chiefdoms or risk the forfeiture of their crowns.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

US troops returning from Ebola mission to be quarantined
Washington, Oct 29 (IANS) US Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel Wednesday approved a measure to place under a 21-day supervised isolation regimen all military service members returning from Ebola response efforts in West...
Read more on Business Balla
 
10 killed in fresh Libyan clashes
Benghazi, Oct 29 (IANS) At least 10 people were killed Wednesday in violent street clashes between the Libyan army and armed Islamic groups in different parts of the eastern city of Benghazi, military and medical...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Kim Kardashian West thanks birthday boy Bruce
Kim Kardashian West has thanked her step-father Bruce Jenner for teaching her ''so much about life''. The 34-year-old star took to her Instagram account to post a nostalgic black and white picture of the pair together...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Ashton Kutcher's daughter has Twitter handle
Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis' daughter already has her own Twitter handle. The former 'That 70s Show' actors welcomed their first child, daughter Wyatt. into the world earlier this month and Ashton has confessed they...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Mike Tyson used same 'low-life dealer' as Robin Williams
Mike Tyson has claimed he and Robin Williams used to use the same ''low-life dealer''. The retired boxer has opened up about battling depression and mental illness and admitted he used to chat with the late Hollywood...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Pakistan lodges protest with India over civilian death
Islamabad, Oct 29 (IANS) Pakistan Wednesday lodged a protest with India through diplomatic channels over alleged cross border firing that killed a 70-year-old man. The civilian was killed in Rawalkot sector "due to...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
10 of a family killed in Egypt car crash
Cairo, Oct 29 (IANS) Ten members of a family were killed and 17 injured in a fatal car crash on a desert highway 80 km from here Wednesday, state media reported. The accident occurred as a private car carrying family...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
14 killed, 300 missing in Sri Lanka landslide (Roundup)
Colombo, Oct 29 (IANS) At least 14 people were killed and around 300 others are missing in a landslide in central Sri Lanka Wednesday as President Mahinda Rajapaksa directed the government to fully support rescue...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
IS executes 30 tribesmen in Iraq
Baghdad, Oct 29 (IANS) The Islamic State (IS) terrorist group executed more than 30 tribesmen in western Iraq Wednesday, as government forces continued their offensive against the extremist militants across the country...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Michael Caine appears in Christopher Nolan films 'without reading the script'
Sir Michael Caine agrees to appear in Christopher Nolan films without reading the script. The Oscar-winning actor has appeared in six films made by Nolan - the latest of which is new sci-fi thriller 'Interstellar' - and...
Read more on Movie Balla